Media supporters of a carbon tax wrote of a new found “momentum” for climate change amendments in the weeks leading up to the Energy Bill debate. “Senate warming to idea of need to cut emissions,” wrote the editors at the Palm Beach Post. The Dallas Morning News stated, “Some time in the next couple of weeks, as the U.S. Senate hammers out an energy bill, its members are expected to endorse the first national legislation to curb emissions of greenhouse gases.” The Christian Science Monitor reported, “Momentum is gaining for floor votes this week or next on measures to curb the carbon emissions.” The New York Times said, “There is speculation that a less ambitious but also less costly bill sponsored by Jeff Bingaman, Democrat of New Mexico, and modeled after proposals from the bipartisan National Commission on Energy Policy, could win a filibuster-proof 60 votes.” Fact: And simple speculation it appears to be. This alleged “momentum” of climate change legislation either never existed or is rapidly grinding to a halt. One needs to look no farther than the internal revolt taking shape within the environmental special interest community: “Outlook Dim for Climate Change Action as Energy Bill Nears Senate Floor” writes Bush Green Watch, the website funded by Moveon.org. The McCain-Lieberman amendment, having suffered defeat twice previously in the Senate, is under assault by its once strident supporters in the environmental special interest community: In disgust, Greenpeace issued a press release stating McCain-Liberman “has simply become a corporate handout to the nuclear power industry.” Legislative Director of U.S PIRG Anna Aurillo says, “We like the original version of McCain-Lieberman, not the Chuckie , evil version.” Liberal special interests united against including the Sierra Club, U.S. PIRG, Public Citizen, Friends of the Earth, Clean Water Action signed a letter to every member of congress opposing McCain-Lieberman. The Bingaman amendment also suffers from barrage of criticism: Dan Lashof, science director for the Natural Resources Defense Council’s Climate Center says, “This trading scheme is watered down to the point where it is basically ineffectual in getting us on the path,” adding “If the Hagel provision is a fig leaf for the climate problem, this is basically a banana leaf.” Senator McCain agreed in part saying anything less than McCain-Lieberman “is a fig leaf, is a joke,” and nothing but a “hoax.” A new report from the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), the Bingaman (NCEP cap-and-trade) amendment would only reduce temperatures by 0.008oC in temperature by 2050 (assuming climate alarmists are correct). While there are apparent divisions within the liberal environmental special interest community over which amendment to support, one fact is clear: both amendments provide virtually no benefit at astonishing costs to American families and businesses. The McCain-Lieberman amendment, according to the most recent Charles River Associates (CRA) study, would: cost more than one million American jobs over the next 15 years, impose an additional cost of $810 dollars a year on households, increase already high gasoline prices by 55 cents a gallon, increase electricity prices 20% by 2020, increase the cost of natural gas by 47%, and result in the aversion of 0.029ºC in temperature – assuming climate alarmists are correct about causation. According to the new report from CEI, the Bingaman (NCEP cap-and-trade) amendment would: reduce cumulative U.S. GDP by $588 billion from 2010 to 2025, result in the loss of 171,000 non-farm jobs in 2025, and result in virtually no benefit to justify such costs – the aversion of 0.008oC in temperature by 2050.