News Round Up: Too Much Drama for Obama – Rise and Fall of Van Jones – Resigns Amid Controversy
Obama’s Green Jobs Czar, Van Jones was forced to resign Saturday after reporting by several investigative blogs and show host Glenn Beck led to main stream media coverage on his extreme views and incendiary statements. Vowing he would not be a distraction to the Administration, Jones resigned quietly, refusing to take responsibility for his past associations.
In a statement, Jones wrote: “On the eve of historic fights for health care and clean energy, opponents of reform have mounted a vicious smear campaign against me. They are using lies and distortions to distract and divide.”
Van Jones: “The environmental justice community that said, ‘Hey, wait a minute, you know, you’re regulating, but you’re not regulating equally.’ And the white polluters and the white environmentalists are essentially steering poison into the people-of-color communities, because they don’t have a racial justice frame.” (January 2008)
Van Jones: “Right now we say we want to move from suicidal gray capitalism to something eco-capitalism where at least we’re not fast-tracking the destruction of the whole planet. Will that be enough? No, it won’t be enough. We want to go beyond the systems of exploitation and oppression altogether. But, that’s a process and I think that’s what’s great about the movement that is beginning to emerge is that the crisis is so severe in terms of joblessness, violence and now ecological threats that people are willing to be both pragmatic and visionary. So the green economy will start off as a small subset and we are going to push it and push it and push it until it becomes the engine for transforming the whole society.” (April 2008)
Houston Chronicle Science Reporter Raises Inconvenient Questions
I’m the science reporter for the Houston Chronicle, the daily newspaper in the petrochemical capital of the United States, if not the world. I’ve been called a global warming skeptic by environmentalists, and I’ve been called an environmentalist toady by the skeptics.
I’m neither of these things. Rather, I’m just trying to grasp what is happening to the planet’s climate, and how humans are impacting it.
For a long time now, science reporters have been confidently told the science is settled. That the planet is warming and humans are unquestionably the primary cause. We’ve been told to trust the computer models — the models which show a markedly upward trend in temperatures as carbon dioxide concentrations increase. And I’ve trusted the scientists telling me this.
10 SENATORS
Now that cap-and-trade legislation is taking another hiatus, we turn again to significant events in August that fell beneath the radar. One such was a letter sent to President Obama on August 6 by ten Democratic Senators, representing states heavily reliant on coal for electricity and manufacturing for jobs. Its contents present serious problems for proponents of cap-and-trade legislation in the Senate. The letter, signed by Senators Brown (Oh.), Feingold (Wis.), Stabenow (Mich.), Levin (Mich.), Casey (Pa.), Specter (Pa.), Byrd (W. Va.), Rockefeller (W. Va.), Franken (Minn.), and Bayh (Ind.), is a constructive attempt to influence the design of cap-and-trade architecture. The Senators’ concern, expressed in the letter, for the fate of American manufacturing in a cap-and-trade regime is both warranted and welcome. What struck us as interesting is the statement from the Senators that they “would find it extremely difficult to support a final measure” without the proposals outlined in the letter. The proposals, noted below, have sparked the ire of the White House, and could have serious global trade implications. Beyond that, their inclusion in climate legislation would no doubt further complicate the Senate debate.
WSJ Editorial: Terms of ‘Endangerment’
Cap and trade may be flopping around like a dying fish in Congress, but the Obama Administration isn’t about to let the annoyance of democratic consent interfere with its climate ambitions. Almost as bad is the new evidence that it understands how damaging its carbon regulations and taxes will be and is pressing ahead anyway.
The White House is currently reviewing the Environmental Protection Agency’s April “endangerment finding” that as a matter of law CO2 is a pollutant that threatens the public’s health and must therefore be subject to regulation under the Clean Air Act. Such a rulemaking would let the EPA impose the ossified command-and-control regulatory approach of the 1970s across the entire economy, even if Democrats never get around to passing a cap-and-tax bill.
Yet a curious twist is buried in the EPA’s draft rule. The trade press is reporting that the agency thinks it enjoys the discretion to target the new rules only to major industrial sources of carbon emissions, such as power plants, refineries, factories and the like. This so-called “tailoring rule” essentially rewrites clear statutory language of the Clean Air Act by bureaucratic decree.
EPW FACT OF THE DAY: $300 MILLION
In an above-the-fold article yesterday, the Washington Post reported that environmental groups “slacked off” after House passage of the Waxman-Markey bill, creating an open field for opponents to savage the bill’s high costs on consumers and families. In detailing how “progressives and clean energy types” have made tactical and strategic mistakes over the summer, the Post contends environmentalists are losing in part because of a lack of funding. According to the report, “Oil and natural gas groups have always had deeper pockets. In the first six months of 2009, the Center for Responsive Politics found they spent $82.1 million lobbying Washington on various issues, including climate policy. In the same time, environmental and health groups concerned with climate change spent about $6.6 million on lobbying and clean-energy firms $12.1 million, according to two other analyst groups, the Center for Public Integrity and New Energy Finance.”
Democrats Delay Climate Bill For Second Time in Two Months
Joint Statement of Senator John Kerry and Senator Barbara Boxer
The Kerry-Boxer bill is moving along well and we are looking forward to introducing legislation that will create millions of clean energy jobs, reduce our dependence on foreign oil, and ensure American leadership in the clean energy economy.
Because of Senator Kennedy’s recent passing, Senator Kerry’s August hip surgery, and the intensive work on health care legislation particularly on the Finance Committee where Sen. Kerry serves, Majority Leader Reid has agreed to provide some additional time to work on the final details of our bill, and to reach out to colleagues and important stakeholders. We have told the Majority Leader that our goal is to introduce our bill later in September.
National Journal: Should EPA Bow To Chamber’s Demand ?
The National Journal asked politicians, academics and others the following questions: Should the Environmental Protection Agency be required to publicly defend its finding that greenhouse gases endanger public health and welfare? Should the climate change data be reviewed in a public administrative law hearing? Would a public hearing make any difference? Or is the hearing request just an excuse to delay the agency’s climate change decision?
Background from National Journal:
In April, the EPA released a proposal concluding that carbon dioxide and other global warming pollutants cause health problems. Now the agency is poised to release the final version of that ruling. But the U.S. Chamber of Commerce argues that before the decision is finalized, EPA should be required to defend its scientific conclusions in front of an administrative law judge. Chamber officials and other critics claim that the Obama administration is suppressing internal agency studies that disagree with the proposed endangerment finding.
INVESTOR’S BUSINESS DAILY: Carbongate
Junk Science: The EPA may be considering closing the watchdog office that exposed the flimsy evidence of man-caused warming. So much for the administration’s promise to “restore science to its rightful place.”
Recently we commented on the plight of Dr. Allen Carlin, the EPA senior research analyst at the National Center for Environmental Economics who dared to say, in essence, that emperor Al Gore and his environmental sycophants at the Environmental Protection Agency wore no clothes.
The EPA had been working on an “endangerment finding” that would say carbon dioxide, rather than being the basis for all life on earth, was a dangerous pollutant and allowing the EPA to regulate it and five other gases down to your lawn mower.
Along came Carlin, who decided to do something unheard of and actually check the empirical data. After examining numerous global warming studies, Carlin — who holds a doctorate in economics with an undergraduate degree in physics — said his research showed that “available observable data . . . invalidate the hypothesis” that humans cause dangerous global warming. The EPA has “tended to accept the findings reached by outside groups . . . as being correct without a careful and critical examination.”
With the Democrats about to push the Waxman-Markey cap-and-trade legislation, it didn’t help for Carlin to report, for example, that ocean cycles, rather than anthropogenic carbon dioxide, appeared to be the single best explanation of temperature variations.
ON LIBERTY
It is well known that questioning the science underlying climate change policy—that is, publicly raising doubts about various aspects of it, or even disbelieving the anthropogenic global warming hypothesis entirely—is outré, something that simply cannot be raised in polite society, or in the halls of Congress. This is a reality we know well, and one we accept with ironic amusement. Moreover, we are, in various forums, happy to stipulate the so-called consensus science—i.e. mankind’s consumption of fossil fuels is fueling a planetary disaster—given that the policies (read: cap and trade) driven by it do absolutely nothing to remedy the problems—droughts, disease, general decimation of all kinds—that are identified by it.
This is not to say, of course, that questioning should stop—to the contrary: it should continue, unabated, in the true spirit of open, Baconian scientific inquiry, if only because such questioning, by numerous, respected, well-credentialed scientists, including those once convinced of the accuracy of the “consensus” position, has revealed serious, in fact devastating, flaws, in what some believe to be an open and shut case deserving of no dissent. For this reason, we welcomed the news that the U.S. Chamber of Commerce has asked EPA to hold a hearing on the scientific evidence supporting the agency’s proposed endangerment finding for greenhouse gases.
One would expect EPA and the environmental community, so convinced of the absolute certainty of their position, to welcome such a challenge, which would once and for all dispose with “denier” doubting about the supposed harms of carbon dioxide emissions. Yet we found just the opposite. According to the LA Times an EPA spokesman dismissed the Chamber’s request for an open hearing as a “waste of time” and “frivolous.” A representative from the Union of Concerned Scientists, following that group’s usual penchant for nuance and subtlety, compared the Chamber’s request to “the Salem witch trials, based on myth.” “In this case,” according to the UCS’s Brenda Ekwurzel, “[the Chamber filing], would be ignoring decades of publicly accessible evidence.” Joe Romm, of the Center for American Progress, asks the board members of the Chamber “to declare whether they are evolved members of humanity or dedicated to our self-destruction.”
WSJ: Climate Bill Exposes Rifts Within Political Families
The debate over how to curb carbon-dioxide emissions and other gases linked to global climate change is splitting some prominent political families in both parties.
Interior Secretary Ken Salazar is one of the Obama administration’s leading advocates of strong action on climate change. His older brother John, a Democratic congressman from Colorado, voted with many House Republicans against a bill to cap U.S. greenhouse-gas emissions.
John Salazar said the House climate bill would be “unfair” to Colorado and lead to “dramatically” higher electricity bills for his constituents.
“He has his job to do; I have my job to do,” said his brother, the interior secretary.
John Podesta knows that feeling. Mr. Podesta, a White House chief of staff under President Clinton who advised President Barack Obama on his White House transition, is one of the House bill’s most outspoken supporters.
The debate over how to curb U.S. emissions of carbon dioxide and other gases linked to global climate change is splitting some powerful political families, environmental reporter Stephen Power says.
In blog posts on the Web site of the Center for American Progress, an Obama-friendly think tank, Mr. Podesta has accused “coal lobby groups” of waging “a massive campaign” to defeat the measure.
Mr. Podesta’s older brother Tony is a registered lobbyist for the American Coalition for Clean Coal Electricity. The coalition, which represents major coal producers such as Peabody Energy Corp. and electric utilities such as American Electric Power Co., said the House legislation “does not adequately protect consumers and the domestic economy.”
The coalition has come under attack from the younger Mr. Podesta’s group over the former’s use of a subcontractor that has acknowledged sending members of Congress fake letters purporting to be from nonprofit groups opposed to climate legislation.