Posted by David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
In the News…
E&E News
Obama’s face-to-face pitch does little to sway GOP
(05/25/2010)
Alex Kaplun, E&E reporter
President Obama’s visit to Capitol Hill today seemingly did little to move the ball forward on a sweeping climate and energy bill, as Republican senators said they continue see deep philosophical differences between the two sides and urged the president to a support a scaled-down version of the legislation.
Energy policy was one of several topics of discussion during a rare meeting between Obama and Senate Republicans today. The 90-minute visit marked only the second time during his presidency that Obama met with the Senate Republican caucus.
Obama did not answer questions from reporters upon exiting the meeting, saying only, "We had a good, frank discussion on a whole range of issues."
Republican senators had conflicting reports on the tone of the meeting. Sen. Mike Johanns (R-Neb.) said it was "very, very respectful," with give and take from Obama and lawmakers. But a number of GOP lawmakers described the meeting as "testy," and several said they believed the president was "combative" during some of the exchanges.
"I’m trying to ask myself why the president even asked for this meeting," said Sen. Roger Wicker (R-Miss.). "In terms of advancing the agenda for the rest of the year, I don’t think it pushed any issues closer to passage."
Several Republican senators said that Obama called on them to support the climate change legislation sponsored by Sens. John Kerry (D-Mass.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.), along with items such as the war supplemental, the tax extenders package and immigration reform.
But Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), one of about a half-dozen lawmakers to ask Obama a question, said he urged the president to look at supporting more scaled-back legislative efforts that had a higher likelihood of political success.
"On energy and climate, the way you move forward is you have a comprehensive approach you can sell, and I don’t think many people believe that the oil spill has helped to get more voters on offshore drilling," Graham said. "It’s made it a harder climb, so let’s do smaller versions of an energy, climate bill."
"Maybe I’m wrong, but I don’t see 60 votes right now for cap and carbon and expanding offshore drilling," Graham said.
Asked if Obama appeared supportive of passing an energy bill that did not include the cap-and-trade components, Graham responded, "Not particularly."
Graham did say that he praised Obama for being willing to consider expansion of both offshore drilling and nuclear power. "For a Democratic president, he has been very forward-leaning on expanding nuclear power, and I think that’s good," Graham said. "He was very good on expanding offshore drilling. I think he’s done some things that will help us on the energy-climate debate in the future."
But overall, the statements on climate and energy were all in line with Obama’s "normal pitch," according to Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), a staunch opponent of climate change legislation.
"I don’t believe anything he said will change what would have happened had he not come into the meetings," said Inhofe, ranking member of the Environment and Public Works Committee. "I don’t say that in an insultive way, I’m just saying that the positions that he held are positions that are well-defined in terms of our opposition to them, Republican opposition, so I don’t think any of that changed."
Foreign Relations Committee ranking member Richard Lugar (R-Ind.) said that while Obama expressed hope that the Senate would move climate and energy legislation this year, he did not rank the legislation in comparison to the other major legislative priorities. "He was very careful to indicate that he did not want to jeopardize immigration as opposed to climate change as opposed to anything else," Lugar said. "He’s open — wants to meet people halfway."
Other Republicans took a much more skeptical view of the president’s visit, saying they received only a list of the president’s agenda with little indication that he would be willing to work with them in a bipartisan manner.
"He just went through a litany of seven or eight things that he’d like to see happen, and he wanted to do it in a bipartisan way," said Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.). "And my question is, again, ‘How can you reconcile that duplicity?’ meaning that you say that, but yet the big issues that we’ve dealt with have been constructed in such a way to absolutely be partisan."
The White House released a statement after the meeting with Republicans in which it said the president told the caucus that the Gulf of Mexico oil spill should hasten the need for action. "There were continued differences on some of these issues," said the White House. "But, the president believes that direct dialogue is better than posturing, and he was pleased to have the opportunity to share views with the conference."
White House officials also downplayed the notion that the meeting was contentious, with a White House spokesman describing it as "civil in tone."
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) also said after the meeting that it met his expectations and that it was unreasonable to expect any major legislative breakthrough from one face-to-face meeting. "I don’t think we were going to hash out an agreement on anything with a whole big group like that," McConnell said. "But it was a good exchange, a candid exchange on both sides, and we’re glad the president came up."
"Surely, you didn’t think we were going to walk out of there with some specific agreement on one of these issues," McConnell added. "That was not anticipated by him or by us."
Climate schedule to be determined after break
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) said he intends to meet with relevant committee leaders after the Memorial Day recess to determine the agenda for energy legislation. Reid added that "everything was on the table" as far as which particular incarnations of the energy bill the Senate might take up this year.
Kerry, however, said he believed that Obama and other top Democrats were committed to pushing the bill to passage once Congress returned from the break.
"The president is going to be engaged in this, he’s committed to try to help find the people to support it and work on it," Kerry said. "I think people come back with their batteries recharged and we begin to, you know, have the president be engaged personally and the White House and so forth."
Asked if he believed that Obama needed to lobby individual lawmakers, Kerry said, "I think the president has to do what he needs to do to get votes. And I think it involves a wide range of activities presidents have at their disposal. And I think the president is prepared to do that."
###