Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

EPW POLICY BEAT: RECESS REVIEW

 

After a short (and much needed) break, EPW Policy Beat is back (as if anyone, at least in the waning days of August, really cares).  After cleaning out in-boxes and taking stock of the last three weeks, it occurred to us that, as the siren calls of August recess rang out, several notable events occurred that were lost in the mad rush to leave town.  These were events, upon closer inspection, that could have ramifications for the climate change debate expected in the Senate this fall.  We plan to focus on them in the next few days.  Our first installment covers the (welcome) defeat of cap-and-trade in the Australian Senate. 

 

First, some background.  After his election in 2007, Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd fulfilled a campaign promise to ratify the Kyoto Protocol.  Then earlier this year, he proposed a cap-and-trade plan, dubbed the “Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme,” or CPRS, to reduce Australia’s emissions.  The CPRS requires reductions between a range of 5 and 15 percent below 2000 levels by 2020.  The CPRS covers 75 percent of Australia’s emissions, and auctions 70 percent of allowances, moving to a full auction over time.   The proceeds of the auction would accrue to households to mitigate the costs of the CPRS.

According to Sen. Penny Wong, who serves as the Rudd government’s Minister for Climate Change and Water, the CPRS “is a highly complex reform and like all serious action on climate change, it is not without cost.  But we know that for Australia, and indeed the world, the cost of not acting is far greater than the cost of responsible action now.” Link

Wong’s plea for action failed to carry the day.  After an intense, and, at times, personal debate, Senators voted 42 to 30 to defeat the CPRS.  The crux of the opposition concerned the following points: cap-and-trade will have no impact on global climate; cap-and-trade imposes high costs and burdens on Australian consumers and industries, especially, among others, agriculture; regions with energy-intensive industries will bear the brunt of cap-and-trade’s costs; and last, but not least, the science of global warming is uncertain.  In addition, from the left, five members of the Green Party complained that CPRS wasn’t strong enough.

This defeat by no means marks the end of cap-and-trade in Australia.  Rudd’s Labor party plans to resubmit a revised CPRS in the next three months.  If the opposition kills the bill again in the Senate, Rudd can ask that Parliament be dissolved, forcing an early election.  But, at this point, the outlook for cap-and-trade remains in doubt.  According to Andrew Macintosh, an analyst from Australian National University’s Center of Law and Climate Policy, “Climate has slipped down the list of priorities for Australians…Climate has gone on the backburner because of the economic climate we have found ourselves in.” Link

We perused the Australian equivalent of the Congressional Record, and found some interesting debate and discussion.  Below are excerpts. Link to Debate Transcripts 

Cap-and-Trade’s High Costs for Consumers, Agriculture

Senator Williams (New South Wales): “As I said when last speaking on this, Bayswater power station in the Hunter Valley in New South Wales produces 40 per cent of the electricity for New South Wales. The cost of their coal under the proposed emissions trading scheme, as they have reported to me, will rise from $350 million a year to a massive $950 million a year. What cost will this put on business and what cost will this put on households? Sure, the government is saying that there will be rebates. There will be rebates until the government runs out of the money, and at the rate the debt is building that will not be long. I want to give you one example. Bindaree Beef, the abattoirs that I am so proud of for the way they carry out their business in Inverell, the town I live at, employs 600 people.  Bindaree Beef pays around $160,000 a month for their electricity bill. If that is going to rise by 50 or 60 per cent, as the models have said electricity prices may well rise, that is going to be an extra $1 million a year for that abattoir just to pay the electricity bill.” Doc. Page 21

Cap-and-Trade Kills Jobs, Lowers Wages

Sen. Bernardi (South Australia): “Why, then, has the government delayed the commencement of this scheme? Has reality smacked the disingenuous Rudd government in both of its faces? If so, here is a little more reality for you to contemplate from your gilded cage: this bill will damage our economy. It will lift taxes, it will kill jobs and it will not make a jot of difference to the climate. Under the Rudd-Wong scheme Australian industry will be taxed an extra $12 billion over five years. Many of these industries will not be able to pass on these costs.  Some will simply close down or move overseas.  

“This scheme will also affect wages. Treasury secretary Dr. Henry has stated: ‘It is my understanding that in general terms the real wages in alternative employment would probably be lower than the real wages offered in the mining sector.’  In other words, this scheme will force some people out of their current jobs into lower paid jobs—hardly the outcome designed to boost prosperity in an already damaged economy. According to the minerals industry, this scheme will impose costs of $2 billion per annum and seriously damage their competitive position. The grains industry, a very low emitter, will be slugged with an annual indirect cost of more than $500 million—hardly the stuff to support their international competitiveness in an already uneven playing field.” Doc. Page 30   

No Climate Benefits

Senator Williams (New South Wales): “The carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere are currently around 380 parts per million. Assuming the rest of the world remains at balance on that, considering that places like China, India and Indonesia are most unlikely to make reductions, Australia could be billed for as much as $200 billion by the year 2020. That will have the effect of reducing the carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere from 380 parts per million to 379 parts per million, which is a reduction of one part per million. As you would be well aware, if you have a big tub in front of you with one million dollar coins in it and you took one coin out, then the change would be miniscule, minute—call it what you like—it would be nothing. And it would be at the cost of some $200 billion to the Australian industry and the Australian people.” Doc. Page 21

Senator Eggleston (Western Australia): “Mr. Rudd promised before the election to introduce an ETS which would produce deep cuts in carbon dioxide emissions but would not disadvantage Australia’s export- and import-competing industries. However, it is quite obvious that this immensely complex ETS will damage our export- and import-competing industries, it will cost thousands of jobs and it will stifle investment; yet it will not produce any meaningful reductions in carbon dioxide emissions around the world. In fact, emissions from high-emission domestic industries will not be diminished at all because instead of reducing their emissions these industries will be able to trade them off—for example, by buying a rainforest in Indonesia. How does that benefit Australia, you might ask, and how does that benefit the world? I really cannot see any benefit at all in a scheme like that if it does not actually reduce emissions in this country.” Doc. Page 62

Severe Regional Impacts

Sen. Bernardi (South Australia): “I am a senator for South Australia and I will and must consider the interests of my state. You see, when talking about job losses and increased cost; it is easy to think that it will not happen in an area near you.  This scheme will affect everyone. But some, of course, will be much worse off than others. South Australia, for example, relies on agriculture, manufacturing, mining and other energy intensive industries that will all be disadvantaged by the introduction of Labor’s CPRS. It is estimated that the South Australian government will experience a net additional cost of $99 million. This will place a significant burden on other areas of state government expenditure, such as health care, just to cover the costs of this scheme.”

“South Australia is reliant on more than mining and industry for its prosperity. We also have a big agricultural presence that contributes a large amount to our state economy. The proposed CPRS could take up to 22 per cent of a farmer’s income to—I remind the Senate once again—achieve no meaningful benefit for the environment. Beef eaters will pay more and beef producers will make less under this scheme. In fact, input costs will rise and profits will fall for all farmers. The inevitable result will be more farmers leaving the land, placing further pressure on regional communities.”  Doc. Page 73