Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202)224-9797
In Case You Missed It…
The Oklahoman
Editorial: Climate change legislation carries a hefty price tag
April 29, 2009
CONGRESSIONAL Democrats rolled out climate change legislation last week. The rumble that followed was the sound of party moderates and conservatives heading for the hills.
That’s what you get when your proposal to limit carbon output, a so-called "cap-and-trade” plan, comes with a $1.9 trillion tax increase over eight years, raising regular Americans’ tax bills by $2,000 a year. Not even the presence of former Vice President Al Gore at the roll-out hearing slowed the stampede.
That’s because the carbon-limiting proposal will hit every American’s wallet or pocketbook — notwithstanding President Barack Obama’s promise not to raise taxes on people earning less than $250,000 a year. The conservative Heritage Foundation says the cap-and-trade plan will be no respecter of income.
The proposal unveiled last week takes 648 pages to detail a system that would cap the amount of greenhouse gases companies can emit. It would require reductions in carbon dioxide produced by burning fossil fuels and five other greenhouse gases by 20 percent from 2005 levels by 2020 and 83 percent by the middle of the century. It would allow businesses to buy and sell carbon permits, depending on how much of it they produce. Of course, consumers ultimately would pay any increase in any company’s cost of doing business, such as a new government carbon permit — hence Heritage’s $2,000-per-household estimate.
Gore told lawmakers that differences over the new legislation are "partisan” and he renewed his claim that global warming is a "dire and growing threat.”
Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich said the bill would tax Americans "into living lives that the government wants them to live.” He said that "instead of opening up America’s vast resources of oil, natural gas and coal, this bill guarantees that we will remain reliant upon OPEC if we want to continue to drive cars, heat our homes and run our appliances.”
Looks like a bruising fight brewing in Congress, which is fitting. There should be a national conversation before the economy is further saddled and before major changes are forced on the American way of life.
No matter how many times Gore and others say the science is settled on human-caused global warming, it’s not. As unsettled is whether draconian, economy-encumbering measures will do any good with China and India running their economies at full throttle. Gore says those countries will follow the United States’ lead on global warming, but we don’t believe it.
So, bring on the debate. The timing is good, with the midterm congressional election campaigns on the horizon, which will ensure elected officials are listening to the folks back home.
Related Links:
Inhofe Earth Day Challenge: Focus Scarce Resources on Achievable Environmental Solutions
Inhofe-Bond Issue Warning on Green Jobs
Inhofe Says EPA Endangerment Finding Will Destroy Jobs, Harm Consumers
###