Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
Inhofe EPW Rapid Response
Kerry-Boxer’s Bait and Switch: Electricity Consumers
Bait: "The vast majority of allowances will go to consumers to keep them whole." — Barbara Boxer[i]
Switch: Allowances are insufficient and end early, leaving consumers to fend for themselves.
"[U]nder my plan of a cap and trade system, electricity rates would necessarily skyrocket…whatever the plants were, whatever the industry was, they would have to retrofit their operations. That will cost money. They will pass that money on to consumers."[ii] — Candidate Barack Obama
Proponents of cap-and-trade, like President Obama, admit that their plan will cause electricity prices to increase.[iii] In fact, President Obama’s Budget Director, while head of the Congressional Budget Office, made the observation that "price increases would be essential to the success of a cap and trade program."[iv]
To counter this harsh reality, Senator Boxer has said that she plans to devote free allowances to "making consumers whole," like the House-passed Waxman-Markey bill does in the early years of the program. The problem with that promise is that Waxman-Markey would not make consumers whole by giving some allowances to local distribution companies "for the benefit of consumers."[v] Those allowances peak in the first year of the program, are reduced immediately and are gone completely by 2030. A study by The National Black Chamber of Commerce (NBCC)[vi] examined the Waxman-Markey bill out to 2050. NBCC found that as free allowances decrease, electricity rates increase even more. The graph[vii] to the left demonstrates.
While the Kerry-Boxer bill does not yet specify the precise allocations (there are blanks in the bill), Senator Boxer’s staff has said the bill probably will be modeled after the House Waxman-Markey bill.[viii] The basic problem of cap-and-trade, no matter how the various allowances are allocated, is that the cap on emissions gets more stringent as years pass, so there are fewer allocations available to ensure consumers (and other groups) are adequately protected. (You cannot shrink a pie and make sure everyone would get as big a slice as from the original pie.) Waxman-Markey does not even try to reduce electricity bills by giving free allowances to local distribution companies past 2030.
The bottom line: Saying consumers will be made whole and then removing protection is a classic bait and switch.
[i] "Climate Bill Would Ease Energy Costs, Senator Says," The Washington Post, October 2, 2009.
[ii] Interview with the San Francisco Chronicle, January 2008. See video here: http://www.breitbart.tv/?p=211663&comments=1.
[iii] See, e.g., "Consumer, Not Polluters, Pay for Cap-and-Trade" RPC fact sheet. Available here: http://rpc.senate.gov/public/_files/EnergyFactSheetsPollutersPayCapandTrade.pdf.
[iv] Peter R. Orszag, "Implications of a Cap-and-Trade Program for Carbon Dioxide Emissions," Testimony before the Committee on Finance, U.S. Senate, April 24, 2008. http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/91xx/doc9134/04-24-Cap_Trade_Testimony.pdf.
[v] It is unclear what this language from the bill means; it may not require a rebate back to the consumer.
[vi] "Impact on the Economy of the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 (H.R. 2454)," CRA International, August 2009. Available here: http://www.nationalbcc.org/images/stories/documents/CRA_Waxman-Markey_Aug2008_Update_Final.pdf.
In addition, analysis by the Energy Information Agency (EIA), the government agency dedicated to providing energy statistics and projections, showed that electricity prices would increase by as much as 15.3 percent by 2020 and 77.4 percent by 2030, a year after Waxman-Markey’s free allowances to protect consumers cease altogether. (EIA did not analyze effects past 2030.) "Energy Market and Economic Impacts of H.R. 2454, the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009," Energy Information Agency, August 2009. Available here: http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/servicerpt/hr2454/pdf/sroiaf(2009)05.pdf, Table ES-1, p. xi.
[vii] Creator of chart: John Stoody, Office of Senator Bond.
[viii] See "Climate Bill Would Ease Energy Costs, Senator Says," The Washington Post, October 2, 2009.
###