CHINA AND THE “CLEAN ENERGY RACE”

Picture two runners, call them China and America. They are running in a race. China is ahead of America, but America wants to get ahead and win. Right in the middle of the race, someone puts a massive weight on America’s back, clearing the path to victory for China.

According to Silicon Valley attorney John Doerr, who testified last week at an EPW Committee hearing, there is, in fact, a “clean energy race” between China and America, and China is “cleaning our clock.” Doerr’s plan for winning the race? Throw the massive weight of cap-and-trade on the back of America’s manufacturers and let China run free.

Doerr described China’s commitments to “develop and own clean energy technologies and markets” as “breathtaking.” Examples include cars that are more than “one-third more fuel efficient than U.S. cars,” investing “ten times more than the US on clean power as a percentage of GDP,” and the fact that China “is expected to become the world’s largest wind manufacturer this years.”

All of this is quite interesting, but Doerr’s argument suffers from a fatal flaw: China’s “breathtaking” commitments are occurring without cap-and-trade. Moreover, Doerr glosses over the crucial fact about manufacturing wind turbines and solar panels: making them is energy-intensive, which means significant costs for energy use. According to a paper by DOE’s Robert Garland, “manufacturing processes are amongst the most energy-intensive industrial systems.” “Energy costs,” he concludes, “are therefore a major driver for many plants in the United States.”

House climate bill was flooded with last-minute changes – LA TIMES

Reporting from Washington — Less than 24 hours before the House approved its landmark energy and climate bill last month, Rep. Ed Perlmutter (D-Colo.) got several paragraphs added to the 1,200-page measure — additions expected to be worth millions of dollars to companies that install solar panels.

About the same time, Rep. Melissa Bean (D-Ill.) took the lead in adding another little-noticed provision to the legislation — a section designed to prevent regulatory action she said could shut down the multitrillion-dollar market for over-the-counter derivatives, a complex type of financial instrument.

These narrowly focused amendments were part of a torrent written into the bill during the wheeling and dealing that took place as Democratic leaders rounded up the votes needed to squeak out a victory.

There were about 300 pages of last-minute amendments, many designed to make money for industries and constituencies important to fence-sitting lawmakers.

Will China Follow This Time?

A mantra repeated endlessly in the cap-and-trade debate is that unilateral U.S. action on climate change will spur China (and other developing countries) to follow suit. This mantra is spoken with metronomic regularity, despite China’s unequivocal opposition, stated over and over again, to accepting mandatory emission cuts. Such opposition should be no surprise: China has amassed a long and ignominious record of divergence on issues in which the United States has taken the lead.

EPW Policy Beat delved into the historical record to find examples of China going its own way, regardless of U.S. example and leadership. In some cases, China stands in defiance of international trade rules and basic norms of justice and human rights.

Newspapers Praise Inhofe for Decision to Place Hold on Stimulus Dollars Coming to Town in Oklahoma Slated for Permanent Closure

Local Oklahoma newspapers are weighing-in in support Senator Inhofe’s decision to stop stimulus money going to a town in Oklahoma soon to be shut down.

Senator Inhofe, after learning that over $135,000 of federal stimulus funds were going to be directed to a city in Oklahoma soon to be closed, worked with Congressman Dan Boren (D-Okla) to put a hold on the funds. Senator Inhofe, who has opposed bailout after bailout in Washington DC, and who opposed the Stimulus Bill, issued the following statement when sending a letter to HUD:

“It’s common sense that you wouldn’t spend a huge sum of stimulus money on a town slated for permanent closure. Congressman Boren and I are working closely with HUD to ensure taxpayer money is being spent appropriately. I am confident we will be able to ensure that happens. This is yet another example of the delegation working together to stand up for Oklahoma taxpayers.”

Investor’s Business Daily: Climate Of Control

Politics: Though the EPA says a cap-and-trade bill will do nothing if the developing world doesn’t cut CO2 emissions, Democrats are intent on passing a global warming law anyway. What is their real goal?
During Senate hearings last week on cap-and-trade legislation, Republican James Inhofe of Oklahoma produced a chart generated by the Environmental Protection Agency that shows it makes little difference what developed countries do to limit greenhouse gas emissions if undeveloped countries such as China and India don’t do the same.In response, and to her credit, EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson acknowledged that unilateral limits on carbon dioxide emissions “would not impact CO2 levels.” But Energy Secretary Steven Chu, without elaboration, simply said he didn’t agree with the chart. Which says a lot about how global warm-mongers react these days when confronted by facts.For the record, the EPA isn’t alone in its finding. A recent Massachusetts Institute of Technology study also concluded that “the different U.S. policies have relatively small effects on the CO2 concentration if other regions do not follow the U.S. lead.”

NYTIMES: Barrasso makes a name for himself fighting EPA, climate bill

Waving a handful of papers in the air at a recent Environment and Public Works Committee hearing, a Republican senator told the head of U.S. EPA that the nine-page memo he brandished proves her agency made political, not scientific, findings on possible regulations of carbon dioxide emissions. (NOTE: Watch Barrasso video here)

“This is a smoking gun,” the senator declared.

Such moments have become commonplace whenever EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson appears before the EPW Committee. But it is not Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), the former committee chairman and leading congressional skeptic on the science of global warming, asking the questions.

Instead, it is Sen. John Barrasso of Wyoming, who in his third year on Capitol Hill has made a name for himself fighting Jackson and other top Obama administration officials over the White House environmental policy.

Just last week, as the EPW panel dove into hearings on the climate bill, Barrasso grilled Jackson on allegations that the agency attempted to silence the views of EPA employees who warned against finalizing the agency’s proposed finding that greenhouse gases endanger human health and welfare.

Farmers Lose Big in Climate Bill, Farm Bureau Warns

In testimony before the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee today, (watch) Bob Stallman, President of the American Farm Bureau warned of the devastating costs imposed on farmers if the Waxman global warming bill is signed into law. In his testimony before the committee, Stallman stated, “increased input costs will put our farmers and ranchers at a competitive disadvantage with producers in other countries that do not have similar GHG restrictions. Any loss of international markets or resulting loss of production in the United States will encourage production overseas in countries where production methods may be less efficient than in the United States.”

“Let’s face it: as anyone familiar with agriculture knows, farming is an energy-intensive business with high-costs and low profit margins,” Senator Inhofe said in his opening statement. “So when the price of diesel, electricity, or natural gas goes up, farmers really feel the pinch. So it’s not surprising that a significant portion of the agricultural community opposes cap-and-trade, the purpose of which is to raise prices on the energy that farmers use.”

In Case You Missed it . . .

Sen. George Voinovich has placed a “hold” on President Obama’s pick to be the No. 2 official at U.S. EPA to complain over what the OhioRepublican says is an incomplete analysis of the House-passed global warming and energy bill. In a letter to EPA today, Voinovich said he was blocking Robert Perciasepe’s nomination to be the deputy administrator because of his “continued dissatisfaction” with the agency’s work on the climate legislation.
House Democrats widely trumpeted EPA’s study of the legislation — released just days before the floor vote — that shows the bill would cost American households $80 to $111 a year (E&ENews PM, June 23).
But Voinovich argues that EPA’s work contains a number of shortcomings, starting with the lack of any analysis on provisions establishing a nationwide renewable electricity standard and other requirements to reduce energy demand. “By excluding major portions of the legislation from analysis, EPA’s assessment is of limited value in determining how families and workers could be affected by the legislation,” Voinovich wrote.

Ag Opposes Cap-and-Trade

Note: Listen to Inhofe interview with Agri-Pulse as part of their “Open Mic” series. From the Agri-Pulse newsletter: “Our guest on Open Mic is Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-OK), Ranking Member of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee (E&PW) and a global warming skeptic, who reacts to E&PW Chairman Barbara Boxer’s (D-CA) decision to delay markup of climate change legislation until after the August recess. Inhofe cautions farm and commodity groups not to fall for the strategy of advocates of a cap and trade system, which he claims is to convince each group it will come out a winner, and explains why the 5-year deferral of international land use change requirements contained in the House-passed version will not survive a House-Senate conference committee.” With the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee convening a hearing tomorrow on the role of agriculture under a cap-and-trade system, EPW Policy Beat decided to highlight the significant, broad-based opposition to cap-and-trade and Waxman-Markey in the agricultural sector.

Inhofe: Put Nuclear Energy in the Energy Mix

Listen carefully in Washington, and almost everyone agrees that nuclear energy must be a part of our future domestic energy mix, and for good reason: Nuclear energy is the world’s largest source of carbon-free energy, generating over 70 percent of our emission-free electricity here in the U.S. Nuclear energy is a clean, safe, reliable and domestic source of affordable energy that has created 15,000 new jobs in the last year. The need to grow our domestic energy supply is clear. The Energy Information Administration projects that our demand for electricity will increase by 26 percent by the year 2030, requiring nearly 260 gigawatts of new electricity generation. Every source will need to grow and produce more energy to meet that demand. Curtis Frasier, executive vice president of Americas Shell Gas & Power, recently warned that the recession could be masking a global energy shortage: “When the economy returns, we’re going to be back to the energy crisis,” he said. “Nothing has been done to solve that crisis. We’ve got a huge mountain to climb.”