Posted by Katie Brown Katie_Brown@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It… 

Politico Pro 

GAO: Greens rake in the green by suing EPA

By Robin Bravender

8/31/11

Link to Article 

Link to Inhofe Statement and Report  

The vast majority of the attorney fees doled out by the federal government in environmental lawsuits against the EPA have gone to green groups in recent years, according to a Government Accountability Office report that top Republicans in Congress are seizing on.

The report, released Wednesday, prompted GOP lawmakers to accuse major environmental groups of profiting from taxpayers by suing the federal government.

But greens say they’re acting in the public interest – and the fact that they’ve won fees means the courts agreed with them that the EPA was breaking the law.

National and local environmental and citizens’ groups received 75 percent of the $14.2 million in attorney fees that the Treasury Department paid in environmental cases against the EPA between 2003 and 2010, the GAO reported.

Green groups received 84 percent of the $1.4 million in attorney fees paid by the EPA between 2006 and 2010, the report found.

Sens. Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma and David Vitter of Louisiana, top Republicans on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, released the report along with a breakdown of the top recipients of attorney fees from EPA litigation.

The lawmakers said the national green groups Earthjustice, Sierra Club and Natural Resources Defense Council received a combined 41 percent of all the attorney fees awarded to EPA litigants.

Environmentalists counter that they won fees by proving that EPA had violated the law.

"The reason we had to sue EPA is because industry has been pushing so hard to keep them from implementing the law and we’ve had to bring lawsuits to get them to implement the law and not cut corners," said Patti Goldman, vice president for litigation at Earthjustice. When her group has recovered attorney and court fees, "it means EPA acted illegally and we went to court and proved it," she added.

Major environmental laws, including the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, allow citizens to challenge EPA actions and authorize judges to award attorney fees to plaintiffs that win their cases. Those payments are made either from a permanent Treasury Department fund or from EPA’s appropriations.

In fact, industry groups – not environmentalists – filed more lawsuits against EPA between 1995 and 2010, GAO found. Trade associations and private companies were the lead plaintiffs in 48 percent of the lawsuits against the EPA during that time, compared with 30 percent filed by national and local green and citizens’ groups.

Overall, the Justice Department spent about $43 million – or $3.3 million per year – to defend the EPA between 1998 and 2010.

The GOP lawmakers also blasted federal agencies’ record-keeping on environmental lawsuits after GAO found that they don’t report aggregate data about environmental litigation or associated costs.

"It is outrageous that these federal agencies couldn’t provide the requested information and it is even more concerning that we have yet to get the full story," Inhofe said. He criticized what he called "a glaring lack of transparency on the part of EPA, DOJ and the Department of Treasury as GAO was unable to obtain information for several years of litigation payments."

###