Posted by: Matt Dempsey (202) 224-9797 

EPW FACT OF THE DAY: A NET LOSS ON EARTH DAY

To celebrate Earth Day, President Obama trekked to Iowa to stump for “green jobs” and the assortment of federal green mandates that will, truth be told, free us from dependence on foreign oil.  The President said that protecting the nation’s natural resources “not only fulfills a sacred obligation to our children and grandchildren, but also provides an opportunity to stimulate economic growth.” According to the Associated Press, Obama visited “financially struggling Newton, Iowa,” where he touted the Trinity Structural Towers wind energy plant “as a model for job creation and energy production in a town whose biggest employer was sold and then stopped operations.”  “The administration contends,” the AP reported, “that the president’s plan will create jobs and protect the environment.”

FACT: As the New York Times recently put it, “No one believes that renewable energy can fully replace what has been lost on the American factory floor…”  Except, of course, President Obama.  Upon closer inspection, one finds that the Times is right: the plant that “was sold and then stopped operations” in 2007 was the Maytag washing machine factory, which employed 1,800 people in a town of 16,000.  Obama today highlighted green jobs at wind energy facilities amidst the rubble of Maytag.  Both would employ 700 workers—no doubt a welcome development for Newton, but it represents a net job loss.  Moreover, workers at the Maytag plant earned $20 an hour with health benefits; workers at the TPI Composites wind turbine facility, across the way from where Obama delivered his speech, would earn $13 an hour.  For the record, this is not the first time Obama has raised an example of green jobs that fell short.  He has also lauded Spain for its green jobs programs.  Yet Dr. Gabriel Calzada, an economics professor at Juan Carlos University in Madrid, found that each renewable job created by the Spanish government destroyed an average of 2.2 other jobs, while each “green” megawatt installed in Spain destroyed 5.39 jobs in non-energy sectors.  This is hardly the green utopia as marketed by Obama and Al Gore.  Or is it?

 

# # #