Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202)224-9797

 

 

EPW POLICY BEAT: IT’S BTU ALL OVER AGAIN 

 

From the Inhofe-EPW Press Office   

 

 

As George Santayana once said, “Those who cannot learn from history are condemned to repeat it.”  Go back to 1993: the House considers a destructive BTU (British Thermal Units) tax on energy, passing it by just six votes, 219 to 213.  The Senate thinks briefly about the tax, and then unceremoniously dumps it, leaving those House members who voted for the measure holding the proverbial bag.  Fast forward to 2009: proponents of the Waxman-Markey bill are studying history, and they know that ramming through a controversial energy tax, only to have it die in the Senate, is bad politics.  “The first thing we need to do is see whether we can come together around a consensus position in the committees in the House, and that’s what we’re working on,” Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md), told the Hill Newspaper.  “And then, of course, if we were able to arrive at that, the question is whether you would take it to the floor, or do you wait to see if anything develops on the Senate side,” he said.  “The chances of doing cap-and-trade in the Senate are much more difficult. We recognize that,” he added.  As Yogi Berra might have said, “It’s BTU all over again.” 

 

The House-Senate energy dynamic is not the only similarity between the BTU tax and cap-and-trade.  EPW Policy Beat recently read a 1993 paper by the National Center for Policy Analysis (http://www.ncpa.org/pub/bg127) examining the BTU tax.   As would be expected, the issues surrounding BTU and cap-and-trade—that is, their distributional effects, their regional effects, the regressive nature of both, etc.—are nearly identical.  And the arguments fashioned by proponents of the BTU tax and cap-and-trade, not surprisingly, look remarkably similar. 

 

 

Here are the excerpts that illustrate the almost comic similarities: 

 

 

A beneficial tax. “Proponents of the energy tax point to several benefits. They argue that the tax would (1) significantly reduce the budget deficit and therefore lower interest rates and raise investment, (2) reduce America’s dependence on foreign oil, (3) benefit the environment by encouraging energy conservation and (4) be fair and affordable for all income groups because the tax on low-income families would be offset by increases in low-income support programs.”

 

 

Energy tax as panacea.  “In sum, over the past several decades the energy tax has been touted as a panacea for almost every economic and ecological crisis that has confronted the country. Even though the arguments for the energy tax have proved groundless, support for the concept has never waned.”

 

 

Presidential tax promises.  “Bill Clinton ran for president pledging not to raise taxes on the middle class. Although the energy tax clearly violates this campaign promise, during his State of the Union address President Clinton assured Americans that the energy tax would cost the typical middle-income family just $17 per month – or $204 per year. This estimate is highly suspect, however, because all other forecasts – including government forecasts – say that the burden on middle-income families would be much higher.”

 

 

Regional impacts.  “The actual impact on particular families would depend on where they live, how much energy they use in the home, what types of products they buy and how much driving they do. Contrary to the administration’s claim that the energy tax hits all regions of the country equally, energy usage and production vary widely by state. Even if the tax applied to energy uniformly, the tax incidence would be much higher for residents of some states than others. The fact that different tax rates are applied to different types of energy makes the impact even less fair.”

 

 

A regressive tax. “The Clinton administration argues that low-income families would not be made worse off because of the energy tax. The truth is that an energy tax is among the most regressive of all possible taxes.”

 

 

Trying to keep the poor whole. “Although the administration proposes to increase government subsidies for low-income families by the average amount of the BTU tax they would pay, roughly half of the low-income families would have energy tax liabilities that are above the average.  Hence, for millions of poor families, a higher EITC and higher welfare benefits would not fully compensate for higher energy taxes.”

 

 

A hidden tax.  “The Clinton energy tax is largely a hidden tax. That is, the tax would not show up as a separate item when goods were purchased. Rather, it would be embedded in the production cost of the goods and services we buy. This is quite deliberate. White House officials have admitted that one reason the administration opted for a BTU tax is that it is less conspicuous than a gas tax. And they have resisted, in some cases unsuccessfully, moving the tax collection point closer to the final consumer.”

 

 

Higher prices across the board. “Some of the increased cost of production would be paid directly by consumers through higher gas prices, heating costs and electric utility bills. Consumers would also pay indirectly for the energy tax at the supermarket, the drug store and the shopping mall. White House economic adviser Robert Rubin conceded as much when he said, ‘The notion is [that] this BTU tax would get passed on to consumers.’”

 

 

Weakening international competitiveness.  “The BTU tax could weaken the international competitiveness of major U.S. industries. Currently, low energy costs are a primary advantage for U.S. manufacturers competing with Japanese, Korean and European industries. Low energy costs help U.S. industry keep production costs low. Proponents of the energy tax contend that U.S. industry would not be hurt by the energy tax, because energy costs would still be lower in the United States than in competitor nations. However, unlike the Clinton proposal, Japan and most European nations exempt industrial fuel from their energy taxes.”

 

 

Lower profits, fewer jobs. “As the auto and airline industries illustrate, the energy tax would impose substantial new costs on American manufacturers. For many industries, the BTU tax would almost certainly require layoffs as well as delays or cancellations of planned plant expansions and new hiring – and it would lower profits. Several studies that attempted to quantify the job loss and economic growth reduction from the BTU tax have arrived at remarkably similar estimates.”

###