Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
EPW POLICY BEAT: ACID RAIN MYTH, PART 2
It’s an unfortunate fact of history that some myths have remarkable staying power. In this case, we are referring to the time-honored Acid Rain myth. This is a myth with compelling surface appeal, yet it takes only the slightest reflection to see why it’s false.
The myth goes something like this: cap-and-trade was successful in reducing SO2 and NOx at low cost; cap-and-trade is the method of choice for reducing greenhouse gas emissions; therefore, cap-and-trade will be successful in reducing greenhouse gas emissions at low cost. For several reasons that we’ve stated before, this nifty syllogism is wrong.
There is yet another facet to the myth, as its propagators have recounted over the last several weeks. In an attempt to undercut numerous economic analyses showing cap-and-trade of the greenhouse gas variety destroying jobs and raising energy prices (see, for example, the release yesterday of the Energy Information Administration’s analysis of Waxman-Markey), proponents of energy rationing note with relish the industry’s “doomsday” cost estimates of the Acid Rain program in 1990. As two Senators recently wrote in the Washington Post, “Naysayers said the cost to business [from the Acid Rain program] would be more than $50 billion a year, but health and other benefits outweighed the costs 40 to 1.”
What are we to believe from this? It seems that industry said the program would cost billions more than it actually did; note that these are the same people making the same arguments today about cap-and-trade; therefore, don’t believe them. Case closed. Or so it seems.
The $50 billion figure cited above is surely an eye-opener. And it would be a powerful rhetorical weapon were it not for the fact that it’s incorrect and misleading. The $50 billion figure was the cost estimate for all six titles of the Clean Air Act amendments, not for the Acid Rain program (Title IV) alone. In fact, according to “The Cost of Reducing SO2 (It’s Higher Than You Think),” a 1998 article in Public Utilities Fortnightly by Jeremy Platt, Denny Ellerman, and Anne Smith, power sector and EPA estimates of the cost of the Acid Rain program were not dramatically different. According to the article, industry estimated the cost of the Acid Rain program to be somewhere between $4.7 and $6.6 billion, not $50 billion. As for EPA, the agency said the range was $2.6 to $6.0 billion.
So in sum, remember one word—wrong—the next time you hear someone equate cap-and-trade for carbon with acid rain.
Related:
Higher Prices, Fewer Jobs and Weaker Economy With Cap-and-Trade, Says EIA
EPW POLICY BEAT: ACID RAIN REDUX
EPW POLICY BEAT: THE ACID RAIN MYTH
STUDY: Why Acid Rain is the Wrong Template
###