Inhofe Point by Point Rebuttal to Senator Kerry 30 Minute Filibuster
On October 27, 2009, Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.) appeared before the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works to speak on behalf of the Kerry-Boxer cap-and-trade bill. Sen. Kerry spoke uncontested for 28 minutes, allowing no time for questions by members of the Committee.
The following is a line-by-line analysis of Sen. Kerry’s assertions. In reading through the document, one will see that Sen. Kerry is badly misinformed about the many of the key details and issues surrounding the climate change policy debate.
EPW Climate Hearings Day 1: Dem Divisions Show During Climate Hearing
Congress Daily: Dem Divisions Show During Climate Hearing – Tensions between the liberal and moderate wings of the Democratic Party over climate change legislation were previewed at today’s Senate Environment and Public Works Committee hearing.Senate Finance Chairman Max Baucus said he has “some concerns about the overall direction” of a 923-page cap-and-trade bill from Environment and Public Works Chairwoman Barbara Boxer and Foreign Relations Chairman John Kerry.”We cannot afford a first step that takes us further away from an achievable consensus,” Baucus said. “We could build that consensus here in this committee. If we don’t, we risk wasting another month, another year, another Congress, without taking a step forward to our future.” Baucus said he has “serious reservations” about the bill’s requirement that U.S. greenhouse gas emissions be reduced 20 percent below 2005 levels by 2020, a higher goal than the 17 percent reduction by 2020 target in a House-passed bill and the 14 percent level once suggested by President Obama. Baucus told reporters he did not have a specific target in mind, but said generally that some modifications will be needed. Boxer said afterwards Baucus might be convinced to support the bill’s 2020 target because the economic slump this year has reduced U.S. greenhouse gas emissions by 8 percent. “I think once he sees the fact that we’re already down 8 percent, that 20 percent target is way lower,” Boxer said. “So I think we’re going to be talking to them about that.” Baucus and Sen. Arlen Specter, D-Pa., also said the bill — unlike the House version — would not pre-empt EPA from regulating greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act. “It’s a pretty big point,” Specter said. “Let’s let Congress act on it. That’s really our job.” Others more on the left want to preserve what is currently in the Kerry-Boxer draft and may go down swinging.
Energy Daily: Baucus Has ‘Serious Reservations’ On Senate Climate Bill – Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus signaled Tuesday he has “serious reservations” about key provisions of Democratic climate change legislation before the Senate, saying the bill’s 2020 emissions cap and the lack of a provision to exempt greenhouse gases from regulation under the Clean Air Act could threaten committee approval of the measure. In a brief statement at a Senate Environment and Public Works Committee (EPW) hearing on the legislation (S. 1733), Baucus (Mont.), a moderate Democrat whose support is seen as crucial if the bill is to clear the Senate, expressed concern about the bill’s 2020 emissions-reduction target of 20 percent below a 2005 baseline and the lack of the Clean Air Act exemption in the bill.”I have some concerns about the overall direction of the bill before us today and whether it will lead us closer to or further away from passing climate change legislation,” Baucus said before hurrying away for a meeting on health care reform legislation… Arlen Specter (Pa.), another moderate Democratic member of the committee, also raised concerns about the absence of the Clean Air Act exemption. Specter said that without an exemption, industries falling under the bill’s emissions caps could not be sure they wouldn’t face additional regulation by EPA. That uncertainty, Specter said, could harden objections to the bill and threaten its passage.
Video and Transcript of Kerry 30 Minute Opening Statement
Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov Video and Transcript of Kerry 30 Minute Opening Statement at EPW Hearing Senator KERRY: Well, Madam Chairman, thank you very, very much. Thanks for the privilege of appearing before this committee. Senator Inhofe and all the members of the committee, many of whom I’ve met with individually, talking about this — […]
RR: EPA ‘Discussion Paper’ of Kerry-Boxer Is Incomplete
EPA refers to its 38-page document as “a discussion paper.” By contrast, Republicans provided Democrats in 2005 with 10,000 pages of analysis for the Clear Skies bill.
EPA’s paper fails to provide comprehensive analysis. There is no analysis of impacts on consumers, electricity prices, gasoline prices, food prices, households, different regions of the country, and industrial sectors of the economy.
EPA’s assumptions about CCS are seriously flawed. Kerry-Boxer could make CCS deployment less likely than Waxman-Markey. On page 14, EPA contends that fewer bonus allowances are available under Kerry-Boxer than Waxman-Markey because of its more stringent 2020 cap.
EPA ignores flaws in Waxman-Markey analysis. EPA states that, “Because of these many similarities and the relatively small differences between the two bills, it is likely that a full analysis of S. 1733 would show economic impacts very similar to H.R. 2454.” But EPA’s analysis of Waxman-Markey is incomplete. EPA rejected a request from Senators Inhofe and Voinovich to model more realistic assumptions about the growth of nuclear power, the availability of offsets, and the prospects for international action to reduce emissions.
EPA says cap-and-trade brings flexibility, but doesn’t model cap with Kerry-Boxer’s mandates. EPA states, “The cap-and-trade policy often is carefully crafted to afford sources numerous flexibilities that further decrease the costs of compliance, such as the option to purchase offsets from non-covered sources.” Yet Kerry-Boxer includes building and appliance efficiency standards, new source performance standards for coal-fired power plants and other sources. EPA failed to model the simultaneous adoption of cap-and-trade with command-and-control mandates.
RR: Acid Rain Myth, Part 2
In an attempt to undercut numerous economic analyses showing cap-and-trade of the greenhouse gas variety destroying jobs and raising energy prices, cap-and-trade supporters note the industry’s so-called “doomsday” cost estimates of the Acid Rain program in 1990. As two Senators recently wrote in the Washington Post, “Naysayers said the cost to business [from the Acid Rain program] would be more than $50 billion a year, but health and other benefits outweighed the costs 40 to 1.”
RR: Cap-and-Trade Destroys Jobs in Ohio and Michigan
Ohio
According to the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM), under Waxman-Markey, “Ohio jobs decline by 79,700 under low cost case and by 108,600 under high cost case. The primary cause of job losses would be lower industrial output due to higher energy prices, the high cost of complying with required emissions cuts, and greater competition from overseas manufacturers with lower energy costs.”
Michigan
According to NAM, under Waxman-Markey, “Michigan jobs decline by 66,600 under the low cost case and 90,800 under the high cost case. The primary cause of job losses is lower industrial output due to higher energy prices, the high cost of complying with required emissions cuts, and greater competition from overseas manufacturers with lower energy costs.”
RR: The Economy and the Stimulus Package
Posted by David Lungren, David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov: Inhofe EPW Rapid Response: The Economy and the Stimulus Package www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog President Obama promised to "save and create" 3.5 million jobs with the $787 billion stimulus package, but since it passed in February, the economy, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, has lost nearly 3 million jobs. In January, the […]
RR: Cap-and-Trade: Little to No Help on Foreign Oil Dependence
Myth: Cap-and-trade will break our dependence on foreign oil.
Fact: The EPA predicts cap-and-trade will barely make a dent in petroleum use.
Some proponents of cap-and-trade legislation argue that it will lead to a new era of energy independence. For example, Rep. Henry Waxman, a sponsor of the House cap-and-trade bill,[i] said that “one of the best ways to accomplish the overall goal is through what’s called a cap-and-trade mechanism…We won’t have to import so much gasoline and oil from a lot of countries that certainly don’t look out for our interests…”[ii]
But an EPA analysis indicates that the cap-and-trade portion of the bill[iii] – the most controversial part – would only very slightly reduce petroleum use (see the purple bar at the bottom of the chart on the left).[iv] The chart on the right shows EPA’s projection of greenhouse gas (GHG) abatement, heavily focused on electricity.
RR: Clear Skies analysis vs. Kerry-Boxer analysis
Posted by David Lungren, David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov Inhofe EPW Rapid Response: Clear Skies analysis vs. Kerry-Boxer "analysis" www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog Clear Skies Markup was delayed three times to accommodate the request of Democrats asking for more time. Despite complaints over lack of modeling data from the Administration, the Committee received over 10,000 pages of data, far more than […]
RR: Kerry-Boxer’s Bait and Switch: Electricity Consumers
Bait: “The vast majority of allowances will go to consumers to keep them whole.” — Barbara Boxer[i]
Switch: Allowances are insufficient and end early, leaving consumers to fend for themselves.
“[U]nder my plan of a cap and trade system, electricity rates would necessarily skyrocket…whatever the plants were, whatever the industry was, they would have to retrofit their operations. That will cost money. They will pass that money on to consumers.”[ii] — Candidate Barack Obama