Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

Link to CRA Study

Link to Beinecke Testimony

It’s a common (green) refrain: pass cap-and-trade legislation to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 80 percent and the ineluctable result is a growing economy, greater prosperity, and green jobs galore.  “If the American Clean Energy and Security Act were enacted tomorrow,” Frances Beinecke, president of NRDC, said, “millions of clean energy jobs would be created, starting right away.”  Worried about the drought in capital investment?  How about corporate profits? Beinecke says pass cap-and-trade. “[Waxman-Markey] will unlock large-scale private sector capital investments starting today, saving companies money in the short and long term and boosting the recovery.”  Want to encourage technology innovation?  Strengthen energy security?  Restore the balance of trade?  End world hunger?  Enact cap-and-trade, the green unified field theory: “Properly designed legislation,” declared Beinecke, “will encourage innovation, enhance America’s energy security, foster economic growth, improve our balance of trade, and provide critically needed U.S. leadership on this vital global challenge.”

FACT: Such noble sentiments provide a captivating story about cap-and-trade—except for the fact that they are false.  In a study on the costs of Waxman-Markey for the National Black Chamber of Commerce, CRA International explained why: “This analysis reveals that businesses and consumers would face higher energy and transportation costs under ACESA, which would lead to increased costs of other goods and services throughout the economy. As the costs of goods and services rise, household disposable income and household consumption would fall. Wages and returns on investment would also fall, resulting in lower productivity growth and reduced employment opportunities.”

CRA says cap-and-trade would in fact create green jobs, but green job enthusiasts fail to balance their employment equation: “The present study finds that the cap-and-trade program would lead to increases in spending on energy efficiency and renewable energy, and as a result that significant numbers of people would be employed in ‘green jobs’ that would not exist in a no-carbon policy world. However, any calculation of jobs created in these activities is incomplete if not supplemented with a calculation of the reduced employment in other industries and the decline in the average salary that would result from the associated higher energy costs and lower overall productivity in the economy.”   

In short, CRA found that “even after accounting for green jobs, there is a substantial and long-term net reduction in total labor earnings and employment.”  CRA also argues that this result is the logical outcome of energy rationing policies.  “This is the unintended but predictable consequence of investing to create a ‘green energy future.’” 

Finally, CRA explains that cold, hard reality is the obstacle to achieving the utopian hopes of America’s green energy future.  CRA thus offers up some sobering conclusions for cap-and-trade proponents: “Claims that GHG cap-and-trade can boost total employment have become commonplace.  This contention has become a central point in the national debate about climate policy. That it has is understandable; the U.S. economy is undergoing both a cyclical downturn and a structural adjustment. Unemployment is high, and so is political pressure to respond to both the short-term cyclical and to the long-term structural aspects of the challenge. Not surprisingly, this pressure has led to claims and hopes that GHG cap-and-trade might somehow solve both problems. These claims are incorrect, and the hopes that spring from them are destined to lead to disappointment. ACESA can have no impact on the unemployment arising from the current cyclical downturn because its provisions will not take effect soon enough. In the longer run, its net effects on employment will be negative…” 

 ###