Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202)224-9797

 

EPW POLICY BEAT: THE CARBON LOOPHOLE?

From the Inhofe-EPW Press Office   

 

What’s a loophole?  That’s more than an etymological question these days.  EPW Policy Beat has encountered this oft-used noun in the context of climate change.   Specifically, we’re hearing proponents of cap-and-trade call for “closing the carbon loophole.”  Consider this recent ad from Al Gore’s Repower America: “What if we could make our planet cooler and our economy hotter?  We can…by closing the carbon pollution loophole.  The stuff from coal and oil…cap it and spur new investments and jobs in clean energy.”  Sure enough, we heard the same from President Obama in his economic address on April 14th: “But we can no longer delay putting a framework for a clean energy economy in place. If businesses and entrepreneurs know today that we are closing this carbon pollution loophole, they will start investing in clean energy now.”

We found two entries for loophole in Webster’s dictionary: the first—“a small opening through which small arms may be fired”—is not entirely relevant; the second, however, seems more apt: “a means of escape; especially: an ambiguity or omission in the text through which the intent of a statute, contract, or obligation may be evaded.”   We wonder: are Repower America and President Obama accusing businesses of evading the law?  If so, which law?  And what “means of escape” are they employing to evade the “intent of a statute”?  As far as we can tell, there is no federal law mandating reductions or establishing standards for carbon dioxide emissions—unless, of course, one thinks the Clean Air Act sets such mandates or standards; it doesn’t, at least not yet. 

But we suppose this rather idiosyncratic view is unsurprising from an Administration whose conception of business is, shall we say, a bit harsh.   On Earth Day, DOE Secretary Chu and Labor Secretary Solis wrote an op-ed urging passage of President Obama’s carbon scheme.  Certainly, those who violate pollution laws should be punished according to law.   But Chu and Solis level an unremitting attack against those who emit carbon, for which there is no federal emissions law: “As part of this comprehensive policy, we must crack down on the corporations that pollute the water we drink and the air we breathe.  Cracking down on these polluters in a real way will mean that we can finally tackle global warming and its potentially catastrophic effects – because ultimately, our approach to energy policy and combating the effects of global warming are two sides of the same coin.”    In the same vein, they wrote, “If we are going to create clean energy industry jobs in this country, break the stranglehold that foreign oil has on our economy and punish the polluters who are devastating our natural resources, then we’ve got to be honest about the difficult tasks and tough choices ahead.”    “Cracking down.”  “Punish.”  “Polluters.”  “Loophole.”  Sounds like business as usual.

###