Wash Examiner Editorial: Stop using tax dollars to fund Big Green lawsuits

Republican Sens. Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma and David Vitter of Louisiana thought they were posing a simple question last year when they asked the Government Accountability Office to determine how many tax dollars are paid in court costs to Big Green environmental groups that file lawsuits against the government. It took GAO nearly a year and required the work of at least 14 professional staff members of the congressional watchdog agency to arrive at a response to the Inhofe/Vitter query. The answers contained in the GAO report, first reported yesterday by Washington Examiner columnist Ron Arnold, are anything but simple.

First, despite the fact that “no aggregated data on such environmental litigation or associated costs are reported by federal agencies,” the agency’s investigators were able arrive at some useful estimates. The Department of Justice spent at least $43 million from 1998 to 2010 defending the Environmental Protection Agency in court, while the Department of Treasury paid about $14.2 million from 2003 through 2010 to successful plaintiffs for attorneys’ fees and associated costs. The EPA paid about $1.4 million from 2006 to 2010 to plaintiffs. Most of the plaintiffs represented Big Green groups. But those figures almost certainly underestimate the true amount of such costs because, GAO said, “the key agencies involved — Justice, EPA and Treasury — maintain certain data on individual cases in several internal agency databases, but collectively, these data do not capture all costs.” In other words, federal officials don’t know how many tax dollars are paid to Big Green environmental groups and their lawyers who sue the government.

As The Washington Examiner showed last September with its “Special Report: Big Green and how the enviroleft is crippling the economy,” the major players in the environmental movement are lavishly funded by private contributions from individuals and foundations. And many of them also receive hundreds of millions more dollars in government grants and contracts, so it’s not as if these groups are unable to pay their legal legions out of their own coffers.

Politico Pro: GAO: Greens rake in the green by suing EPA

The vast majority of the attorney fees doled out by the federal government in environmental lawsuits against the EPA have gone to green groups in recent years, according to a Government Accountability Office report that top Republicans in Congress are seizing on.

The report, released Wednesday, prompted GOP lawmakers to accuse major environmental groups of profiting from taxpayers by suing the federal government.

But greens say they’re acting in the public interest – and the fact that they’ve won fees means the courts agreed with them that the EPA was breaking the law.

National and local environmental and citizens’ groups received 75 percent of the $14.2 million in attorney fees that the Treasury Department paid in environmental cases against the EPA between 2003 and 2010, the GAO reported.

Green groups received 84 percent of the $1.4 million in attorney fees paid by the EPA between 2006 and 2010, the report found.

Sens. Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma and David Vitter of Louisiana, top Republicans on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, released the report along with a breakdown of the top recipients of attorney fees from EPA litigation.

Obamas Infrastructure Record

Wednesday, February 16, 2011 Inhofe Reaction to Obama’s Transportation Budget: I’d like to end with some comments on the President’s budget proposal for the highway bill, which was released on Monday. I was hoping for some positive leadership by the Administration after only paying lip service to our crumbling roads and bridges. Sadly, the President failed to step up and show any leadership. He failed to specify how he would pay for his mammoth $556 billion proposal. Instead he punts, saying his higher trust fund revenue is “a placeholder and do not assume an increase in gas taxes or any specific proposal to offset surface transportation spending. Rather, they are intended to initiate a discussion about how the Administration and Congress could work together on a bipartisan basis to pass a surface transportation reauthorization….” This puts us back in the hole former House Democrats dug last Congress: proposing a huge bill with no way to pay for it. This is flat out irresponsible. If he were serious about getting a bill done, he would have either cut spending or said how he is going to pay for it. I can only call this a setback. It gives false hope to transportation advocates and leaves Congress in the same box as before the budget was released. This comes almost exactly 2 years after the failed, so-called stimulus bill, which was sold as having primarily an infrastructure focus, but ended up with only 3 percent of the total going to roads and bridges. Here we go again.

January 26, 2011 Inhofe Reaction to Obama’s State of the Union: I’d like to take a moment to comment on last night’s State of the Union. I have always said that government has three spending responsibilities: defense, infrastructure, and unfunded mandates. We’ve heard President Obama talk about infrastructure before, but there has been little follow through. For example, the President’s so-called Stimulus bill, which was largely sold to the American people as a way to improve our infrastructure, actually spent less than 3 percent on repairing the nation’s crumbling roads and bridges. Another example was this past Labor Day’s announcement where he promised a $50 billion plan for infrastructure, but no action ever followed and he never spoke of it again. In light of this, I was interested to hear him highlight our infrastructure needs again last night. I hope he actually follows through. If he is serious this time, I am committed to working with him and Senator Boxer, as I have always done, to address our nation’s infrastructure needs.

2010 Obama Labor Day Infrastructure Roll Out “Lousy Idea”

October 14, 2010: OBAMA’S CONFUSION ON INFRASTRUCTURE; Now says: “No such thing as shovel-ready projects” In a New York Times blog post, previewing a Sunday Times interview with President Obama about lessons learned in his first two years in office, an interesting quote stands out: the President now believes, “there’s no such thing as shovel-ready projects.” How things change. Indeed, how can one forget the mantra of 2009, when President Obama routinely touted “shovel-ready” projects to sell his stimulus bill (check out this Washington Post article from January 2009). We look forward to reading the entire Times article on Sunday, but for now, it seems the President can’t quite get a handle on what to do about infrastructure. On Labor Day, the President rolled out a new $50 billion infrastructure policy. But it was an unserious proposal, flawed in many respects, as members of his party clearly understood.

September 14, 2010 Denver Post Editorial: Editorial: Political theater or poor policy? Whether or not President Obama’s plan to spend $50 billion on transportation is a ploy to help fellow Dems, it’s a lousy idea. President Barack Obama’s latest plan to spur the economy back to health has rightly found a new group of detractors. This time, though, it’s his fellow Democrats, many of whom are locked in tight races, who are saying no. Their rush to say no makes us wonder if the president put forth a serious plan or if this latest blueprint to stimulate the economy, in part by spending $50 billion to rebuild roads, railways and airports, is more political theater than legitimate policy. Several Colorado Democrats who supported past stimulus spending – and at much greater levels – are rejecting the president’s proposal.

September 8, 2010: Oklahoman Editorial: Politics apparent in Obama’s new economic proposals: DESPERATION wafts from President Obama’s new proposals to jump-start the economy – $50 billion in infrastructure spending and $300 billion in tax breaks for business. Coming as they do less than two months before the midterm congressional election, it’s hard not to chalk them up to politics.

Democratic Congressman Calls Obama’s Economic Advisers Pick Out of Touch

Democratic Rep. Dan Boren on Monday said President Obama’s appointment of Princeton University economist Alan Krueger as one of his top economic advisers sends a signal that the president is out of touch with independent voters.

The blunt critique of Krueger, a labor economist picked Monday to head the president’s White House Council of Economic Advisers, encapsulates the frustration some centrist Democrats feel toward the president.

“If the No. 1 issue is the economy and jobs, you don’t get a labor economist from Princeton,” said Boren, an Oklahoma centrist who is not seeking reelection next year. He argued that independent voters want the president to bring in someone with more business experience. “You get a Jack Welch-type, someone from the business world.”

Boren argued that the Obama administration is insufficiently business-friendly.

Inhofe Pans Krueger Despite White House Raves (Human Events)

Although the name of Sen. Jim Inhofe (R.-Okla.) did not come up at the press briefing at the White House yesterday, Press Secretary Jay Carney made it clear that the administration is gearing up for a confirmation battle over the nomination of Alan Krueger to be chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) against opposition that is sure to be led by Inhofe.

In response to a question from Talk Radio Network’s Victoria Jones about why he felt Senate Republicans would want to confirm Krueger, Carney noted that the Senate had confirmed him for other positions before this one. Then Carney went on to trot out endorsements of the nominee by prominent Republicans-a bit unusual to do only hours after the President had announced he was nominating Krueger to succeed Austan Goolsbee as CEA chairman.

Senate Republicans request IG probe of commission chairman

Four Senate Republicans asked the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s inspector general today to investigate the agency’s chairman for alleged abuses of emergency authorities and withholding information from fellow commission members.

Sens. James Inhofe of Oklahoma, John Barrasso of Wyoming, Jeff Sessions of Alabama and David Vitter of Louisiana say NRC Chairman Gregory Jaczko is thwarting the five-member commission’s ability to make decisions in a crisis spurred by the March 11 earthquake and tsunami that crippled a Japan nuclear plant.

At issue is Jaczko’s use of authority granted under Section 3 of NRC’s 1980 reorganization plan, which allows for the transfer of certain commission powers to the chairman himself. Jaczko justified use of that power since the United States issued tsunami warnings in the wake of the Japan earthquake (Greenwire, April 29).

Congress passed the reorganization law in the aftermath of the 1979 partial meltdown at Pennsylvania’s Three Mile Island plant. Former NRC Chairman Richard Meserve last used that authority following the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks to raise security designations at U.S. nuclear plants to the highest levels, NRC said.

Senate GOP wants Jaczko investigation

NRC Chairman Gregory Jaczko is under fire once again as Senate Republicans demand a new investigation into his actions in response to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear crisis.

Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), ranking member of the Environment and Public Works Committee, and three of his colleagues on the panel, sent a letter to NRC inspector general Hubert Bell Wednesday calling for a review of Jaczko’s use of emergency powers after the Japanese nuclear incident began.

The lawmakers say Jaczko “exceeded his authority” as chairman in assuming emergency powers because the facility under threat was in Japan and therefore not a licensee of the NRC.

Wednesday’s letter also jumped on a previous NRC IG report finding that said Jaczko “strategically withheld” information from his fellow commissioners regarding the agency’s shutdown of the Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository.

Jaczko also blocked the distribution of a paper from the agency’s executive director for operations that was meant to provide context and recommendations to the commission on a recent post-Fukushima task force report, the senators wrote. Jaczko, they said, has “inhibited the flow of information to the commission,” by blocking the paper from his colleagues on the commission.

Sens. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.), Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.) and David Vitter (R-La.) also signed the letter.

Politico Pro: Testing Obama’s advice to a farmer, the sequel

After a farmer expressed his concerns about rules and regulations that he heard could hurt his industry to President Barack Obama at a town hall in Atkinson, Ill., on Wednesday, POLITICO tested Obama’s advice that the man “contact USDA.” That didn’t lead to very helpful answers.

The response – eventually – from a USDA representative was that “the question that was posed did not fall within USDA jurisdiction,” but rather the Environmental Protection Agency.

Turns out, Obama administration officials have been trying to fight rumors about various nonexistent regulations in farm states all year. Among them, a “cow tax” on farmers for the greenhouse gases emitted by livestock and limits for ammonia and ammonium under clean air rules.

Earlier this year, EPA struck down a rumor that it would regulate spilled milk the way it regulates spilled oil. To end this misinformation, the agency formally exempted milk containers from rules aimed at preventing oil spills from reaching water supplies. And the EPA’s clean air rules for nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides released in July didn’t include limits for ammonia or other reduced forms of nitrogen.

EPA chief Lisa Jackson, who has been traveling to farm country in an attempt to improve her agency’s image, has repeatedly insisted that the EPA has no plans to regulate farm dust, and she says that the cow tax rumor was a myth started by a lobbyist.

Politico: Obama’s unhelpful advice

At Wednesday’s town hall in Atkinson, Ill., a local farmer who said he grows corn and soybeans expressed his concerns to President Obama about “more rules and regulations” – including those concerning dust, noise and water runoff — that he heard would negatively affect his business.

The president, on day three of his Midwest bus tour, replied: “If you hear something is happening, but it hasn’t happened, don’t always believe what you hear.”

When the room broke into soft laughter, the president added, “No — and I’m serious about that.”

Saying that “folks in Washington” like to get “all ginned up” about things that aren’t necessarily happening (“Look what’s comin’ down the pipe!”), Obama’s advice was simple: “Contact USDA.”

“Talk to them directly. Find out what it is that you’re concerned about,” Obama told the man. “My suspicion is a lot of times they’re going to be able to answer your questions and it will turn out that some of your fears are unfounded.”

Call Uncle Sam. Sensible advice, but perhaps the president has forgotten just how difficult it can be for ordinary citizens to get answers from the government.

Interior IG sees potential conflict in suspended biologist’s role vetting polar bear study

An Interior Department biologist potentially violated procurement rules when he helped another scientist prepare a proposal for an agency-funded study, according to a letter from Interior’s inspector general.

The letter sheds light on an investigation that has caused an uproar among environmentalists.

The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement suspended wildlife biologist Charles Monnett last month, prompting widespread debate over whether the investigation was related to his 2006 paper on drowned polar bears. That paper helped galvanize the global warming movement, and a transcript revealed that IG investigators questioned Monnett in detail about his observations and scientific methods for it.

But in a letter sent to Monnett this week, Special Agent in Charge David Brown alleges that the biologist assisted Andrew Derocher in preparing a response to the government’s request for proposal for a current study on polar bears. The sole-source contract was subsequently awarded to Derocher’s employer, the University of Alberta in Canada.

Monnett was chairman of the Technical Proposal Evaluation Committee. By helping Derocher draft that proposal, Monnett essentially reviewed a document he helped write, according to the IG letter.