Yesterday the Senate Commerce Committee held a hearing on the recent scientific research concerning the impacts of “global warming” and actions being taken by states to address climate change. Unfortunately, once again, the Commerce Committee only invited witnesses who support the Kyoto Accords and the Chairman of the committee’s Climate Stewardship Act.
At the hearing the Chairman of the committee asked one of the witnesses if he believed anyone could possibly disagree with his testimony. The witness replied, “There are always going to be groups like that.”
FACT: The Climate Stewardship Act of 2003, also known as McCain- Lieberman, was soundly defeated by the United States Senate by a vote of 55-43. The Senate also sent a clear message against the Kyoto Accords with a 95-0 vote against implementing the treaty. It appears at least one group, the United States Senate, does disagree.
Why?
Scare tactics do not sell to the American public.
As Senator Inhofe said from the floor of the Senate during the debate over McCain-Lieberman, “Much of the debate over global warming is predicated on fear, rather than science. Global warming alarmists see a future plagued by catastrophic flooding, war, terrorism, economic dislocations, droughts, crop failures, mosquito-borne diseases, and harsh weather-all caused by man-made greenhouse gas emissions.”
Not surprisingly, alarmist claims were exactly the claims presented at the recent hearing. Dr. Epstein argued the effects of climate change are already being felt as the American West suffers through a serious drought. But if the committee heard from a variety of opinions perhaps a different view would have presented — much like what was reported in a New York Times article just this past week:
“Continuing research into drought cycles over the last 800 years bears this out, strongly suggesting that the relatively wet weather across much of the West during the 20th century was a fluke. In other words, scientists who study tree rings and ocean temperatures say, the development of the modern urbanized West — one of the biggest growth spurts in the nation’s history — may have been based on a colossal miscalculation.” – New York Times
In addition, both Dr. Epstein and Senator Lautenberg discussed a recent climate change paper from the Pentagon. Senator Lautenberg went as far as to ask the panel if they knew of anyone who questioned the findings of the Pentagon Report. Again, if the committee would have asked those with differing opinions to testify, they might have heard this about the Pentagon Report:
“They got it all wrong.” In fact Peter Schwartz — one of the authors of the controversial report said Tuesday that, “the report’s scary-sounding projections are highly improbable and extremely unlikely.” -San Francisco Chronicle
Unfortunately the Senate Commerce Committee has closed the door to open debate on the facts of climate change from all sides of the issue. It is unfortunate that those critical of climate change science have not been allowed to present their case before the Committee. Members and the American public should relish the opportunity for spirited debate – not stifle it.