Lawmakers Urge EPA to Keep Water-quality Program
The Oklahoma congressional delegation expressed concern Thursday that a federal agency is moving away from a successful voluntary program tied to Tulsa’s water quality.
In a letter to Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa Jackson, the delegation said Oklahoma’s $9 million investment in the program since 2003 has resulted in a 66 percent reduction in phosphorus levels in Beaty Creek.
That creek is a tributary to the Eucha-Spavinaw watershed, the primary water supply for Tulsa.
Boxer Climate Bill To Put ‘Collar’ On Allowance Prices (Energy Daily 9/17/09)
Moving to assuage concerns about the potential costs of capping U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, Senate Environment and Public Works Committee Chair Barbara Boxer has included an allowance “price collar” provision in climate change legislation she is drafting that would establish maximum and minimum prices for emission allowances in the early years of the cap-and-trade program the bill would create, The Energy Daily has learned.
The draft legislation, which Boxer (D-Calif.) plans to introduce at the end of the month, would establish an initial allowance price ceiling of $28 per metric ton of carbon dioxide and a price floor of $11, with the prices adjusted upwards annually thereafter, according to a source familiar with the measure.
Under the provision, if heavy demand pushed allowance market prices above the $28 ceiling, the government would borrow allowances from future years and sell them to regulated entities at the ceiling price, a move that in theory would reduce demand for allowances and lower prices.
The minimum, or floor, price would ensure that government-administered allowance auctions generate sufficient revenues to fund climate change adaptation efforts, for example, and other climate change-related public benefits.
Details of Boxer’s draft emerged as Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) signaled Tuesday that climate change legislation is unlikely to come to the Senate floor until late in the year given the Senate’s crowded schedule, which includes health care and financial services reform legislation and a number of appropriations bills.
Reid’s pronouncement notwithstanding, Boxer is expected to hold hearings on her legislation in early October and move it through her committee later that month.
Boxer signaled in early August she was considering including a price collar in her legislation, a move clearly aimed at addressing concerns by a number of Democratic senators over the past two months that limiting carbon emissions could harm the U.S. economy by driving up the costs of energy and consumer products.
Inhofe Says Revised EPA Smog Standards Would Hurt Oklahoma
U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe warned Wednesday that Tulsa County and at least eight other Oklahoma counties will face severe restrictions on economic development if the Obama administration follows through with revisions on smog standards.
“I am proud that over the past few years we have made tremendous progress in cleaning up our air in Oklahoma,” Inhofe said, adding that not a single county in the state is now in violation of ozone standards. “But if EPA follows through on its action, Oklahoma communities will face severe restrictions on their ability to grow and promote economic development.”
Inhofe was reacting to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa Jackson’s announcement that her agency will reconsider 2008 smog standards.
Cap And Trade Redux: $1,761 Annually Per Family? Or Not?
An inevitability of writing about controversial political topics is that you’re bound to see nastygrams from someone who doesn’t especially care for what you’ve written.
After I wrote an article yesterday reporting on the Obama administration’s private estimate of the cost of a cap and trade law, the good folks at the liberal Center for American Progress (John Podesta’s group) decided they didn’t care for it very much.
My article said: “The Obama administration has privately concluded that a cap and trade law would cost American taxpayers up to $200 billion a year, the equivalent of hiking personal income taxes by about 15 percent… the total in new taxes would be between $100 billion to $200 billion a year. At the upper end of the administration’s estimate, the cost per American household would be an extra $1,761 a year.” Cap and trade is, of course, the idea of pollution credits, meaning that a pollution limit is established and industries can sell the right to emit carbon to each other.
So the Center for American Progress replied by posting a response alleging I was “promot[ing] another false CEI attack on clean energy reform.”
Inhofe Welcomes Oklahoma State Chamber of Commerce to DC
Senator Inhofe was pleased to welcome back the Oklahoma Chamber of Commerce to Washington D.C. this week to discuss a number of wide-ranging issues important to Oklahoma businesses, including critical transportation issues. At the invitation of Senator Inhofe, Secretary of Transportation Roy LaHood addressed the group and took questions.
E&E News: Reid Says Cap-and-Trade Bill May Wait till 2010
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) today said the Senate may not act on comprehensive energy and climate change legislation until next year, given the chamber’s busy fall schedule.
Speaking to reporters about the possibility of taking up the bill this fall, Reid said the Senate must first finish work on health care and regulatory reform.
“So, you know, we are going to have a busy, busy time the rest of this year,” Reid said. “And, of course, nothing terminates at the end of this year. We still have next year to complete things if we have to.”
Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) acknowledged the current focus on health care but said he is hopeful climate will remain part of the packed agenda this year. Asked whether he and Reid are discussing the climate and energy bill amid the current health care push, Durbin said, “It’s all health care, all the time. I shouldn’t say all the time, because we have a list of about a dozen things we have to do, and that is one of the elements that we want to finish before the end of the year.”
GOP Beware: Though Now Stalled, Cap-and-Trade is Alive and Well
Now that the debate on cap-and-trade has stalled indefinitely in the Senate, inquiring minds are wondering: what’s next? While there’s no question the Democrats have declared a cease fire on cap-and-trade—many of them want nothing to do with the issue—their allies outside the Beltway are preparing a massive $20 million campaign to push legislation forward.
This effort should serve as a wake-up call to anyone who believes cap-and-trade is dead and buried—it is very much alive. So Republicans remain ever vigilant, preparing to defeat any cap-and-trade energy tax that will drive up unemployment, slow our economic recovery, and make America less competitive in the global marketplace.
A key component of this pressure group campaign will be the so-called “endangerment” finding now under review at the White House. This finding under the Clean Air Act will declare that greenhouse gases endanger public health and welfare, and thus will trigger a cascade of new regulations that will crush small businesses and raise electricity, food, and gasoline prices.
Green groups and the Obama Administration are threatening Congress with this finding, arguing that the Waxman-Markey cap-and-trade bill, or any cap-and-trade bill, will take care of it. They argue that cap-and-trade is more efficient than command-and-control regulation. But this is a smokescreen for the truth: cap-and-trade would simply substitute one bad policy for another, as Congress would be replacing one energy tax with another. Republicans reject both, and both should be defeated.
Dismal Outlook For Climate Bill As Congress Returns From August Recess
Reuters – U.S. Senate Democrats Skeptical About Climate Bill (09/10/09) – WASHINGTON, Sept 9 (Reuters) – Several U.S. Senate Democrats, including a top leader, on Wednesday questioned whether it would be possible to vote on a climate change bill this year, especially with healthcare reform eating up so much of the lawmakers’ time. “It’s a difficult schedule” with many members already “anxious” about healthcare reform, Senator Dick Durbin, the second-ranking Democrat, told Reuters when asked about prospects this year for a bill to cap emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. President Barack Obama is engaged in the toughest fight of his presidency in trying to win passage of expanded healthcare. Obama also has called on Congress to approve legislation this year to control climate change by reducing pollutants from utilities, oil refineries and factories. Besides the need to pass the complex healthcare bill this year, which Durbin said was “first in the queue,” he also noted the need to tackle legislation imposing stricter rules on the U.S. financial industry.Durbin said it was unclear whether the climate bill or financial industry reform would be a higher priority in 2009. With most Senate Republicans expected to oppose a climate change bill in the 100-member Senate, nearly all of the 60 seats controlled by Democrats would have to line up in favor of the legislation for it to clear procedural hurdles.
Inside EPA – Senators Offer No Firm Plan For Passing Cap-And-Trade This Year (09/10/09) – Senate leaders have set no firm deadline for committees to finish work on climate change legislation, a revelation that comes amid increasing talk that the chamber may be unable or unwilling to act on a controversial cap-and-trade plan before the end of the year given a host of other competing concerns. In interviews, Democratic lawmakers were split on whether the Senate can or should even try to enact climate legislation ahead of December talks in Copenhagen aimed at crafting a new global climate change treaty, and none put forward a clear plan for how the chamber will tackle the issue. Given the dwindling amount of time left for lawmakers to address the topic this year, some senators suggested Congress may be better off passing piecemeal measures, such as a utility-only cap-and-trade scheme, or simply leaving the issue for EPA to handle. In late August, Senate Environment & Public Works Committee Chair Barbara Boxer (D-CA) and Sen. John Kerry (D-MA), chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, announced their climate bill would not be introduced until at least the end of this month, the most recent in a series of delays for the bill’s introduction…The lack of a firm deadline — or a public consensus on the plan even from committee chairmen tasked with drafting aspects of the bill — may be an indication Senate leaders are not fully committed to holding a vote on climate legislation before the end of the year. Senate Energy & Natural Resources Committee Chairman Jeff Bingaman (D-NM), for instance, said in an interview that “there hasn’t been a lot of discussion” within the Senate about the climate and energy agenda for the rest of the year, evidence the health care debate has been dominating lawmakers’ attention. That said, he didn’t rule out that there would be some form of action. “My expectation is that we are going to move forward,” he said. “Once health care is done, that is next up on the agenda.”
WAXMAN-MARKEY’S ENDANGERMENT MESS
As EPA prepares to finalize its proposed endangerment finding for greenhouse gases under the Clean Air Act, many are wondering: doesn’t Waxman-Markey take care of that endangerment mess? It’s true that in the bill’s vast wasteland of mandates, restrictions, and controls, there are provisions preempting specific provisions of the Clean Air Act. One such is Section 831, prohibiting EPA from establishing a national ambient air quality standard for greenhouse gas emissions. This is indeed helpful, considering the mess such a standard setting process would cause.
Yet despite this and other narrow preemption provisions, Waxman-Markey is in no way a panacea for endangerment, as there is nothing in the bill that overturns Massachusetts v. EPA, or blocks EPA from making an endangerment finding (not to mention tying the hands of Interior and NOAA on the Endangered Species Act, or preempting GHG regulation under the National Environmental Policy Act). What’s clear is that the bill’s authors attempted to manage some of the potential results of an endangerment finding. But their attempt, while admirable in some respects, in no way prevents a regulatory nightmare from occurring.
What’s more, Waxman-Markey uses existing provisions of the Clean Air Act to drive emissions reductions. In Section 811, EPA is required to utilize Section 111 of the Clean Air Act to impose new source performance standards on certain sources emitting between 10,000 and 25,000 tons of GHG per year. Also, Section 821 explicitly preserves existing Clean Air Act authority for EPA to regulate GHG emissions from mobile sources. And to make matters worse, Section 705f(3)(C) instructs EPA to “develop strategies and approaches for achieving additional reductions” of GHG beyond those established in the act. One would bet the farm that EPA would use this authority to mandate any and all sources not covered under Waxman-Markey, even to invoke Clean Air Act authorities otherwise preempted by the bill.
Inhofe Highlights Energy Report: Common Sense for Concerned Americans
Senator James Inhofe spoke on the Senate Floor this week highlighting a recent report from Robert P. Smith, Ph.D., P.E., of Strategic Resource Consulting. In his speech, Inhofe outlined energy policies that would help reduce our dependence on foreign sources of oil and make energy more affordable by increasing domestic energy supplies and fostering new energy technologies.
Organized into seven chapters, and written in non-technical language, the report is a perfect primer for any citizen concerned about America’s energy future.