FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Contact:
Kristina Baum –
202.224.6176
Donelle Harder
– 202.224.1282
Senate EPW Republicans Take a Stand for Academic Freedom
WASHINGTON, DC – U.S.
Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-OKla.), Chairman of the Senate Committee on Environment and
Public Works (EPW), today led all EPW Republicans in
a letter promoting scientific discovery and academic freedom. The
letter was sent to the same 107 recipients of letters sent earlier this
week by Congressional Democrats to universities, private companies, trade
groups, and non-profit organizations, asking for detailed information on
funding climate science. As explained in the EPW Republican letter sent today,
there is a real concern the Democrats inquiry may impose a chilling effect on
scientific inquiry and free speech.
“Rather than empower
scientists and researchers to expand the public discourse on climate science
and other environmental topics, the [Democrats] letter could be viewed as an
attempt to silence legitimate intellectual and scientific inquiry,” said the Senators in
today’s letter.
There has been a
public outcry in response to the Democrats letters. Noted climate scientist,
Dr. Michael Mann spoke of the letters calling them “heavy handed and overly
aggressive.” Earlier today the American Meteorological Society warned that the
letters sent by Congressional Democrats send a “chilling message to all
academic researchers.”
“At the end of the
day, those disagreeing with certain scientific findings should judge them based
on whether or not they are sound and transparent,” said
Chairman Inhofe.
The full text of the
letter is as follows:
February 27, 2014
Dear _______,
We write in regards to the recent request for information on your support of
scientific research initiated by several of our colleagues in the United States
Congress. At the outset, we are deeply concerned the letter calls into
question the importance of scientific discovery and academic freedom.
Rather than empower scientists and researchers to expand the public discourse
on climate science and other environmental topics, the letter could be viewed
as an attempt to silence legitimate intellectual and scientific
inquiry.
Federal government-sponsored research is good and necessary, but such funding
has limits. The federal government does not have a monopoly on funding
high-quality scientific research, and many of the nation’s environmental laws
require decisions be based on the best scientific information available—not
just federally funded research. At the core of American ingenuity are
those researchers who challenge the status quo whether in matters of climate,
economics, medicine, or any field of study. Institutions of
higher-learning and non-governmental funding are vital to facilitating such
research and scientific inquiry. Limiting research and science to only
those who receive federal government resources would undermine and slow
American education, economic prosperity, and technological advancement.
The credibility of a scientific finding, research paper, report, or advancement
should be weighed on its compliance with the scientific method and ability to
meet the principles of sound science; in short, it should be weighed on its
merits. The scientific method is a process marked by skepticism and
testing, rather than dogma. If the work can be reproduced and independent
experts have a fair chance to validate the findings then it is sound,
irrespective of funding sources. Science the federal government uses to
support regulatory decisions should also comply with the integrity, quality,
and transparency requirements under the Information Quality Act and Office of
Management and Budget Guidelines.
Indeed, science is only one criterion we must take into
consideration when developing laws and regulations. Credible deliberation
requires thoughtful analysis and an understanding of the economy, policy, and
legal framework in which we function. Dissenting opinions fostered
through the encouragement of all ideas is what truly facilitates intellectual
prosperity and political discourse.
The
letter you received from our colleagues is a wholly inappropriate effort to challenge
these well-accepted truths. We ask you to not be afraid of political
repercussions or public attacks regardless of how you respond. Above all,
we ask that you continue to support scientific inquiry and discovery, and
protect academic freedom despite efforts to chill free speech.
Sincerely,
Sen. Jim Inhofe,
Chairman
Sen. David Vitter
Sen. John Barrasso
Sen. Shelley Moore
Capito
Sen. Mike Crapo
Sen. John Boozman
Sen. Jeff Sessions
Sen. Rodger F. Wicker
Sen. Deb Fischer
Sen. Mike Rounds
Sen. Dan Sullivan
###