Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov 

E&E News

Darren Samuelsohn

July 13, 2009

Link to Article

Link to Voinovich Letter

Sen. George Voinovich has placed a "hold" on President Obama’s pick to be the No. 2 official at U.S. EPA to complain over what the OhioRepublican says is an incomplete analysis of the House-passed global warming and energy bill.

In a letter to EPA today, Voinovich said he was blocking Robert Perciasepe’s nomination to be the deputy administrator because of his "continued dissatisfaction" with the agency’s work on the climate legislation.

House Democrats widely trumpeted EPA’s study of the legislation — released just days before the floor vote — that shows the bill would cost American households $80 to $111 a year (E&ENews PM, June 23).

But Voinovich argues that EPA’s work contains a number of shortcomings, starting with the lack of any analysis on provisions establishing a nationwide renewable electricity standard and other requirements to reduce energy demand.

"By excluding major portions of the legislation from analysis, EPA’s assessment is of limited value in determining how families and workers could be affected by the legislation," Voinovich wrote.

The two-term senator also questioned what he said are "significant flaws that mask the economic consequences" of the House bill, which passed 219-212 and now awaits action in the Senate. Specifically, Voinovich narrowed in on EPA’s projections for the availability of international carbon offsets, as well as nuclear power and carbon capture and storage at coal-fired power plants.

Urging EPA to go back and do another review, Voinovich suggested, "The analysis should have a greater appreciation of the economic consequences that may result from a slower adoption of low-carbon technologies and greater scarcity of offsets than EPA assumes."

Voinovich also insisted in his letter that his hold "does not serve as a reflection on Mr. Perciasepe’s ability to perform in the role of the deputy administrator."

Perciasepe currently works as the National Audubon Society’s chief operating officer. Under the Clinton administration, he served as assistant administrator of EPA’s air and water offices. He also was Maryland’s top environmental official and Baltimore’s assistant planning director.

An EPA spokeswoman referred questions about Voinovich’s hold to the White House. Aides to Obama and Senate Environment and Public Works Committee Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

###