U.S. Refining Capacity Requires a Boost By Senator James Inhofe Special to Roll Call June 19, 2006 American families continue to face high energy prices both in their homes and at the pump. Unfortunately here on Capitol Hill, rising energy prices continue to be met with empty political rhetoric. For many, the answer lies somewhere between name-calling, finger-pointing and cries of unsubstantiated “gouging.” The good news is that there are options available to improve the situation. Increasing domestic refining capacity is one of the best solutions. Recent statements by my Senate colleagues, especially those on the other side of the aisle, lead me to believe that partisan politics may be giving way to this reasonable approach. Increasing Domestic Refining Capacity Is a Must Our nation continues to outsource refining capacity. Today, the East Coast imports about 25 percent of its refined products. Importing will likely increase, and with it the price of refined products will rise. Even amid a global oil surplus, the refining market remains significantly tight. Unless policymakers work to boost domestic refining capacity, prices will continue to climb. The best way to affect the price of a commodity is to control it. When supplies increase relative to demand, prices fall. Of course, the more painful corollary we’re experiencing today is also true; when supplies are volatile or low relative to demand, then prices increase. In Washington, D.C., we must come up with a reasonable solution to this demand. Another truth: While Congress continues to argue about environmental hypotheticals and improbable nightmare scenarios, other countries are making progress in energy development. For instance, China’s national oil company will begin drilling just 40 to 50 miles off Florida shores at the invitation of its communist Cuban cousin. The situation is so dire that in a September 2005 interview, Virgin Atlantic Airline founder Sir Richard Branson stated, “If we don’t start now to get more refineries built then fuel prices could literally rocket to $US 100-$US 200 [per barrel of oil] and the world economy would come to a grinding halt.” Although Branson expressed interest in building refineries in the United States, his concerns about difficult permits and regulatory framework will mean that he likely will look elsewhere. The nonpartisan National Petroleum Council’s December 2004 report concluded that “uncertainty over regulations can delay investment decisions and permitting processes can add to investment lead times. Both of these factors will slow the industry’s response to bringing additional supplies to the market.” Further, the expert body concluded that “streamlining the permitting process would help improve the environment for domestic refining capacity investment. … Streamlining should provide for expeditious overall review and have a clearly defined process for obtaining a permit, with agency roles and responsibilities well-defined and specific deadlines for making permit decisions.” The Gas PRICE Act That’s why, as chairman of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, I introduced legislation S.1772, the Gas Petroleum Refiner Improvement and Community Empowerment Act. The legislation provides for a voluntary state-based permitting program to help states to permit new and expand existing refineries without changing environmental laws. Prior to markup, I worked closely with groups representing state and local organizations and environmental directors. Further, as amended by Sens. George Voinovich (R-Ohio) and John Thune (R-S.D.), the concept of “refinery” was broadened to meet the transportation fuel needs of today and the future. As amended, bio-refineries producing renewable fuels such as ethanol and facilities turning coal into ultra-clean synfuels also would benefit from the cooperative state-federal permit streamlining provisions. Along with state and local support, the National Mining Association and the Renewable Fuels Association endorsed the legislation. As chairman, I carefully worked to balance and respect diverse regulatory interests when crafting this bill. I felt confident that this important legislation would pass out of committee easily. Unfortunately, however, the Gas PRICE Act stalled due to partisan politics. The Nov. 7, 2005, issue of the Topeka Capital Journal outlined the politics behind the vote. It read: “Politics played the crucial role in Democrat opposition. If gas prices are high next year, the GOP will be blamed and that will allow Democrats to gain seats in Congress. It is a bold strategy, but it is not a solution.” The minority did offer one alternative to my bill. Their bill would have authorized the Environmental Protection Agency to design, construct and operate oil refineries. Thankfully, their Soviet-style proposal was rejected along party lines. Bipartisan Support Grows for More Domestic Refining Capacity Now six months later, statements by Democrats across the country may signal a new willingness to put politics aside in support of reasonable efforts like my Gas PRICE Act to increase domestic refining capacity. For example, Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer (D) wrote an opinion piece in The New York Times lauding coal-to-liquid synfuels. The Gas PRICE Act would help Montana realize its dream. Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-N.M.), in a speech last month on the Senate floor, stated, “That is not to say we cannot do an even better job of responsibly increasing refining capacity. For example, the government should look for ways to bring stakeholders together to cooperate more in the siting of refineries outside the Gulf of Mexico coastal region, but we need to act in Congress on the basis of actual facts and not on the basis of overheated and inaccurate rhetoric.” Decision Time: Help Lower Gas Prices or More Democrat Obstruction? Whether Senate Democrats actually will set aside partisan politics in support of legislation that will increase domestic refining capacity is yet to be seen. What is certain, however, is their statements in support of increasing refining capacity. If Senate Democrats are serious, I look to their support of the Gas PRICE Act. Time will tell if their actions match their rhetoric. My colleagues in the Senate are some of the smartest professionals I have ever had the pleasure of working with, and so I invite colleagues from both sides of the aisle to work with me to put politics aside and lower prices for all Americans. Click here for the Op/Ed