Posted by David Lungren, David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
Inhofe EPW Rapid Response:
Clear Skies analysis vs. Kerry-Boxer "analysis"
Clear Skies
- Markup was delayed three times to accommodate the request of Democrats asking for more time.
- Despite complaints over lack of modeling data from the Administration, the Committee received over 10,000 pages of data, far more than Congress received during the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments.
- 24 hearings were held by the EPW Committee on multi-emissions issues.
- Majority and minority staff were informed of the Committee’s schedule and focus on Clear Skies on November 15, 2004.
- Bipartisan staff briefings on the legislation were provided by the Administration and industry and environmental organizations.
- Multiple member to member meetings and discussions occurred.
- Daily bipartisan staff negotiations occurred for five weeks.
- Due to specific requests for a process to develop compromise legislation, the business meeting was delayed two weeks so that extensive negotiations could occur.
- Three bipartisan member meetings were held to discuss a path forward. Numerous one-on-one meetings between chairman and ranking member of air subcommittee.
Kerry-Boxer
- No comprehensive economic analysis of the bill. EPA provided a 38-page narrative to the committee.
- EPA did not do modeling runs on key issues, such as the availability of offsets, nuclear power, and international action by China and India.
- The analysis will not be helpful in providing a comprehensive understanding of the bill’s economic impacts jobs and on family budgets.