Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
Sen. Inhofe: Providing Responsible Oversight of Federal Ethanol Policy
Questioning Ethanol’s Compatibility with Existing Engines, Transportation and Infrastructure Needs, Economic Sustainability, and Environmental and Public Health Impacts.
With the passage of the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (EISA), Congress doubled the corn-based ethanol mandate despite mounting questions about ethanol’s compatibility with existing engines, its transportation and infrastructure needs, its economic sustainability-and numerous other issues. Then, as now, Senator Inhofe argued that the fuels industry and engine manufacturers need more time to understand and manage the myriad challenges of an unrealistic corn-based ethanol mandate.
The most pressing issue facing corn ethanol is the so-called "blend wall". EISA mandated 15 billion gallons of corn-based ethanol by 2015. Yet, long-standing federal regulations require that a gallon of gasoline should contain no more than 10 percent ethanol. So there will soon be more corn ethanol production than the amount of ethanol allowed in gasoline. So what is the solution?
Corn ethanol advocates have the wrong approach. Rather than reform EISA’s corn mandates, they have successfully lobbied EPA for higher, mid-level ethanol blends in gasoline – higher than E10. EPA recently approved the use of E15 in all 2001 and newer light duty cars and trucks. Sounds like a simple solution, except its consequences could be dire, with potential damage to agriculture, the environment, and engine equipment manufacturers.
Unrealistic corn ethanol mandates have made it very difficult to purchase clear gas, or gasoline without ethanol, despite strong consumer demand for this product. As he travels throughout Oklahoma, Sen. Inhofe frequently hears this complaint. In order to address this problem, Senator Inhofe proposed legislation in the previous Congress that will enable states to opt out of the corn-ethanol portions of the Renewable Fuel Standard mandate, which will ensure the availability of clear gas. Senator Inhofe plans on reintroducing the legislation soon in the 112th Congress.
Learn More about Senator Inhofe’s Ethanol Legislation and EPA Oversight:
LISTEN: Inhofe on Grandy Group Talks About Effort to Stop EPA Energy Tax and New Alliance on Ethanol – (02/07/11)
Inhofe Welcomes Boxer Commitment to Hold EPW Hearing on Ethanol 01/31/11)
Senators Snowe, Inhofe Request EPA Evaluation of E15 Waiver on Fuel Supply (01/06/11)
Inhofe: EPA’S E15 Action Confirms Flaws in Fuel Mandate (10/13/10)
Inhofe: New Bill Restores Consumer Choice at the Pump (08/10/10)
Inhofe Op-Ed: Don’t Increase Ethanol Percentage in Gasoline (07/29/09)
Letters
Bipartisan letter sent to EPA on the unintended consequences of the E15 Waiver (01/06/11)
Letter sent to EPA along with Senator Snowe regarding reduced availability of pure gasoline (01/05/11)
Letter from 39 stakeholders requesting a Senate hearing on mid-level ethanol blends (08/25/10)
Ethanol and Inhofe in the Press
The Oklahoman: Inhofe, environmentalists on same side – (02/06/11)
VIDEO: Oklahoma Matters with Ed Kelley: Ethanol has given Jim Inhofe a strange bedfellow (02/03/11)
Tulsa World: Inhofe’s new allies on ethanol issue surprising (01/30/11) – Inhofe again stepped up his efforts against ethanol after the Environmental Protection Agency’s decision to allow gasoline that contains more than 10 percent ethanol to be sold for newer model passenger vehicles. He believes he has won a commitment from Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., chairwoman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, to hold a hearing on ethanol. "We are rolling. We are going to get this done," said Inhofe, the panel’s top Republican. A date for that hearing has not been announced. During his frequent travels across Oklahoma, the senator said, he runs across signs promoting the availability of "100 percent gas." "What I am doing is very popular right now," Inhofe said, adding that he routinely hears from Oklahomans who do not want to use gasoline with ethanol. Concerns over ethanol include potential damage to certain engines, confusion at the pump, lack of availability for "clear" gasoline, lower mileage for fuel with ethanol and higher feed stock prices for farmers. Inhofe has warned that the EPA is pushing too much ethanol too fast and criticized Congress for doing too little to provide appropriate oversight of such decisions.
Reuters: EPA Ethanol Expansion Hardens a Divide (01/27/11) – But Inhofe, one of the Senate’s longest-serving climate change deniers, doesn’t see eye-to-eye with Grassley. He has questioned ethanol’s compatibility with existing engines, its transportation and infrastructure needs, its economic sustainability and its environmental and public health impacts. For instance, Inhofe joined other legislators – including Sens. Susan Collins, R-Maine, Jack Reed, D-R.I. and Ben Cardin, D-Md. – earlier this month to write a letter to the EPA outlining their opposition to the E15 decision and its unintended consequences. Inhofe said he plans to reintroduce legislation addressing the lack of availability of ethanol-free gasoline."This approach will restore choice at the pump," the Oklahoman said, "and allow fuel producers to respond to market demands, specifically, when and where consumers prefer clear gas."
Tulsa World: Sullivan, Inhofe blast EPA ruling on ethanol (01/22/11) – Republican Sen. Jim Inhofe, a major player in Congress on environmental and transportation issues, also urged oversight hearings on the EPA and its latest ethanol announcement. Democrats, however, set the agenda in the Senate. "EPA’s latest action continues to push too much ethanol too fast,” Inhofe said. "I have expressed serious concerns about ethanol and related fuels issues since passage of the 2007 energy bill.” He said that measure doubled the corn-based ethanol mandate despite mounting questions about ethanol’s compatibility with existing engines, its economic sustainability, its environmental impact and its transportation needs.
Des Moines Register: Senate ethanol opponents attack E15 plan (01/20/11) – That means fewer stations may sell ethanol-free gasoline for use by consumers who are trying to avoid putting ethanol in boats and power equipment."This situation is occurring today in many rural regions of our country. Recently, the major distributor of pure gasoline in New England ceased providing this fuel to local distributors causing a scramble to locate additional supplies," wrote Republican Sens. Olympia Snowe of Maine and Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma. Inhofe is the ranking Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee.
The Hill: Senators mount opposition to EPA’s decision to allow higher ethanol blends (01/07/11) – A bipartisan coalition of senators are mounting increased opposition to the Environmental Protection Agency’s decision to allow some vehicles to fuel up with higher blends of ethanol in their gasoline. In two consecutive letters to the EPA this week, the senators criticized the EPA’s decision to allow 15 percent ethanol blends (E15) in gasoline for model year 2007 and newer vehicles, and asked the agency to analyze the effects of increased ethanol use on the vehicle fleet.
Tulsa World: Inhofe rips EPAs approval of increased ethanol use (10/14/10) – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe said Wednesday that a decision by the Environmental Protection Agency to allow an increase in ethanol for fuel used in newer vehicles would have little impact on consumers or the marketplace. "That’s because very few of the nation’s retailers will actually sell E-15 anytime in the foreseeable future," Inhofe, R-Okla., said, referring to the fuel, which can contain as much as 15 percent ethanol. "The reasons are straightforward: substantial fuel tank and dispensing infrastructure costs as well as liability issues associated with misfueling and potential engine damage." Inhofe also said the EPA’s action to allow E-15 for vehicles built since the 2007 model year again points to the need for Congress to revise the 2007 Energy Independence and Security Act, which includes a mandate for corn-based ethanol.
E&E News: Groups Request Senate Hearing on EPA’s E15 decision (08/25/10) – Thirty-nine industry and environmental groups requested a Senate hearing next month to examine U.S. EPA’s handling of a proposal that would boost the amount of ethanol blended in gasoline. In a letter to Environment and Public Works Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) and the panel’s ranking Republican, James Inhofe of Oklahoma, the groups say there are too many unanswered questions about EPA’s looming decision on whether to increase ethanol in gasoline from 10 percent to 15 percent. EPA is expected to decide the matter this fall after the Energy Department completes vehicle testing.
The Hill: Inhofe Crafting Measure To Allow States To Offer Pure Gasoline (06/24/10) – The legislation would provide for states to offer pure gasoline alongside ethanol-gas mixtures, for which federal regulations currently call. Ethanol is supposed to make up 10 percent of the content of gas sold in the United States. An aide to Inhofe said that they see optimism for bipartisan support for the option, possibly along the fault lines seen in the 2007 energy bill, where some conservatives joined liberals, driven by environmental concerns, in opposition to the ethanol mandates.
National Media Coverage
The Hill: Draft EPA report: Biofuels threaten habitat, water quality (01/28/11) – The draft finds, for instance, that growing biofuels crops can affect water quality through erosion and fertilizer runoff, among other factors. The report comes as ethanol is already under attack from some environmentalists, and lawmakers seeking to strip tax subsidies. But renewable fuels are valued as a way to displace oil reliance and boost rural economies, and retain powerful political support on Capitol Hill.
New York Times: E.P.A. Approves Increased Ethanol in Auto Fuel (01/21/11) – Service-station owners, meanwhile, have noted that many of their pumps are not certified by Underwriters Laboratories to pump E15, and few are willing to incur the expense to replace equipment to accommodate the new formulation. And despite the E.P.A.’s assurances, some motorists and engine manufacturers still might require further convincing that higher formulations would not cause engine damage and thereby void vehicle warranties.
Wall Street Journal: EPA to Allow Higher Ethanol Blends in 2001-06 Autos (01/20/11) – Livestock ranchers, auto makers and oil refiners have all challenged the Obama administration’s efforts to expand ethanol use in cars. While the groups have varying motives for opposing greater corn-ethanol production, they-along with many environmentalists-generally say the government hasn’t conducted sufficient testing to warrant higher concentrations of ethanol in motor fuels. Some have also expressed concern that encouraging more ethanol production could exacerbate the recent run-up in food prices, by diverting corn away from food production to fuel production, but the ethanol industry has disputed such criticisms.
Consumer Reports: EPA approves E15 fuel, raises concerns EPA approves E15 fuel, raises concerns (01/24/11) – On Friday, the EPA released a long-awaited decision allowing the use of 15-percent ethanol in regular gasoline to be burned in cars made from 2001 to 2006. Gas station owners, as well as makers of boats, snowmobiles, and yard equipment, resisted the move, saying the EPA’s proposal for signage is inadequate and consumers might use the fuel in non-approved products, risking premature failure. E15 is still not approved for use in cars older than the 2001 model year. So today’s regular fuel, which often contains 10-percent ethanol, or E10, will still be available.
Stakeholders Speak Out
New York Times: E.P.A. Approves Use of More Ethanol in Gasoline (01/21/11) – The National Association of Clean Air Agencies, which represents state and local clean-air officials, said that burning higher ethanol blends would result in increased emissions of nitrogen oxides, an ingredient of smog, and other harmful pollutants.
Release: Farm and Food Industry Groups Oppose EPA Decision on Corn-Based Ethanol (10/13/10) – A coalition of farm and food industry trade associations representing every step of the food chain from meat and poultry producers, restaurants, bakers to other food manufacturers today issued the following statement in response to the Environmental Protection Agency’s announcement that it would allow the sale of gasoline containing 15 percent ethanol ("E15") for cars manufactured in the 2007 model year or later…These farm and food industry groups criticized the decision, noting that it is certain to accelerate the recent dramatic rise in corn prices, and questioned whether the EPA decision is legally sound. Members of the Coalition include the American Meat Institute, the Grocery Manufacturers Association, the National Council of Chain Restaurants, the National Chicken Council, the American Frozen Food Institute, the American Bakers Association, the National Meat Association and the National Turkey Federation.
NPRA Says EPA Decision on E15 Could Hurt Consumers (01/21/11) – Charles T. Drevna, president of NPRA, the National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, issued the following statement in response to the decision by the Environmental Protection Agency today approving a 50 percent increase in the amount of ethanol allowed in gasoline used by cars and light trucks manufactured in the 2001-2006 model years: "EPA has acted without adequate scientific evidence to endanger the gasoline-powered engines used by millions of Americans in their vehicles and outdoor power equipment. Widespread use of 15 percent ethanol in gasoline could cause engine failures that could leave consumers stranded, injured or worse, and hit consumers with costly engine repairs. It’s the wrong decision, at the wrong time, made for the wrong reasons.
Documents and Reports
Comments submitted to EPA on E15 rule from the Environmental Working Group
Other
Link to EPA Announcement on E15 Partial Waiver Decision
In an effort to help provide information for constituents, the Inhofe-EPW Press office has created this webpage. If you need more information, please feel free to contact Matt Dempsey at Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov.