RR: Acid Rain vs. Carbon Cap and Trade
Authors Laurie Williams and Allen Zabel, career employees of the Environmental Protection Agency who support instituting a carbon fee to address climate change, examine what they call the “Acid Rain Myth.” As the authors explain, “those who champion using cap-and-trade to address climate change claim that it has been ‘proven’ to work in the U.S. Acid Rain program. However, this assertion ignores crucial distinctions between the challenges we faced in 1990 with Acid Rain and the challenges we face today with global warming.”
As the following highlights from the study make abundantly clear, the experience of the Acid Rain program simply cannot be compared to cap and trade for GHG:
“Most importantly, the success of the Acid Rain program did not depend on replacing the vast majority of our existing energy infrastructure with new infrastructure in a relatively short time.”
RR: Kerry-Boxer’s Bait and Switch: Manufacturing
Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov Inhofe EPW Rapid Response Kerry-Boxer’s Bait and Switch: Manufacturing www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog Bait: "The biggest priority is softening the blow on our trade sensitive industries” – Barbara Boxer Switch: Allowances are insufficient and end early, leaving workers to fend for themselves. "It makes no sense for a plant to be […]
RR: Cap-and-Trade, with or without Nuclear Title, is an Energy Tax
Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov Inhofe EPW Rapid Response Cap-and-Trade, with or without Nuclear Title, is an Energy Tax www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog Despite the new national energy tax that cap-and-trade proposals will impose on the American people, its sponsors are hoping that adding a more robust nuclear title will mask the higher taxes and co-opt support from […]
RR: Consumers, Not Polluters, Pay for Cap-and-Trade
Posted By: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov Inhofe EPW Rapid Response Consumers, Not Polluters, Pay for Cap-and-Trade www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog Myth: "Polluters" will pay for cap-and-trade Fact: Consumers will pay for cap-and-trade One of the new talking points for proponents of cap-and-trade is that it makes polluters pay. "At a time of great fiscal challenges, this legislation […]
RR: U.S. Cap-and-Trade Without International Action: All Pain and No Gain
The purpose of global warming legislation, including cap-and-trade, is to reduce emissions and concentration of greenhouse gasses (GHGs). The American Clean Energy and Security Act includes cap-and-trade to limit U.S. emissions unilaterally, without regard to whether other countries take similar measures. Action by the U.S. alone, however, would not significantly reduce global concentrations of GHGs – failing to achieve its environmental objective – while inflicting American families with higher energy costs and fewer jobs.
As of 2005, 20 nations combined to release more than 70 percent of global emissions.[i] Those 20 countries include many developing countries whose emissions since 1990 have increased dramatically, including China (up 100.8%), India (68.1%), Brazil (47.3%), Indonesia (78.0%), Iran (131.3%), South Korea (78.6%) and South Africa (26.4%).[ii] By contrast U.S. emissions have increased by only 16.6 percent in that time frame, while the U.S. is emitting less per unit of economic outcome.[iii] Since 1990, the share of developing countries’ emissions has increased, while developed countries’ share has declined.
RR: Incomplete CBO Estimate Does Not Include All Costs of Cap-and-Trade
On June 19, 2009, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released a letter and supplemental report about the American Clean Energy Security Act of 2009.[i] This analysis, which only looked at a portion of the costs of cap-and-trade, is being used by some to deceive the public into believing that this vast economy-altering bill would cost U.S. households only a “net average” of $175 in the year 2020.
In its document, CBO attempts to estimate how government redistribution (by giving away allowances and auction proceeds) will protect taxpayers, including those who were promised by the President that their taxes would not increase by a single dime.[ii] CBO estimates an average gross cost of $890 per household in 2020 with the top quintile paying an average of $1,380.[iii] After a generous assumption of an enormous government run wealth redistribution scheme via auction proceeds and free allowances, CBO projects a net average cost of $175 per household on average, with a middle quintile facing the highest net costs of $340.[iv] That figure, however, is only the budgetary cost of the scheme per household, not a comprehensive economic analysis. Moreover, it examines only one year of the program, a year that CBO optimistically assumes is relatively low cost, and after the expensive transition years.
As a result, CBO’s estimate really only captures some of the costs of cap-and-trade, as the report acknowledges.
RR: Cap-and-Trade Destroys Jobs
Promise: “But the bulk of our efforts must focus on unleashing a new, clean-energy economy that will … cut our carbon pollution by about 80 percent by 2050, and create millions of new jobs right here in America[.]” — President Barack Obama, April 22, 2009 (speech in Newton, Iowa)
Reality: Cap-and-trade will destroy millions of jobs overall, even if it does create some green jobs. Numerous studies have analyzed the effect of cap-and-trade legislation[i] and concluded that it would result in millions of fewer jobs overall, even if it does create some green jobs. The Energy Information Administration (EIA), the government agency in charge of providing official energy statistics, concluded that cap-and-trade could result in up to 2.3 million fewer jobs in 2030 and up to 800,000 fewer manufacturing jobs in 2030, after including new green jobs.[ii]
The National Black Chamber of Commerce (NBCC) commissioned a study by Charles River Associates (CRA) that concluded cap-and-trade would result in about 1.5 million fewer jobs in 2015 and 3.6 million fewer jobs in 2050, after new green jobs were considered[iii] (graph below[iv]).
The Hill: Inhofe: Dems Understate Nation’s Resources
This week as the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee kicks off hearings on the Kerry-Boxer cap-and-trade bill, one argument Democrats will spout over and over is that America is a nation poor in natural resources. As seen from the quotes below, we are shamed into the belief that America possesses too little and consumes too much:
“With 3 percent of the world’s oil reserves, the U.S. cannot drill its way to energy security,” then-presidential nominee Barack Obama wrote on his campaign website in 2008. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) stated, “All told, the U.S. has only 1.6 percent of world’s known oil supply.” And in the Senate, Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) added, “The math is simple: America has just 3 percent of the world’s oil reserves, but Americans use a quarter of its oil.”
NRO Editorial: Scrap the Cap
Hear that? It’s the sound of another 1,000-page bill hitting desks all over Washington. Sens. John Kerry and Barbara Boxer have introduced the “Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act,” which is the Senate equivalent of the Waxman-Markey cap-and-trade bill that passed the House earlier this year. Compared to Waxman-Markey (1,428 pages), the Kerry-Boxer bill (925 pages) is a model of concision. However, it is expected to grow as Senate Democrats try to buy Republican votes with token support for nuclear energy and offshore drilling. Skeptical senators should not take the bait.
Sen. Jim Inhofe, the ranking Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, has blown the whistle on the Democrats’ strategy, which involves targeting Republicans such as John McCain and Lindsey Graham. We’ve been down this road before: Last year, when the GOP was winning the debate over offshore drilling, Graham and four other Republicans nearly snatched defeat from the jaws of victory by signing onto a watered-down compromise that would have opened only a tiny sliver of the coast for drilling in exchange for a batch of new subsidies for renewable energy, including nuclear power.
Inhofe Works to Fix Road Funding (Tulsa World)
WASHINGTON – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe says the financial hit suffered by Oklahoma’s transportation program this month was $15 million more than expected.
By the end of the week, the Oklahoma Republican hopes to have a deal in place to at least halt that downward trend.
“Oklahoma loses on this,” he said.
At issue is whether Inhofe and other top congressional players on transportation can work out an agreement on a short-term extension, possibly six months, of the current transportation programs.
If they fail, they may have to settle for another month-long resolution like the one passed in September.