The Office of the Inspector General
(OIG) of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) was designed to be
independent of political influence while investigating and preventing waste,
fraud, and abuse at the Agency. Recent reports coming from the OIG have
raised concerns from the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works (EPW)
Republicans due to a lack of transparency and potential bias when crafting and
researching their reports. Below are three examples showing how the OIG
has failed to impartially investigate the Agency and has simply rubberstamped
EPA’s controversial practices. EPW Republicans believe it is time for Congress
to have more scrutiny over what is going on in the IG’s office at EPA.
OIG Ignores Hydraulic Fracturing Facts
& Gives EPA Expanded Authority
In 2010, EPA Region 6 issued an
Emergency Administrative Order (EAO), aimed at shutting down natural gas
production wells belonging to Range Resources, an oil and gas company operating
in Parker County, Texas to further justify onerous federal regulations on
hydraulic fracturing. Amidst an ongoing State investigation EPA
interceded formally claiming that it had "determined" that the company’s
drilling for natural gas had "caused or contributed to the contamination of at
least two residential drinking water wells."[1] The evidence behind
the EAO was both flawed and manipulated, having been highly criticized and
disputed by State officials, Members of Congress, and a wide range of stakeholders.
EPA’s very issuance of the EAO was an unnecessary usurpation of traditional
state authority and an attempt to manufacture a smoking gun against hydraulic
fracturing.
The OIG’s report
on EPA’s actions against Range Resources was published a year and a half after
the initial request. The OIG failed to hold EPA accountable for a
multitude of inappropriate and unjustified actions in issuing the EAO. The
report entirely ignored EPA’s political dealings and collusion with far-left
environmental groups, and disregarded EPA’s manipulation of facts and science
to justify the issuance of the EAO in the first place. In fact, the OIG report
went as far as to commend EPA for properly conforming to agency guidelines by
exercising what the OIG interpreted as their limitless authority under the
SDWA, stating, "for the EPA to take and enforce a Section 1431 emergency order,
it needs neither proof that contamination has already occurred nor proof that
the recipient of the order is responsible for the contamination."[2]
The OIG report was the result of a
Congressional request from all six Republican Senators from Region 6 to look
into the actions of the EPA region. The request letter’s questions were
carefully crafted with extensive negotiations with and edits made by the OIG –
questions which the OIG subsequently chose largely to ignore. It has set
a dangerous precedent in giving EPA carte blanche authority to issue EAOs – no
proof necessary – to suspend the operations of any company or individual and
forcing them to incur unlimited costs in taking actions deemed necessary by
EPA.
On Friday, February 7, 2014, the OIG
announced a plan to conduct a review on "EPA’s and States’ ability to manage
potential threats to water resources from hydraulic fracturing."[3]
Despite the OIG’s inability to carry out their own stated mission of conducting
"independent oversight of the programs and operations of the Environmental
Protection Agency" in order to "prevent and detect fraud, waste, and abuse,"
they have seemingly taken on a new investigation that is both outside the scope
of their authorities as well as their expertise.[4] The OIG is
greatly outstepping its bounds in reviewing States’ regulatory policies for
what one can only glean is to further justify EPA’s political agenda aimed at
federal control of hydraulic fracturing despite any legitimate need to do so.
OIG Ignores Leads on EPA’s Email Follies
In 2013, several Congressional
Committees, including the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works
(EPW), had expressed serious concerns that the actions of several high ranking
EPA officials may have violated transparency statutes,[5] namely the Federal Records Act (FRA) and the
Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), by using personal and alias email accounts
to conduct agency business. Both statutes were put in place to help
ordinary Americans keep tabs on their government, but require the cooperation
and diligence of the Administrative Branch to ensure that responsive records
are captured and preserved.
Prompted by the discovery that EPA
officials had violated the Agency’s internal email protocol,[6]
the EPA OIG released a report entitled, Congressionally Requested Inquiry
into the EPA’s Use of Private and Alias Email Accounts on September 26,
2013.[7]
According to the report, the OIG "found no evidence that the EPA used, promoted
or encouraged the use of private ‘non-governmental’ email accounts to circumvent
records management."[8] Since that finding the
Committee has learned that at least these individuals were using private email
accounts:
Lisa Jackson, former Administrator
Bob Perciasepe, Deputy Administrator
Jared Blumenfeld, Region 9 Administrator
James Martin, former Region 8
Administrator
Judith Enck, Region 2 Administrator
Michelle DePass, Assistant Administrator
for International and Tribal Affairs
Mathy Stanislaus, Assistant
Administrator for the Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response
M. Allyn Brooks-Lasure, Deputy Associate
Administrator for Public Affairs
Brendan Gilfillan, Deputy Press
Secretary
Bob Sussman, former Senior Policy
Counsel
David Cohen, Spokesman
Robert Goulding, former Director of
Operations
Michael Moats, former Chief Speechwriter
Seth Oster, former Associate
Administrator for the Office of External Affairs and Environmental Education
Larry Elworth, former Chief Agricultural
Advisor
Tseming Yang, former Deputy General
Counsel
Diane Thompson, former Chief of Staff
A number of factors led to the OIG’s
faulty conclusion. In the course of writing the report, OIG relied solely
on interviews of EPA officials willing to cooperate, and never examined in any
way, actual staff emails.[9] Additionally, according to
the OIG, they have no authority to review the use of private email accounts for
agency business beyond asking the employee if they had ever improperly used a
private email account,[10] and did not follow-up or
fact-check. Moreover, investigators never spoke to former EPA
Administrator Lisa Jackson or former General Counsel Scott Fulton, two senior
level officials who played central roles in the controversy,[11]
nor did the OIG examine or compare the practice of using alias accounts by
Administrator Jackson and past Administrators. The OIG also did not review the
emails showing that EPA officials were inappropriately using their email
accounts that were produced in response to multiple FOIA requests.
In September 2013, EPW Republicans
released a report entitled, "A Call for Sunshine: EPA’s FOIA and Federal Records
Failures Uncovered," which provides a detailed accounting of
EPA’s inappropriate email practices. Additionally, the Committee has confirmed
that Region 9 Administrator Jared Blumenfeld used his private email account to
conduct agency business, although during his interview with the IG, he lied and
said that he had not.[1] It does not appear that
Blumenfeld has been held accountable by the Agency for lying to the IG.
OIG Turns Blind Eye to Crony Clean Air
Advisors
In 2011, former EPW Ranking Member
Senator James Inhofe (R-Okla.) asked the EPA OIG to evaluate EPA’s management
of the Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC), the Advisory Council on
Clean Air Compliance Analysis (Council), and the peer review process in order
to address concerns of a lack of impartiality, failure to balance perspectives,
failure to rotate members, and financial conflicts of interest.[12]
In 2013, the OIG concluded its audit and released the report entitled, "EPA Can
Better Document Resolution of Ethics and Partiality Concerns in Managing Clean
Air Federal Advisory Committees."[13]
During the course of the audit, OIG
reviewed only 37% of the CASAC and Council member files from 1998 to 2012,
reviewing only 18% "in depth," without disclosing their selection
process. They also admitted that they relied solely on members’ financial
disclosure forms to assess impartiality concerns and did not attempt to conduct
any independent research, including search engines (Lexis, Google, etc.).
Even though 72% of CASAC and Council members from 2006 to the present have
received EPA and related multi-agency research grants, OIG stated that members
with research grants did not present a conflict of interest, and did not follow
up on that line of inquiry. Additionally, the OIG used a narrow scope to
examine the membership balance, ignoring whether panels were balanced based on
consideration of individual members’ independence or impartiality concerns,
viewpoints, receipt of research grants, or membership tenure.
Unfortunately, the report refrained from
making specific recommendations to address concerns of impartiality, potential
conflicts of interest, and membership balance, missing the opportunity to
reform EPA’s policies for the scientific community responsible for providing
advice on some of the Agency’s most aggressive regulations. In the case
of addressing EPA procedures for when financial conflict of interest
disclosures were blatantly violated, OIG recommended that EPA instruct
employees of the proper procedures and nothing more.
OIG kept their recommendations broad and to a minimum, including one
that EPA could better document the membership selection process. While
EPA’s current process is not fully transparent, nor does it provide assurance
of neutrality, OIG failed to specify what EPA could do to address these
weaknesses.
Additional Concerns with OIG
On August 27, 2013, Sen. David Vitter (R-La.) requested
the OIG "immediately launch an investigation of the Agency’s policies and processes that facilitated John Beale’s fraud,
and to make recommendations to ensure that this does not happen again."[14] During the course of this
investigation, the OIG changed its protocol in executing their
responsibilities to Congress. OIG protocol dictate that in response to a
Congressional request, the report or work product is produced to the requestor
before it is available to the public. However, the OIG cancelled their
requested briefing with EPW Republican staff right before their reports on
Beale would be released to the public, thus abandoning its protocols.
In
a January 14, 2014, letter the current EPA IG, Arthur Elkins, has since
confirmed that his office’s actions were problematic and stated, "In light of
the OIGs obligations under the IG Act to be open and transparent – and given
the issues raised by recent reports – the OIG is revisiting practicality and
fairness issues as they relate to the sequence currently dictated by our
protocol. Should we decide to repeal or revise that protocol, we will
publically announce the change."[15]
Click here to read Sen. Vitter’s letter to his colleagues on the EPA OIG
protocol change.
-30-
[1]
Press Release, Envtl. Prot. Agency, EPA Issues an Imminent and Substantial
Endangerment Order to Protect Drinking Water in Southern Parker County
(Dec. 7, 2010), available at http://yosemite.epa.gov/opa/admpress.nsf/ab2d81eb088f4a7e85257359003f5339/713f73b4bdceb126852577f3002cb6fb!OpenDocument.
[2]
Office of Inspector Gen., Envtl. Prot.
Agency, Report No. 14-P-0044 Response to Congressional Inquiry
Regarding the EPA’s Emergency Order to the Range Resources Gas Drilling Company
(Dec. 20, 2013), available at http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/2014/20131220-14-P-0044.pdf.
[3]
Memorandum from Dan Engelberg, Dir., Water Issues, Office of Program
Evaluation, Office of Inspector Gen., Envtl. Prot. Agency, to Nancy Stoner,
Acting Assistant Adm’r for Water, Envtl. Prot. Agency (Feb. 5, 2014),
available at http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/notificationMemos/newStarts_02-05-14_HyraulicFracturing.pdf.
[4]
See Office of Inspector Gen.,
Envtl. Prot. Agency, About OIG (last accessed Feb. 13, 2014), available
at http://www.epa.gov/oig/about.html.
[5]
Minority Office, S. Comm. on Env’t &
Pub. Works, A Call for Sunshine: EPA’s FOIA and Fed. Records Failures Uncovered
9-15 (Sept. 9, 2013).
[6]
Memorandum from Melissa M. Heist,
Assistant Inspector General for Audit to EPA Administrator (Dec. 13, 2012)
available at http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/notificationMemos/newStarts_12-13-2012_Audit_of_Records_Managements_Practices.pdf
[7]
Office of Inspector Gen., Envtl. Prot.
Agency, Report No. 13-P-0433, Congressionally Requested Inquiry into the EPA’s
Use of Private and Alias Email Accounts (Sept. 26, 2013).
[8]
Office of Inspector Gen., Envtl. Prot.
Agency, Report No. 13-P-0433, Congressionally Requested Inquiry into the EPA’s
Use of Private and Alias Email Accounts: At a Glance (Sept. 26, 2013), available
at http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/2013/20130926-13-P-0433_glance.pdf.
[9]
Minority Office, S. Comm. on Env’t &
Pub. Works, A Call for Sunshine: EPA’s FOIA and Fed. Records Failures Uncovered
12-14 (Sept. 9, 2013); Briefing for Staff of S. Comm. on Env’t & Pub. Works
(Jan. 24, 2014).
[10]
Briefing for Staff of S. Comm. on Env’t & Pub. Works (Jan. 24, 2014).
[11]
E-mail from Michael Goode, Project Manager, Office of Audit, Office of
Inspector Gen. Envtl. Prot. Agency, to Lisa Jackson, Former Adm’r, Envtl. Prot.
Agency (Apr. 16, 2013 04:32 PM); E-mail from Michael Goode, Project Manager,
Office of Audit, Office of Inspector Gen. Envtl. Prot. Agency, to Lisa Jackson,
Former Adm’r, Envtl. Prot. Agency (May 2, 2013 03:06 PM); E-mail from Michael
Goode, Project Manager, Office of Audit, Office of Inspector Gen. Envtl. Prot.
Agency, to Scott Fulton, Former Gen. Counsel, Envtl. Prot. Agency (Apr. 11,
2013 05:37 PM); E-mail from Michael Goode, Project Manager, Office of Audit,
Office of Inspector Gen. Envtl. Prot. Agency, to Scott Fulton, Former Gen.
Counsel, Envtl. Prot. Agency (May 2, 2013 03:01 PM); Briefing for Staff of S.
Comm. on Env’t & Pub. Works (Jan. 24, 2014).
[1] Minority
Office, S. Comm. on Env’t & Pub. Works, A Call for Sunshine: EPA’s FOIA and
Fed. Records Failures Uncovered 9-15 (Sept. 9, 2013) (citing letter from
Jared Blumenfeld, Reg’l Adm’r, U.S. Envtl Prot. Agency Region 9, to Hon. David
Vitter Ranking Member S. Comm. on Env’t & Pub. Works (Sept. 6, 2013)).
[12]http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=503cd8ab-802a-23ad-45e8-1d8528fa6847
[13]http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/2013/20130911-13-P-0387.pdf
[14] Letter from
the Hon. David Vitter, Ranking Member, Senate Env. &Public Wks Com., to the
Hon. Arthur Elkins, Inspector Gen., Envtl. Prot. Agency (Aug. 27, 2013).
[15] Letter from
Arthur Elkins, Inspector Gen., Envtl. Prot. Agency, to Hon. David Vitter,
Ranking Member, S. Comm. on Envt. & Pub. Works (Jan 14, 2014).