Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
Inhofe EPW Rapid Response
Kerry-Boxer’s Bait and Switch: Manufacturing
Bait: "The biggest priority is softening the blow on our trade sensitive industries” – Barbara Boxer
Switch: Allowances are insufficient and end early, leaving workers to fend for themselves.
"It makes no sense for a plant to be closed here because we follow international climate rules and open up in another country that does not follow them[.]" – Sherrod Brown[ii]
As explained previously,[iii] enacting a unilateral cap-and-trade bill will not help the environment and may even increase emissions of carbon dioxide worldwide. Moreover cap-and-trade would put our economy, and especially our manufacturing sector, at a competitive disadvantage versus countries that do not have a cap on emissions.
This phenomenon is well understood, including among some Democrats in the Senate. Senator Brown was one of 10 Democrat Senators who sent a letter to President Obama seeking his help in advocating for sufficient support for the manufacturing sector in any cap-and-trade bill.[iv] The help is important because all manufacturers will face higher input costs, especially for energy, and many will have to comply directly with the new regulations.
While S. 1733, The Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act (Kerry-Boxer bill), does not yet specify the precise allocations (there are blanks in the bill), Senator Boxer’s staff has said the bill will be modeled after H.R. 2454, The American Clean Energy and Security Act (Waxman-Markey).[v] That bill provides some help in the early years of the program for energy intensive, trade exposed sectors of the economy. As this chart[vi] shows, however, that help quickly evaporates, peaking in the early years and ending completely by 2035.
Waxman-Markey would be a disaster for manufacturing, even with the free allocations included in the bill. Analysis by the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) shows that economic growth would slow (GDP losses of up to $3.1 trillion from 2012-2030), employment would suffer (up to 2.44 million fewer jobs in 2030), and industrial production would decrease by up to 6.5 percent, which "would make it harder to keep the U.S. economy out of recession or [produce] sluggish growth insufficient to restore job growth."[vii] Moreover, the NAM reported that manufacturing employment would be especially hard hit (up to 740,000 fewer manufacturing jobs in 2030).[viii]
The Kerry-Boxer bill seems to recognize that workers will lose their jobs as a result of the bill because it provides, as the Waxman-Markey bill did, for assistance to displaced workers.[ix]
The bottom line: Promising that workers will be protected and then dropping protection for the manufacturing sector over time is a classic bait and switch.
[i]
Senator Boxer in Environment and Public Works Hearing, July 16, 2009. See coverage of comments here: http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=850753f9-802a-23ad-48ea-b618f97ee450.
[ii]
"CLIMATE: Key Senate votes hinges on trade protections – Brown" E&E, October 1, 2009. Available here: http://www.eenews.net/eenewspm/2009/10/01/1.
[iii]
"U.S. Cap-and-Trade Without International Action: All Pain and No Gain," RPC Energy Facts, July 10, 2009. Available here: http://rpc.senate.gov/public/_files/EnergyFactsInternationalAction.pdf.
[iv]
Letter signed by Senators Brown (D-OH), Stabenow (D-MI), Feingold (D-WI), Levin (D-MI), Bayh (D-IN), Casey (D-PA), Byrd (D-WV), Specter (D-PA), Rockefeller (D-WV), and Franken (D-MN). Available here: http://brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press_releases/release/?id=AD9CC0FA-53C2-442C-AB20-EEE0A7572F02.
[v]
See "Climate Bill Would Ease Energy Costs, Senator Says," The Washington Post, October 2, 2009. Available here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/01/AR2009100103908.html?hpid=sec-politics.
[vi]
Chart by: John Stoody, Office of Senator Bond. Sources: H.R. 2454 and Peterson Institute for International Economics, 2009.
[vii]
"Analysis of the Waxman-Markey Bill "The American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009," conducted by Science Applications International for the American Council for Capital Formation and the National Association of Manufacturers, pp. 4-5. Available here: http://www.accf.org/media/dynamic/3/media_387.pdf.
[viii]
[ix]
See S. 1733, Secs. 311-313.