Clear Skies is significantly better for the environment than the existing Clean Air Act because it provides predictably that significant pollution reductions will occur and certainty as to when they will occur. The existing Act cannot guarantee either result. Unlike efforts to reduce emissions by rulemaking, when Clear Skies is enacted into law it cannot be held up or derailed by litigation. Opponents claim that existing New Source Review and Section 126 petition programs will achieve faster and greater reductions than the Clear Skies Act — but history tells a different story: FACTS: In 1997, eight Northeastern states petitioned EPA to force Midwestern states to reduce nitrogen oxides. After four federal court decisions and EPA retooling, this culminated in the NOx SIP call, which went into effect not in May 1998 but in May 2004 – seven years after the process began. Similarly, in 1999 the Clinton Administration initiated several NSR enforcement actions, many of which were challenged and several are still being litigated nearly six years later. If the legal standard reached in the Duke case prevails – which will not be known for some time, NSR cannot be applied as frequently and to the degree that opponents of Clear Skies claim. Additionally, a federal court heard oral arguments on the Bush Administration’s first round of NSR reforms, promulgated two years ago with oral arguments on its 2003 routine maintenance reforms not expected to occur until at least 2006. As Ron Harper, CEO of Basin Electric testified, the uncertainty and litigation over existing regulations, such as New Source Review, have prevented improvements that would reduce emissions and fuel use. NSR litigation has been against a couple of dozen power plants, while Clear Skies is direct regulation on all electricity generators, including over 1300 coal fired power plants. Penalties for noncompliance under Clear Skies are immediate and severe and not hindered by litigation. In light of the troubled history of Clean Air Act regulations and the years and years of delays that have prevented their full and timely implementation, Clear Skies is the best solution for reducing toxic power plant emissions by meaningful levels, and for making sure those reductions actually become reality.