Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov

According to today’s Los Angeles Times, in an article headlined, "Buzzwords: Remaking Obama’s Lexicon," marketing and public opinion gurus are shunning the term "cap-and-trade," because it’s "confusing."  "Now when Obama talks about forcing companies to bid at auction for the right to emit greenhouse gases," the Times reports, "he is more apt to mention ‘market-based’ proposals and ‘clean energy jobs,’ hinting at a rich new employment source." 

We hope this semantic shift prompts an end to the inapt comparisons between the 1990 Acid Rain Program and cap-and-trade for carbon-but we have our doubts.   As we’ve noted before, Laurie Williams and Allen Zabel, career employees of the Environmental Protection Agency, who support instituting a carbon fee to address climate change, wrote in a recent paper about the "Acid Rain Myth."  "Those who champion using cap-and-trade to address climate change claim that it has been ‘proven’ to work in the U.S. Acid Rain program," they wrote.  "However, this assertion ignores crucial distinctions between the challenges we faced in 1990 with Acid Rain and the challenges we face today with global warming." 

One such crucial distinction is the size of the respective allowance markets.  According to a presentation by Edison Mission Group, the value of the market for SO2 and NOx allowances pales in comparison to that forecasted for CO2.  As Edison Mission’s numbers attest, the monumental difference in value is a fact that convincingly disproves the shallow carbon-acid rain analogy:

America‘s Climate Security Act of 2007 (Lieberman-Warner)

– 5.7 MMM ton 2012 cap @ $25/ton = $145 billion

Acid Rain Program (SO2)

– 9 MM ton annual allocation @$350 ton = $3.2 billion

SIP call NOx trading program

– 550 k ton annual allocation @775/ton = $430 MM

###