March 9, 2015

NEWS: Senators Question Obama Administration’s Commitment to Public Input on Social Cost of Carbon Estimates

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Contact:
Kristina Baum – 202.224.6176
Donelle Harder – 202.224.1282 

 

Senators
Question Obama Administration’s Commitment to Public Input on Social Cost of
Carbon Estimates

 

WASHINGTON,
DC – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), chairman of the Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works (EPW), today led Sens. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.),
David Vitter (R-La.), John Barrasso (R-Wyo.), Roger Wicker (R-Miss.), Roy Blunt
(R-Mo.), John Boozman (R-Ark.), Deb Fischer (R-Neb.), Shelley Moore Capito
(R-W.Va.), James Lankford (R-Okla.), and Mike Rounds (R-S.D) in a letter to
Howard Shelanski, administrator for the Office of Information and Regulatory
Affairs (OIRA), on the social cost of carbon (SCC) estimates.  Today’s
letter renews congressional oversight interest in the SCC, questioning OIRA’s
commitment to accept public input on the SCC and to keep the public informed of
the status of the secretive Interagency Working Group (IWG) developing the SCC
estimates. 

 

“Congress and the American people deserve greater transparency and
government accountability regarding the social cost of carbon (SCC)—a
theoretical measure of climate change damages the Administration uses to
justify onerous regulations,”
the Republicans said in the letter.  “In fact, the
Administration has not provided the public with any new information on the
status of the SCC since the 2013 update.  Accordingly, we write to request
OIRA—as a steward of the regulatory process and IWG—fulfill its obligation to
be fully responsive to the public and Congress in these matters.”

 

The SCC is key to all the Administration’s climate benefit claims.  Last Congress, Senate Republicans raised a
number of concerns with the SCC estimates, including a lack of transparency in
the IWG’s process for developing the estimates, failure to comply with
regulatory guidance, technical deficiencies in the models used, questionable
assumptions selected, and lack of public participation.  Subsequently,
OIRA—the office convening the IWG—agreed to provide public comment on the
estimates in November 2013.  The comment period closed over a year ago on
Feb. 26, 2014, and they have not responded to
the comments or provided any public information on the status of the SCC. 
Yet, the administration has continued to use the SCC estimates to justify
burdensome regulations. 

 

“Above all, it is only reasonable for the public to know how OIRA
plans to use their comments.  We want to encourage public participation in
the regulatory process, not stifle it by ignoring those individuals who engaged
in the process by submitting comments,”
the Republicans concluded in the letter.

 

“Transparency is a friend of the American people, not the
enemy.  This administration has gone above and beyond to operate behind
closed doors, and has developed a pattern of ignoring dissenting views on its
aggressive climate agenda.  The social cost of carbon is no
different.  There is no reason it should take more than a year to respond
to the public comments, particularly when during the past year the
administration used the social cost of carbon to justify its most far-reaching
climate regulations. It is time for the administration to own up to the errors
in the estimates and make responses to the public comments a priority.  It
is time to give the public access to the methods used to justify burdensome
regulations and restore confidence in government accountability,”

said Chairman Inhofe.

 

The full text of the letter is as follows:

 

March
9, 2015

 

The Honorable Howard A. Shelanski

Administrator

Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs

725 17th Street, NW

Washington, DC 20503

 

Dear Administrator Shelanski:

 

           
Congress and the American people deserve greater transparency and government
accountability regarding the social cost of carbon (SCC)[1]—a
theoretical measure of climate change damages the Administration uses to
justify onerous regulations.  The estimates were developed by a secretive
Interagency Working Group (IWG) absent notice or public participation. 
Only after numerous written requests from Congress and the public, the Office
of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) agreed to provide the opportunity
for public comment on the SCC beginning November 26, 2013.[2] 
A year has passed since the comment period closed,[3]
but OIRA has not responded to the comments and it is unclear whether the
comments have been reviewed.  In fact, the Administration has not provided
the public with any new information on the status of the SCC since the 2013
update.  Accordingly, we write to request OIRA—as a steward of the
regulatory process and IWG—fulfill its obligation to be fully responsive to the
public and Congress in these matters.

 

While we continue to have
significant concerns over the process establishing and the substance underlying
the SCC, public information on the estimates is paramount given its increasing
application to federal—and state—programs.  Despite President Obama’s
Executive Order 13563 mandate to “promote predictability and reduce
uncertainty” in the regulatory system,[4]
the Administration has used the SCC in an expansive and erratic manner with
little to no public notice.  The SCC was first applied to Department of
Energy (DOE) conservation program standards and has since been cited in nearly
100 proposed and final rules from DOE, the Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA), and the Departments of Transportation, Housing and Urban Development,
and Agriculture.[5]  These include
some of the most expensive and burdensome regulations.  For example, all
the climate-related benefits of EPA’s Clean Power Plan were derived from the
SCC estimates.[6]  However,
evidence indicates severe deficiencies in the models used, so a review of the
public comments on the SCC could result in changes to the estimates and alter
the rule before it is made final.  Most recently, the Council on
Environmental Quality proposed use of the SCC in its revised draft guidance for
National Environmental Policy Act reviews,[7]
which may delay approval of individual infrastructure or energy development
projects.  Given these trends, OIRA responses to public comments on the
SCC could ameliorate the regulatory uncertainty over future application of the
estimates.  

  

OIRA responses to SCC
comments and public access to information on the IWG is also necessary to
comport with Presidential directives on the regulatory process.  At the
beginning of the Obama Administration, the President issued a Memorandum on
Transparency and Open Government, which directed agencies to “establish a
system of transparency, public participation, and collaboration”[8] because “[p]ublic engagement enhances
the Government’s effectiveness and improves the quality of its decisions.”[9]  Executive Order 13563 also
acknowledged the public must have a “meaningful opportunity to comment” in the
regulatory process.[10] 
Yet, in regards to the SCC, the Administration has largely ignored these
mandates. 

 

Above all, it is only
reasonable for the public to know how OIRA plans to use their comments. 
We want to encourage public participation in the regulatory process, not stifle
it by ignoring those individuals who engaged in the process by submitting comments. 
In an effort to preserve the integrity of the regulatory process and bring the
much needed level of transparency to the IWG, we respectfully request OIRA’s
cooperation and thorough responses to the following by no later than March 30,
2015:

 

Please
make arrangements for OIRA officials to provide a briefing for Congressional
staff on OIRA’s involvement in the IWG and role in the public comment process.

 

All
documents and communications referring or relating to OIRA’s plans for
reviewing the public comments.  Please provide all documents in electronic
format. 

 

How
many comments were submitted, including those submitted to the online docket as
well as those submitted directly to OIRA, during the public comment
period?  What were the major issues raised in the comments?  Do any
of the comments support revising the SCC estimates?  Please make public
all comments received on the SCC.

 

What
is OIRA’s process for reviewing the comments?  Please provide the names
and titles of reviewing officials and whether or not they participated in the
IWG.

 

What
is the status of reviewing the public comments?  Are there any plans for
responding to the comments?  If so, what is the reason for the delay in
responding to the comments?   Please specify the dates in which the review
started and ended or is anticipated to end.

 

Are
there any plans for making responses to comments available to the public
online?  If so, where will comments be posted?  Will responses to
comments on the SCC reflect a consensus of the IWG?

 

Has
the IWG reviewed the comments?  If so, what is the role of the IWG in
reviewing the comments?  Did the IWG review the comments after OIRA’s
review or was it a simultaneous review?  When did the IWG receive the
comments?  Please specify the IWG participants, including the names,
titles, and agency, of each IWG participant reviewing the comments, and the
dates in which each IWG participant’s review started and ended or is
anticipated to end. 

 

What
is the status of the IWG’s review of comments?  If the IWG has not
reviewed the comments, please indicate the reason and specify the plans, if
any, the IWG has for reviewing the comments.    

 

Has
the IWG reconvened to review the SCC estimates?  If so, please specify
what prompted its reconvening, the date it was reconvened, the number of times
and dates the IWG has met, when the group plans to meet in the future, as well
as who reconvened the group, the participants involved, the role of each
participant, and provide any new materials being considered by the IWG. 
If not, please specify whether there are any plans for reconvening the IWG,
including the date to be reconvened, expected participants and their role, and
provide any new material the IWG plans to consider.

 

Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.  If you
have any questions with this request, please contact the Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works at (202) 224-6176.

 

Sincerely,

 

###


[1] Interagency Working
Group on Social Cost of Carbon, Technical Support Document: Technical Update
of the Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory Impact Analysis under Exec. Order
12866
, U.S. GOV’T (May 2013),
http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/inforeg/social_cost_of_carbon_for_ria_2013_update.pdf.

[2] Technical Support
Document: Technical Update of the Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory Impact
Analysis Under Exec. Order No. 12866, 78 Fed. Reg. 70586 (Nov. 26, 2013), available
at
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2013-11-26/pdf/2013-28242.pdf.

[3] Comment period ended
February 26, 2014.  See Technical Support Document: Technical
Update of the Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory Impact Analysis Under Exec.
Order No. 12866, Notice of extension of public comment period, 79 Fed. Reg.
4359 (Jan. 27, 2014), available at
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2014-01-27/pdf/2014-01605.pdf.

[4] Exec. Order No.
13563, §1(a), 76 Fed. Reg. 3821 (Jan. 21, 2011).

[5]See Memorandum from Cong. Research Serv. to S. Comm. on
Env’t & Pub. Works (Jan. 26, 2015) (on file with Committee).

[6] Carbon Pollution
Emission Guidelines for Existing Stationary Sources: Electric Utility
Generating Units, 79 Fed. Reg. 34830 (June 18, 2014), available at
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2014-06-18/pdf/2014-13726.pdf.

[7] Revised Draft
Guidance for Federal Departments and Agencies on Consideration of Greenhouse
Gas Emissions and the Effects of Climate Change in NEPA Reviews, 79 Fed. Reg.
77802 (Dec. 24, 2014), available at
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2014-12-24/pdf/2014-30035.pdf.

[8] Memorandum from
President Barack Obama, Transparency and Open Government (Jan. 21,
2009), available at
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the_press_office/TransparencyandOpenGovernment.

[9]Id.

[10] Exec. Order No.
13563, §2(b), 76 Fed. Reg. 3821 (Jan. 21, 2011).

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share