Improving ESA: The Klamath Case Study In At Least One Region, The ESA Process For Three Species Has Had A Devastating Impact On Hundreds Of Others Environmental special interests claim that the current form of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) has been successful, and they are lobbying Congress against making modifications to improve it. In a recent press release, the NRDC’s endangered species “expert” stated that the recovery of the bald eagle represented the “success of the Endangered Species Act,” going on to say: In addition to protecting individual species, we must fight attempts in Congress to weaken the Endangered Species Act. The law must remain strong because extinction is irreversible. If a species dies out, we don’t get a second chance. Fact: The ESA has been successful in recovering but 10 of nearly 1,300 species currently listed. In 2001, in an effort to help protect three endangered species, the act severely impacted more than 400 others by forcing Fish and Wildlife Service biologists to shut off water to nearly a quarter of a million acres of farmland in the Klamath Basin region of the Pacific Northwest. As Dr. Robert McLandress of the University of California (Davis) states: There are 433 species of wild life here. The Biological Opinion deals with three. The farms and wetlands supply the food for waterfowl that we are pledged to look after. There are 200 million waterfowl use days that waterfowl have to be fed here in the Klamath Basin. That’s about 70 million pounds of food…we couldn’t even cover half of that under the natural systems. The other half has to come out of the farms. Because irrigation was closed off to protect the endangered coho salmon in Klamath River and two species of sucker fish in Klamath Lake, areas such as Tule Lake in the Tule Lake National Wildlife Refuge became dry for the first time in recorded history, and the effects were devastating. Experts at Oregon State University (OSU) say “that 75 to 80 percent of the waterfowl in the Pacific Flyway pass through the Basin,” where likely the single largest concentration of waterfowl was ever counted in one day (5.8 million). They went on to say, “Lower Klamath NWR is a substantial producer of waterfowl and other water birds, but production in 2001 was expected to be essentially zero [because the water shutoff left no reproductive habitat].” The greatest injustice of all is the fact that the water shut-off has been deemed unnecessary – wetlands did not have to dry up, farmers’ livelihoods did not have to be put at stake, and the loss of wildlife did not have to occur. The National Academy of Sciences found no benefits of raising the lake levels for endangered fish, and stated that the water shut-off was not necessary to protect those three species.