OMB Memo: Serious Economic Impact Likely From EPA CO2 Rules…In Case You Missed It
WASHINGTON (Dow Jones)–U.S. regulation of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide “is likely to have serious economic consequences” for businesses small and large across the economy, a White House memo warned the Environmental Protection Agency earlier this year.
The nine-page document also undermines the EPA’s reasoning for a proposed finding that greenhouse gases are a danger to public health and welfare, a trigger for new rules.
The memo, an amalgamation of government agencies’ comments sent from the Office of Management and Budget to the EPA, is in stark contrast to the official position presented by President Barack Obama and his Cabinet officials. It is likely to give critics of greenhouse-gas regulation ammunition in their political salvos against the administration.
EPW POLICY BEAT: ACID RAIN REDUX
According to today’s Los Angeles Times, in an article headlined, “Buzzwords: Remaking Obama’s Lexicon,” marketing and public opinion gurus are shunning the term “cap-and-trade,” because it’s “confusing.” “Now when Obama talks about forcing companies to bid at auction for the right to emit greenhouse gases,” the Times reports, “he is more apt to mention ‘market-based’ proposals and ‘clean energy jobs,’ hinting at a rich new employment source.”
We hope this semantic shift prompts an end to the inapt comparisons between the 1990 Acid Rain Program and cap-and-trade for carbon-but we have our doubts. As we’ve noted before, Laurie Williams and Allen Zabel, career employees of the Environmental Protection Agency, who support instituting a carbon fee to address climate change, wrote in a recent paper about the “Acid Rain Myth.” “Those who champion using cap-and-trade to address climate change claim that it has been ‘proven’ to work in the U.S. Acid Rain program,” they wrote. “However, this assertion ignores crucial distinctions between the challenges we faced in 1990 with Acid Rain and the challenges we face today with global warming.”
WSJ Editorial: Carbon Reality, Again
It’s turning out that the biggest problem with carbon taxes is political reality. Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has just announced he will delay implementing his trademark cap-and-trade emissions trading proposal until at least 2011. Mr. Rudd’s March proposal would have imposed total carbon permit costs (taxes) of 11.5 billion Australian dollars (US$8.5 billion) in the first two years, starting in 2010. This would have increased consumer prices by about 1.1% and shaved 0.1% off annual GDP growth until at least 2050, according to Australia’s Treasury. Support has fallen among business groups and individuals who earlier professed enthusiasm for Aussie cap and trade. Green gains were negligible; Australia accounts for only 1.5% of global greenhouse gas emissions.
Senator John Barrasso: Environmental Group Will Sue Small Business
The Center for Biological Diversity confirmed what I have long feared. In comments made to the Wall Street Journal the special interest group stated they will sue for the regulation of small emitters under the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Air Act.
Kassie Siegel, director of the Center for Biological Diversity’s Climate Law Institute, was quoted in the Wall Street Journal saying her group is prepared to sue for regulation of smaller emitters if the EPA stops at simply large emitters.
Special interest groups around the country are scheming to sue the EPA to prosecute hospitals, farms, nursing homes, commercial buildings and any other small emitter of greenhouse gasses. These regulations are a dangerous loose cannon in the wrong hands.
In Case You Missed It: EPA Nominee Suggests New CO2 Rules May Expose Small Emitters
WASHINGTON — New federal greenhouse gas emission regulation could expose a raft of smaller emitters to litigation, a nominee for a key post in the Environmental Protection Agency told lawmakers Thursday.
The potential for smaller emitters to be regulated under the Clean Air Act is one reason why business groups warn that EPA regulation of greenhouse gases could create a cascade of legal and regulatory challenges across a much broader array of sectors. The Obama administration has said that isn’t their intent.
Regina McCarthy, nominated to be EPA’s Director of Air and Radiation, told lawmakers that even while the government has flexibility in setting the threshold of emitting facilities to be regulated, she acknowledges the risk of lawsuits to challenge those levels for smaller emitters. Ms. McCarthy’s office is responsible for drafting federal emission rules.
EPW FACT OF THE DAY: ‘IF A TREE FALLS IN THE FOREST…’
“If a tree falls in the forest, and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?” The philosopher George Berkeley once pondered this question. Today, we wonder the same about Al Gore’s ambitious, 3-year, $300 million media blitz to convince the public that climate change is something they should care about. As Gore explained with all his might to the Washington Post:
“This climate crisis is so interwoven with habits and patterns that are so entrenched, the elected officials in both parties are going to be timid about enacting the bold changes that are needed until there is a change in the public’s sense of urgency in addressing this crisis. I’ve tried everything else I know to try. The way to solve this crisis is to change the way the public thinks about it.”
The Hill’s Congress Blog: EPA’s Proposed Rule on RFS
Posted by: Matt_Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202)224-9797 EPA’s Proposed Rule on RFS (Sen. Jim Inhofe) May 06, 2009 Link To Blog Post Yesterday, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) initiated a draft rule for implementing the renewable fuels standard, as mandated by the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007. The act requires producers to blend 36 billion […]
Samuelson: The Bias Against Oil and Gas
Considering the brutal recession and the widespread warnings of a feeble recovery, you’d expect the Obama administration to be obsessed with job creation. And so it is, say the president and his supporters. The trouble is that there’s at least one glaring exception to their claims: the oil and natural-gas industries. The Obama administration is biased against them—a bias that makes no sense on either economic or energy grounds. Almost everyone loves to hate Big Oil (the Exxons and Chevrons), and even small oil, but promoting domestic drilling is simply common sense.
THE FEDS AND ‘THE GREAT MULTITUDE’
In 1896, Henry Ford constructed his first horseless carriage, which he sold in order to finance work on an improved model. Shortly thereafter, in 1903, Ford incorporated the Ford Motor Company, proclaiming, “I will build a car for the great multitude.” Which is precisely what he did: in October 1908, he offered the Model T for $950. EPW Policy Beat had occasion to revisit this snippet of Americana after listening to an NPR interview today (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=103582546) with EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson. If there were any doubt about the Obama Administration’s grand designs for the auto sector, it was removed today. For it appears that the federal government will be taking up Ford’s noble aspiration: to build and design cars “for the great multitude.”
In Case You Missed It… The Oklahoman Editorial: Climate change legislation carries a hefty price tag
CONGRESSIONAL Democrats rolled out climate change legislation last week. The rumble that followed was the sound of party moderates and conservatives heading for the hills. That’s what you get when your proposal to limit carbon output, a so-called “cap-and-trade” plan, comes with a $1.9 trillion tax increase over eight years, raising regular Americans’ tax bills by $2,000 a year. Not even the presence of former Vice President Al Gore at the roll-out hearing slowed the stampede. That’s because the carbon-limiting proposal will hit every American’s wallet or pocketbook — notwithstanding President Barack Obama’s promise not to raise taxes on people earning less than $250,000 a year. The conservative Heritage Foundation says the cap-and-trade plan will be no respecter of income.