The
Environment and Public Works Committee Republicans today released emails
between top officials at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),
including Gina McCarthy, and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC),
which demonstrate the very close working relationship between the two
organizations to develop the carbon rule – dating back to 2011 – two years
before EPA has said the public had an opportunity to provide input.
Sen.
David Vitter, top Republican on the EPW Committee, has launched the second
phase of his investigation into the collusion between environmental activists,
lawyers and lobbyists, billionaires and their supporting foundations who use
large sums of money to influence environmental public policy. Vitter,
along with Rep. Darrell Issa (R-Calif.), Chairman of the House Oversight and
Government Reform, have been investigating the inappropriate levels of
influence of the NRDC over the EPA. Click here to read Sen. Vitter and Rep. Issa’s release
launching the investigation into NRDC influence over EPA. Click here to access the previously released
communications between EPA and the NRDC.
"Even
though both sides have vehemently denied it, these discoveries clearly
demonstrate the EPA and NRDC’s beyond-cozy relationship and force the question
– Who is working for whom? The key example in all of this is the settlement
agreement on greenhouse gases when the NRDC sued the EPA, the EPA settled, and
the two celebrate the agreement. It doesn’t get any more blatantly obvious than
that," said Vitter. "The worst part in all of this – their carbon plan will
kill jobs across the country, decrease electricity reliability, and increase
the cost of energy for American families."
In
2010, the NRDC and others sued the EPA to force the agency to further restrict
greenhouse gas emissions. Later that year, the
EPA accomplished their joint plan, memorialized in a settlement
agreement. The same day the EPA announced the settlement agreement, we
now know Gina McCarthy and a top official at NRDC exchanged congratulatory
emails to one another. McCarthy went so far as to say, "This success
is yours as much as mine."
EPA
and NRDC then engaged in a series of meetings (see below) deliberating how to
regulate greenhouse gases from existing coal-fired power plants. In one
revealing exchange sent on June 8, 2011, an NRDC attorney sent McCarthy a power
point presentation that he had presented to an EPA "workgroup," which included
the basis of EPA’s recently proposed carbon rule. In response, McCarthy
wrote, "I would never say no to a meeting with you."
The
EPW Republicans Billionaire’s
Club report
disclosed that the Obama-led EPA has given NRDC $1,877,907 in taxpayer-funded
grants.
In
July, the New York Times exposed the close communication between the EPA
and NRDC when developing the Agency’s new carbon plan. Below is an excerpt from
the article:
"Over the next
two years the lawyers, David Doniger and David Hawkins, and the scientist,
Daniel Lashof, worked with a team of experts to write a 110-page proposal,
widely viewed as innovative and audacious, that was aimed at slashing planet-warming
carbon pollution from the nation’s coal-fired power plants. On June 2,
President Obama proposed a new Environmental Protection Agency rule to curb
power plant emissions that used as its blueprint the work of the three men and
their team." – Taking oil industry cue, environmentalists drew
emissions blueprint by Coral Davenport, July 6, 2014, New
York Times
The
NRDC and EPA have both denied this.
"The
letter claims NRDC played ‘an outsized role’ on these issues, which is
apparently the authors’ way of saying that EPA ended up agreeing with some of
what NRDC had to say. What exactly is the problem with this, other than
Vitter disagreeing with the policy EPA adopted? Oh, and the letter also
claims NRDC had ‘unprecedented access to high-level EPA officials’ – which is
doubtful – but why is it a subject of investigation that we got the chance to
make our case? So did states. So did industry."- Democracy 101: Or, what does David Vitter want? by David
Goldston, September 4, 2014, NRDC Switchboard Blog
"EPA
rebutted allegations by GOP lawmakers today that the Natural Resources Defense
Council had an outsized influence on its proposed rule to limit greenhouse gas
emissions from existing power plants.
"‘If anyone deserves credit for giving us ideas about how to approach the
problem, it’s the states and communities on the ground that are already cutting
pollution through the approaches we’re calling for in the proposal – cleaner,
more efficient energy, energy efficiency and renewable energy,’ said EPA
spokeswoman Liz Purchia." – EPA disputes allegations of undue NRDC influence on
climate plan by Erica Martinson, September 2, 2014,
Politico Pro Whiteboard
Below
are the newly released links to the communications between the EPA and NRDC:
- Influence
in Staffing Decisions: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Influence
in Staffing Decisions: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Close
Coordination on Messaging: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Close
Coordination on Messaging: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Close
Coordination on Messaging: www.epw.senate.govhttps://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on GHG Rulemakings: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on GHG Rulemakings: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on ESPS Rule: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on ESPS Rule: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on ESPS Rule: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on ESPS Rule: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- Collaboration
on ESPS Rule: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
- 06.06.2011
NRDC slides for EPA, Sec. 111: https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/InfluenceinStaffingDecisions3.pdf
-30-