Posted by: Matt_Dempsey@epw.seate.gov
Proponents of carbon regulation claim that it will extend only to “big polluters,” or large sources such as power plants and refineries, and any claims to the contrary—for example, that EPA’s tentacles will reach into every corner of the economy—are dismissed as so much fear mongering. Hence EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson, who, according to Business Week, “chuckled at the dire predictions from opponents of such regulation.” As Jackson said earlier this year, “Depending on who’s painting the picture, [we are told] EPA will regulate cows, Dunkin’ Donuts, Pizza Hut, your lawnmower and baby bottles.” “I haven’t figured out why baby bottles yet, but…just throw it in there. Somebody said to me today, ‘kittens’—I like that one.” (For the record, so do we.) And as for the notion that EPA’s tentacles could reach far and wide, Jackson said, “It is a myth.” In other words, pay no mind to those pesky Clean Air Act lawyers and cap-and-trade doomsayers who argue that greenhouse gas regulation could cover, say, hospitals.
FACT: But if the experience of British Columbia is any guide—and it should be, considering the affinity its government and the leaders of ours have for carbon regulation—Dr. Carbon is ready to see you now. According to Vancouver’s Surrey North Delta Leader, in a story headlined “Carbon Costs Add to Health Regions’ Woes,” health authorities in British Columbia “will have to dig more than $4 million a year out of their already stretched budgets to pay British Columbia’s carbon tax and offset their carbon footprints.” The paper quotes one Adrian Dix, a member of the Vancouver Legislative Assembly, who said, “You have public hospitals cutting services to pay a tax that goes to another 100 percent government-owned agency. That just doesn’t make sense.” The paper reports that the Fraser Health Authority in Vancouver will pay “$616,000 in carbon taxes this year, rising to $821,000 next year.” And by 2010, it will be paying “$1.3 million a year to the province’s Pacific Carbon Trust to offset its projected 52,600 tons of carbon emissions.” What’s more, the “Vancouver Coastal Health Authority also expects its costs will be close to $2 million next year in combined carbon tax and offset payments.” The paper found that “Fraser Health officials are grappling with a budget shortfall of more than $100 million and potential cuts to patient services, while low on their list, have not been ruled out.” Seems like a prescription for disaster.
###