Posted by David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
“Cash Pledge in Doubt” – “Deal Decades Away” – “Cancun: Great for Spring Break, not for Climate Negotiating”
Inhofe EPW News Roundup
Politico: U.S. Climate Cash Pledge in Doubt – …"They promised to pass a cap-and-trade bill and reminded us they wanted to give away $100 billion, and I said, ‘From where?’" incoming House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Fred Upton (R-Mich.) told POLITICO. Republican Sens. Jim Inhofe (Okla.), David Vitter (La.), John Barrasso (Wyo.) and George Voinovich (Ohio) urged Clinton last week to freeze all future spending requests related to international climate change finance programs and make no new commitments. "You’re looking at a thing where you have a lot of people in Congress who are suspicious of foreign assistance,” said Mark Helmke, spokesman for Senate Foreign Relations Committee ranking member Dick Lugar (R-Ind.). "All of a sudden, we’re putting a whole lot of new demands at a time when people want to cut spending and when people are getting tired of money going overseas when we have a lot of concerns domestically."
Politico: Controversial Questions Punted – Negotiators from about 190 countries reached a modest set of agreements early Saturday in Cancun on how to tackle global warming but punted some of the most controversial questions for a later date. …Diplomats struggled over the past two weeks at the Mexican resort town on some of those key questions and had essentially reached a standoff, forcing them to pick around the edges at ideas like technology, trees and adaptation, all of which could garner sufficient consensus. For the United States, Cancun closes without having to make any new commitments that could put the Obama administration further under fire from Republicans in Congress. GOP lawmakers helped kill Obama’s climate legislation earlier this year and they are already preparing to hold hearings in 2011 that scrutinize global warming science. Members on both sides of the aisle also have their doubts about any new international financial commitments related to global warming when Washington is sinking under its own deficits.
Bloomberg: Global Warming Deal Decades Away – With President Barack Obama struggling to salvage his energy agenda and richer and poorer nations in conflict over extending Kyoto’s emission limits, a new worldwide climate treaty may be 20 years away, said Tim Wirth, who in 1997 led the U.S. delegation in Kyoto, Japan. Such a delay endangers the future of $2.7 billion a year in pollution credits sold under a UN program based on the Kyoto agreement. “We have a dysfunctional Congress and an administration without policy,” Wirth, a former Democratic senator from Colorado, said in an interview during two weeks of UN climate talks in Cancun, Mexico. “The U.S. doesn’t have an energy strategy. You can’t sign up to an international treaty unless you know what you are going to do at home.”
Guardian UK: Loopholes Were left in and dates were left out. The World is in Limbo …They kept the wheels on the bus by reaching an agreement on Saturday, but it is still careering towards the precipice. In the overriding desire to get a deal – any deal – gaping loopholes and ambiguities were left in, dates were left out and major issues about the final legal form and the emission cuts all countries will need to make were pushed back another year. In effect, the world is in limbo. Take the money. The best news from Cancún for developing countries is that a new climate fund will be set up and be largely directed by them under the auspices of the UN, and not the World Bank. But the idea that it will handle the potentially giant flows of new aid which could accrue after 2020 ($100bn a year), is wrong.
WSJ Editorial: The Cancun Crack-Up – The Biggest Climate Conference Achievement: Sun Tans. – How appropriate that the U.N.’s latest climate summit in the Mexican resort of Cancun should have begun last week with the invocation of an ancient jaguar goddess. When it comes to global warming, there’s always been more than a touch of the old-time religion. Unfortunately for the climateers, the rest of the Maya pantheon doesn’t seem to be cooperating. Since last year’s collapse of the climate summit in Copenhagen, the chances that one of these periodic U.N. confabs would result in a binding global agreement on carbon caps was remote. The failure of the meeting in Cancun to produce one—which was all but official as we went to press last night—only underscores the point.
Wash. Post: Cancun: Great for Spring Break, not for Climate Negotiating – Over the years, Cancun has made its name as a freewheeling spring break hotspot where American college students take their reputations to die. So perhaps it is no surprise that the 2010 United Nations Climate Change Conference currently convened there has been so unproductive. Cancun is not a place to stop binging – on alcohol or on fossil fuels. Indeed, those assembled in Mexico can’t even get agreement on inadequate, face-saving carbon-cutting measures.
WSJ: UN Climate talks end – World leaders at a climate-change conference in Cancun, Mexico, made clear that addressing the issue will be all about money, agreeing that rich countries would spend potentially trillions of dollars to help poor countries develop on a greener path. …But the diplomats postponed hashing out which rich countries would pay how much, and exactly what the poor countries would have to do to get the checks. Representatives from the Philippines, Dominican Republic and Mexico sat in the ocean to visually represent their negotiating positions. That is why international negotiations over climate policy amount to a game of economic chicken, with the world’s major economies—notably China and the U.S.—trying to ensure they aren’t stuck with the bulk of the cost of emission cuts.
National Journal: Fight over fate of Kyoto – Nor did the Cancun deal lock in place the architecture for a binding global climate treaty to replace the world’s first such treaty, the 1997 Kyoto Protocol that expires in 2012. …The biggest of these is the fight over the fate of the Kyoto treaty. That fight will escalate throughout 2011 and come to a head at next year’s U.N. climate summit in Durban, South Africa. The Kyoto deal reflects the global economy as it was 20 years ago, divided between rich and developing nations. It binds about 40 of the world’s richest nations to cutting their fossil fuel emissions but exempts developing nations – including China, India, and Brazil – from making similar commitments. The United States is exempt from the Kyoto, since it never ratified the treaty. Developing nations, led by China, want the next climate-change treaty to renew the terms of Kyoto. Developed nations, led by the United States, have made clear that they will never sign such a deal. They insist that any global treaty commit all the world’s biggest emitters to pollution reductions, specifically China, which outstrips the United States as the world’s biggest carbon polluter.
Wash. Post: The Climate-Change Conference’s own Carbon Footprint – This year’s climate-change meeting in Cancun was a lot smaller than last year’s gathering in Copenhagen. But like a Hobbit, Cancun’s footprint was quite big for its size. The meeting’s carbon footprint was 25,000 metric tons of emissions, according to host nation Mexico. That includes the carbon output of everything – flights by delegates, shuttle rides from the swanky Moon Palace hotel, even food preparation. Here’s a breakdown of the numbers: 25 heads of state attended; 2,457 air-conditioned rooms with double Jacuzzis at the main conference hotel; $68 million paid by the Mexican government to host the conference.
###