Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In the News…  

Congress Daily

Carbon-Pricing Plan Might Not Clear Moderate Hurdles

Thursday, July 15, 2010

by Amy Harder

Link to Article 

Senate Democrats working on a last-ditch effort to price carbon emissions of power plants face a mounting wall of resistance from moderate senators in both parties whose support is essential for the passage of any type of energy and climate bill.

Even Democrats with some confidence that the Senate can coalesce around a utility-only bill, such as Sens. Joe Lieberman, D-Conn., and Tom Carper, D-Del., acknowledge that getting support from their Democratic colleagues like Sens. Blanche Lincoln of Arkansas and John (Jay) Rockefeller of West Virginia will be difficult.

Lieberman said Tuesday that he didn’t know whether Lincoln and Rockefeller could support the utility-only bill he and Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., are working on. In order to get the 60 votes needed for passage, Senate Majority Leader Reid needs nearly all Democrats and at least a few Republicans to support it.

Reid said Tuesday he hopes to introduce his energy, climate and oil spill package next week and bring it to the floor the week of July 26.

Lincoln and Rockefeller, who both chair committees with jurisdiction over energy legislation, said Wednesday that they are not working with and have not been contacted by Lieberman and Kerry about their bill that prices carbon emissions of power plants only. A Senate aide said Tuesday that Reid plans to include that proposal in his package, despite Senate Energy and Natural Resources Chairman Jeff Bingaman also circulating a utility-only cap proposal.

"I’m leery of that, but I haven’t seen what they’ve put out or what they’re going to put out," Lincoln, who chairs the Agriculture Committee, said Wednesday of the utility-only proposals. Lincoln reiterated that she is against any type of cap-and-trade system, and both drafts appear to be slimmed-down versions of something included in Lieberman and Kerry’s original bill. Indeed, their scaled-back proposal has been dubbed a "utilities-plus" plan since other sectors can eventually opt into the system in later years.

"I look upon it as dangerous," Rockefeller, who chairs the Commerce Committee, said Wednesday of Kerry and Lieberman’s utility-only approach. He noted that he had not seen drafts of either proposal. "We don’t see words on paper. And that’s the only thing that counts around here. It’s legislative language that you have to have and we don’t have that."

Drafts of both proposals were leaked Tuesday, but Bingaman’s measure was a months-old copy.

Kerry has been meeting with utility associations and environmental groups to try to rally support for his and Lieberman’s bill, but those efforts were dealt a blow when the American Chemistry Council, an association that represents many energy-intensive manufacturing companies, officially came out Wednesday against any type of bill that prices carbon of utilities only. "Unfortunately, under every version of the proposal discussed to date, utility allowances are insufficient to cover their higher energy costs, which will simply be passed through to industrial energy consumers and other rate payers," ACC President and CEO Cal Dooley said in a statement.

Officials who represent utilities say the industry would likely have very similar concerns, although the major utility association, Edison Electric Institute, has not taken a public position on a utility-only approach. Environmental groups, meanwhile, are worried that Democrats are going to bend too far on the climate aspect of any legislation in order to garner utility support.

###