Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

 

Senator Inhofe: …That’s my question.

Administrator Jackson: I have a two word answer – I disagree.  But, just let me respond to three things, Senator, and I’m happy to do additional things for the record if that’s necessary.  I do not agree that the IPCC has been totally discredited in any way.  In fact, I think it’s important to understand that the IPCC is a body that follows impartial and open and objective assessments.  Yes, they have had concerns about email, I do not defend the conduct of those who sent those emails.  There is peer review, which is part of the IPCC process.  There are numerous, numerous groups of teams and independent researchers all a part of coming up with IPCC findings, such that even the IPCC has said, “Wow, we need to investigate and ensure that our scientists are held to a standard of scientific conduct that we can be proud of.  We stand behind our findings.”  And so, I can’t agree with you there.  I’m sure you’re not surprised.  I don’t agree with you on the job killing. I actually believe as the President does that we have to have a foundation for growth in this country, and that Americans want clean energy and see the value of investing in a future for generations to come.  And if we want to make that investment, we have to change from being totally dependent on fossil-based power without controls for carbon, without a price for carbon, and we have to do that.  And I have to tell you that it strikes me when I hear about these doom-and-gloom forecasts for economic ruin that you know, the Clean Air Act Amendments predicted a quiet death for business across the country, that’s what we were told.  A cap-and-trade program, a program to reduce pollution through market incentives, and what really happened is that the US economy grew by 64% even as acid rain pollution was cut by 50%.  There are ways to make smart environmental investments and policy.  I commit to you, sir, that I would do nothing less.  As I sit in the chair, it is too important to our country, economically but also environmentally.  But to sit here and say that these policies and a move towards clean energy won’t be good for jobs in this country, I simply can’t agree.

Senator Inhofe: You know, I would appreciate it if I were the one who was saying this, but this is MIT, the Wharton school, they talk about the economic destruction of our country.  And then of course, the comment you made I do appreciate, except that is the reason why I quoted all the, the Atlantic, the Guardian, all these newspapers, all these publications, who are now saying that the science wasn’t right.  So, it’s not me saying it, I’m quoting others, because I don’t have the credibility – I understand that, but certainly when the whole nation turns around and people say – this should be a wake-up call, we’re basing this major step, this endangerment on science that we know now is flawed.  And that’s the reason I quote other sources, so I don’t have to quote myself. 

Administrator Jackson: Well, I think we have to quote sources like the National Academies of Science.  I think we have to talk about the…

Senator Inhofe: What about the IPCC, isn’t that a pretty good source?

Administrator Jackson: Well, we just talked about the IPCC, and said that I absolutely agree you can look into emails and any allegations that come up, but that, you know, science can be a bit messy, the dust will settle, but I have not at this point seen anything that changes my belief that the endangerment finding is not only on sound ground but will stand up to scrutiny and challenge.

Senator Inhofe: And the IPCC said the science is not settled.  Thank you, Madame Chairman.