In the name of “business certainty,” a coalition of investors, electric utilities, and environmental groups, which has earnestly dubbed itself the “Coalition for Environmentally Responsible Economies,” or CERES, recently recommended adoption of a “mandatory national climate change program to limit greenhouse gas emissions.” Climate change, according to the scientific opinion of the group, represents a serious environmental, not to mention financial, threat that should cause concern. Of course this must be the case, especially for several of the participating utilities, including Keyspan and the Public Service Enterprise Group (PSEG), which are heavily invested in fuels other than coal. Denise Nappier, treasurer of the State of Connecticut, who has spoken out in support of CERES, even said she has a “fiduciary responsibility” to shareholders to advocate for caps on carbon emissions.

 

FACT: CERES would, for certain, get higher electricity prices, which in turn would erode economic growth and undermine investment. Dr. Margo Thorning of the American Council for Capital Formation, echoing the conclusions reached by numerous government and private analysts, said that, “[C]arbon caps would increase the price of electricity.” In her testimony before the EPW Committee on June 5, Thorning said, “As U.S. economic growth slows in response to higher electricity prices, demand for electricity falls and profits decline. Thus, by weakening demand for the product (electricity) carbon caps will increase the risk and uncertainty of investment in utilities.” What about for domestic manufacturers? “Carbon caps will make it harder for U.S. manufacturers to keep their operations at home and will increase the attractiveness of locating in areas like China…with no carbon emissions caps.”