FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Contact:
Kristina Baum –
202.224.6176
Donelle Harder
– 202.224.1282
Senators
Call on EPA for Transparency in Real Costs for Proposed Ozone Standard
WASHINGTON,
DC – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), chairman of
the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works (EPW), today led Sens.
David Vitter (R-La.), Roger Wicker (R-Miss.), Mike Rounds (R-S.D), Jeff Sessions
(R-Ala.), Mike Crapo (R-Idaho), Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Dan Sullivan
(R-Alaska), Deb Fischer (R-Neb.), John Thune (R-S.D.), John Boozman (R-Ark.),
and John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) in a letter to Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) Adm. Gina McCarthy raising six red flags with how EPA is estimating the
impact of its proposed ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standard
(NAAQS).
“The
November 2014 draft Regulatory Impact Analysis (“draft RIA”) estimates that the
cost of lowering the standard could range from $3.9 billion to almost $39
billion in 2025 ($2011 dollars) depending on the standard and the assumptions
used. While these numbers are high, there are significant reasons to
believe that the draft RIA may underestimate the likely true cost to the
American public due to a number of questionable assumptions included in the
analysis,” the Republicans said in the letter.
EPA is in the process of lowering the national standard for ozone
from 75 parts per billion (ppb) to as low as 65 ppb, and even accepting
comments for 60 ppb. This proposed revision comes before the last two
standards have been fully implemented and the benefits fully realized – all at
a great cost to American taxpayers. According to a recent study by the
National Manufacturers Association, revising the standard to 65 ppb could
cost up to $1.7 trillion in GDP from 2017 to 2040 and result in
1.4 million fewer jobs through 2040. Approximately 40 percent of the
population still lives in areas not complying with the 2008 standard.
The full text of the letter is as follows:
March
10, 2015
The Honorable Gina McCarthy
Administrator
U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency
1200 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20460
Dear Administrator McCarthy:
EPA’s recently proposed
National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for ozone is likely to be the
costliest rule the Agency has ever proposed. The November 2014 draft
Regulatory Impact Analysis (“draft RIA”) estimates that the cost of lowering
the standard could range from $3.9 billion to almost $39 billion in 2025 ($2011
dollars) depending on the standard and the assumptions used.[1] While these numbers are high,
there are significant reasons to believe that the draft RIA may underestimate
the likely true cost to the American public due to a number of questionable
assumptions included in the analysis.
Inflated Baseline
Controls: EPA’s draft RIA estimates only the incremental costs of reducing
emissions above a “baseline” level of controls. One way to lower the
projected incremental costs is to assume more controls are imposed in the
baseline. For instance, EPA assumes in the baseline that the existing
ozone standard will be fully implemented, despite the fact that over 225
counties have yet to meet the existing standard. EPA also makes a number of
misleading assumptions that other regulations and proposals will be fully
implemented, such as CAFE, Tier 3, and the existing source proposal for
electric utility generating units (“Clean Power Plan”), greatly underestimating
the true cost of compliance with this proposal.
California costs are also
calculated separately, further underestimating the true potential cost of
compliance of a lowered NAAQS. The draft RIA estimates the annual cost to
California alone would be between $800 million and $2.2 billion.[2] Clearly, the rule’s estimate of
projected costs ignores the very substantial burden the American public has yet
to shoulder to meet the existing standard.
Arbitrarily Capping
Known Control Costs to $14,000/ton for NOx and $15,000/ton for VOCs. (p7-4 of
draft RIA): EPA also lowers compliance costs by arbitrarily assuming
that costs for known controls are capped.[3]
Private sector analyses, however, show that EPA is ignoring expensive and
politically unpalatable known measures, such as early retirement of stationary sources
and replacement of higher emitting mobile sources.
Focusing on only 2025:
While a snapshot of the annualized costs in the year 2025 is illustrative, it
does not provide the public with a full understanding of the likely costs of
the program and when these costs might peak. Nonattainment
designations will be made in 2017 and will be based on nearly-current air
quality conditions (i.e., ozone levels in the years 2014-2016). As a
result, many more counties will likely be designated as nonattainment in 2017
than the nine counties identified by EPA as still being in nonattainment in
2025. For example at 70 ppb, the high end of EPA’s proposed range,
approximately 350 counties would violate the lower standard based on current
ozone levels.[4] Many of these
counties and the surrounding areas will be forced to initiate expensive local
source control programs before 2025, even though EPA estimates only 9 counties
will still fail the 70 ppb standard by 2025. This suggests that the costs
estimated based only on 2025 conditions will omit costs and, in particular,
will omit costs that will occur in earlier years. We believe it would be
useful for the public to see the projected costs and benefits in other years as
well as the net present value costs of the full program.
Underestimating the
cost of unknown controls: One of the most important
assumptions used by EPA is the Agency’s estimate for the cost of “unknown”
controls. At 70 ppb, over 60 percent of the total costs of the program
are based on the costs of unknown controls. At 65 ppb, this number
jumps to roughly 75 percent of the estimated total costs of the program.[5] Any assumption regarding the
costs of unknown controls will clearly dominate the estimate of total and
annualized costs, and yet this is the most uncertain value in EPA’s cost
analysis.
As in past RIAs, EPA makes
the assumption that innovative strategies and new control options not known
today will appear in the near future. The problems with this
fundamental assumption should not be overlooked. Many counties in
California, Texas, and New England have failed to meet the existing standards,
despite decades of struggle. The fact these technologies are not yet
known given strong incentives dating back to the 1970s raises important
questions regarding whether and how quickly these controls will be developed.
EPA’s draft RIA not only
assumes the technologies will quickly develop, but that they will cost no more
on average than the costs of the more expensive emission controls being
employed today. This is at odds with EPA’s final RIA for the 2008 ozone
standard review where EPA evaluated unknown controls using both fixed cost
assumptions and a hybrid cost assumption that allowed for gradual increases in
costs overtime in line with standard marginal cost data. Unsurprisingly,
the hybrid assumption yields higher cost estimates. In the new draft RIA,
EPA has dropped the hybrid cost analysis altogether, further lowering its cost
estimates.
Ignoring Inflation:
EPA also lowers its fixed cost estimates for unknown controls in its new draft
RIA (compared to the 2008 RIA) by assuming the same fixed cost estimates for
unknown controls but in $2011 dollars rather than $2006 dollars.
This sleight of hand lowers the assumed fixed costs by another 10 percent or
more.
Ignoring Market
Prices: As EPA lowers the standard, more areas in the country,
including many in the Northeast and Southeast, will have to adopt
California-level controls before facing the uncertainty of unknown controls.
Emission trading markets in California and Texas give us a market-based
projection of how expensive these controls might actually be. For
Houston, the 2013 annualized offset prices for nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions,
a precursor for ozone, was $97,000 per year. In the California
South Coast, annualized offset prices for NOx have averaged over $106,000.[6]
The American public should
be skeptical of EPA’s cost estimates. In contrast to the 2008 RIA, EPA’s
draft 2014 RIA fails to show through whole economy modeling how these costs
will be distributed through the economy and what the economic impact of the
costs will be. The American public deserves to know more, and we
plan to seek answers to these important questions in the days ahead.
Sincerely,
[1]Regulatory Impact Analysis of the
Proposed Revisions the National Ambient Air Quality Standards for Ground-Level
Ozone (“RIA”), November 2014, at 7A-7 to 7A-8
###
[2]Id. at
ES-18
[3]Id. at
7-4
[4] EPA
fact sheet, Ozone By the Numbers, at 2
[5]RIA at
7A-7 and 7A-8
[6]RIA at
7-24.