A Closer Look at Defeat of Australia Climate Bill
After a short (and much needed) break, EPW Policy Beat is back (as if anyone, at least in the waning days of August, really cares). After cleaning out in-boxes and taking stock of the last three weeks, it occurred to us that, as the siren calls of August recess rang out, several notable events occurred that were lost in the mad rush to leave town. These were events, upon closer inspection, that could have ramifications for the climate change debate expected in the Senate this fall. We plan to focus on them in the next few days. Our first installment covers the (welcome) defeat of cap-and-trade in the Australian Senate.
First, some background. After his election in 2007, Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd fulfilled a campaign promise to ratify the Kyoto Protocol. Then earlier this year, he proposed a cap-and-trade plan, dubbed the “Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme,” or CPRS, to reduce Australia’s emissions. The CPRS requires reductions between a range of 5 and 15 percent below 2000 levels by 2020. The CPRS covers 75 percent of Australia’s emissions, and auctions 70 percent of allowances, moving to a full auction over time. The proceeds of the auction would accrue to households to mitigate the costs of the CPRS.
According to Sen. Penny Wong, who serves as the Rudd government’s Minister for Climate Change and Water, the CPRS “is a highly complex reform and like all serious action on climate change, it is not without cost. But we know that for Australia, and indeed the world, the cost of not acting is far greater than the cost of responsible action now.” Link
Just What The Doctor Ordered: Health Care Could Make Climate Change Legislation “Unlikely”
The Washington Post asked politicians, academics and others whether the health-care debate has made it unlikely that climate change legislation will be passed in the near future. Below is Senator Inhofe’s response posted on the Post website.
SEN. JAMES M. INHOFE (R-Okla.):
As lawmakers return to Washington and assess the fiery backlash of constituent opposition to government-run health care, those mired in the thick of the climate change debate are wondering: What does it all mean for us?
The warring factions over climate policy should step back and try to discern whether constituents are signaling a more basic distrust of new government schemes. Polling data from the past several months indicates that such public distrust is real, deep and widespread. This means the Democrats’ government-run, cap-and-trade scheme — in fact, an energy tax that extends into every corner of American life — now faces an even higher hurdle, including growing opposition from many Democrats in the Senate. Such distrust will only grow if Democrats insist, as they did in the House, on crafting climate legislation in their inner sanctums, with no time for serious public input and debate. And this is exactly the course being drawn in the Senate.
Still, Washington’s appetite for spending, taxing and regulating — cap-and trade contains elements of each — is boundless. So, despite having public opinion on our side, those opposed to cap-and-trade are facing a monumental battle this fall in the Senate. There will be a mad race for 60 votes, and the outcome will reverberate beyond 2010.
Former Sen. Wirth Joins Anti-Cap-And-Tax Chorus
Aug. 18 (Bloomberg) — Cap-and-trade legislation to limit U.S. carbon dioxide emissions has “gotten out of control” and needs to be scaled back in Congress, said former Democratic Senator Timothy Wirth.
“The Republicans are right — it’s a cap-and-tax bill,” Wirth, a climate-change negotiator during President Bill Clinton’s administration, said in an Aug. 14 interview. “That’s what it is because they are raising revenue to do all sorts of things, especially to take care of the coal industry, and it makes no sense.”
A system to cap carbon emissions and then create a market for the trading of pollution allowances is the centerpiece of President Barack Obama’s proposal to fight global warming. Wirth, who helped craft a successful emissions-trading market two decades ago that cut sulfur-dioxide pollution causing acid rain, is among Democrats questioning House-passed legislation set to be taken up next month in the Senate.
“I’m not critical of cap-and-trade,” said Wirth, head of the UN Foundation, a philanthropy established in 1998 with $1 billion from medial mogul Ted Turner. “But it has to be used in a targeted and disciplined way, and what has happened is it’s gotten out of control.”
Wirth, who represented Colorado in the Senate, says the House-passed plan is “too broad across the economy.” Instead of capping carbon pollution generally, the measure should focus solely on coal-fired power plants, he said.
Dem Senators Say “Let’s Wait On Passing an Energy Tax.”
Aug. 14 (Bloomberg) — The U.S. Senate should abandon efforts to pass legislation curbing greenhouse-gas emissions this year and concentrate on a narrower bill to require use of renewable energy, four Democratic lawmakers say.
“The problem of doing both of them together is that it becomes too big of a lift,” Senator Blanche Lincoln of Arkansas said in an interview last week. “I see the cap-and-trade being a real problem.”
The resistance by Lincoln and her Senate colleagues undercuts President Barack Obama’s effort to win passage of legislation that would cap carbon dioxide emissions and establish a market for trading pollution allowances, said Peter Molinaro, the head of government affairs for Midland, Michigan- based Dow Chemical Co., which supports the measure.
“Doing these energy provisions by themselves might make it more difficult to move the cap-and-trade legislation,” said Molinaro, who is based in Washington. “In this town if you split two measures, usually the second thing never gets done.”
The House passed cap-and-trade legislation in June.
BLOOMBERG: Australian Senate Rejects Rudd’s Cap and Trade Emissions Plan
Australia’s Senate rejected the government’s climate-change legislation, forcing Prime Minister Kevin Rudd to amend the bill or call an early election.
Senators voted 42 to 30 against the law, which included plans for a carbon trading system similar to one used in Europe. Australia, the world’s biggest coal exporter, was proposing to reduce greenhouse gases by between 5 percent and 15 percent of 2000 levels in the next decade.
Rudd, who needs support from seven senators outside the government to pass laws through the upper house, can resubmit the bill after making amendments. A second rejection after a three-month span would give him a trigger to call an election.
“We may lose this fight, but this issue will not go away,” Climate Change Minister Penny Wong told the Senate in Canberra. “Australia cannot afford for climate change to be unfinished business.”
Five members from the Australian Greens party sought bigger cuts to emissions while the opposition coalition and independent Senator Nick Xenophon wanted to wait for further studies on the plan’s impact on the economy.
Boxer, Baucus headed for turf war over cap-and-trade bill
Two powerful Senate panels are at odds over which will be the lead author on perhaps the most critical piece of the global warming bill.
Both the Environment and Public Works Committee and the Finance Committee are staking claim to the distribution of what is projected to be hundreds of billions of dollars in emission allowances for a range of industries, adding another layer of complexity to a legislative debate already rife with trap doors.
For now, the leaders of the two committees are playing nice — at least publicly. They say they will work together on the legislation, and any disputes ultimately will get decided by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.).
But sources on and off Capitol Hill say Reid wants nothing to do with a parliamentary struggle that pits EPW Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) against Finance Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.), and he is pleading with them to resolve any differences should the legislation get the green light for a floor vote later this year.
NYTIMES: Climate Bill Is Threatened by Senators
WASHINGTON – Ten moderate Senate Democrats from states dependent on coal and manufacturing sent a letter to President Obama on Thursday saying they would not support any climate change bill that did not protect American industries from competition from countries that did not impose similar restraints on climate-altering gases.
The letter warned that strong actions to limit emissions of carbon dioxide and other heat-trapping gases would add to the cost of goods like steel, cement, paper and aluminum. Unless other countries adopt similar emission limits, the senators warned, jobs will migrate overseas and foreign manufacturers will have a decided cost advantage.
EPW Committee Hearings Expose Costs of Cap-and-Trade Legislation
Inhofe Aug. 6, 2009 Hearing Statement: What We Have Learned from EPW Global Warming Hearings: Madame Chairman, thank you for holding this hearing today. This is the last hearing on climate change before the August recess, so I think it’s appropriate to take stock of what we’ve learned. Madame Chairman, since you assumed the gavel, this committee has held over thirty hearings on climate change. With testimony from numerous experts and officials from all over the country, these hearings explored various issues associated with cap-and-trade-and I’m sure my colleagues learned a great deal from them. But over the last two years, it was not from these, at times, arcane and abstract policy discussions that we got to the essence of cap-and-trade. No, it was the Democrats who cut right to the chase; it was the Democrats over the last two years who exposed what cap-and-trade really means for the American public. We learned, for example, from President Obama that under his cap-and-trade plan, “electricity prices would necessarily skyrocket.”
Boxer Says Goal is to “Soften the Blow” from Cap-and-Trade – Admits That Cap-and-Trade Will Hurt Jobs, Families, Consumers – During a hearing on July 16, 2009, in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-CA.), chairman of the committee, said that her goal is to “soften the blow” of cap-and-trade legislation, implicitly acknowledging that cap-and-trade will harm the economy. “The biggest priority is softening the blow on our trade sensitive industries and our consumers. I just want you to know that, that’s the goal,” Sen. Boxer said. In response, Harry Alford, president of the National Black Chamber of Commerce, dismissed claims that the government could redistribute revenues from cap-and-trade to “soften the blow” on the poor, the elderly, those on fixed incomes, and consumers. “Madam Chair, I will do that, I have been around the block a few times. People are not going to get that refund, it’s not going to hit them, people are going to be unemployed, and they are not gonna have any recourse whatsoever, the government will have failed them again.”
WATCH – EPA’s Jackson Confirms EPA Chart Showing No Effect on Climate Without China, India: During a hearing on July 7, 2009 in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, EPA Administrator Jackson confirmed an EPA analysis showing that unilateral U.S. action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions would have no effect on climate. Moreover, when presented with an EPA chart depicting that outcome, Energy Secretary Steven Chu said he disagreed with EPA’s analysis. “I believe the central parts of the [EPA] chart are that U.S. action alone will not impact world CO2 levels,” Administrator Jackson said. Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) presented the chart to both Jackson and Secretary Chu, which shows that meaningful emissions reductions cannot occur without aggressive action by China, India, and other developing countries. “I am encouraged that Administrator Jackson agrees that unilateral action by the U.S. will be all cost for no climate gain,” Sen. Inhofe said. “With China and India recently issuing statements of defiant opposition to mandatory emissions controls, acting alone through the job-killing Waxman-Markey bill would impose severe economic burdens on American consumers, businesses, and families, all without any impact on climate.”
Surprise? Inhofe and Obama Admin Offical Appear to Agree on “All of the Above” Energy Policy
Posted by Matt Dempsey Surprise? Inhofe and Obama Admin Offical Appear to Agree on "All of the Above" Energy Policy Watch the exchange during the question-answer periord from today’s EPW Committee hearing between Senator Inhofe and Tom Strickland Assistant Secretary for Fish, Wildlife, and Parks for the United States Department of the Interior. Apparently, at least in words, there is […]
Join Me in Signing the No Climate Tax Pledge
Hello, I’m Senator Jim Inhofe from Oklahoma, and I am proud to be one of the hundreds of lawmakers on all levels of government to sign the Americans for Prosperity “No Climate Tax Pledge.” This pledge states clearly that climate change legislation should not be used to fund a dramatic expansion in the size and scope of government. As I add my name to the list, I am also here to call on all those who oppose the largest tax increase in American history to join me in signing the pledge by going online to http://www.noclimatetax.com/.
I have worked tirelessly over the past ten years to expose cap-and-tax for what it really is: the largest tax increase in American history. I began by leading the opposition against Kyoto in 1997 and have successfully led the fight against the cap-and-trade tax in 2003, 2005 and most recently in 2008. Today as American consumers continue to face tough economic times, the last thing Washington should be doing is raising the price of gas at the pumps, energy in our homes, and the cost of food in our grocery stores.