Posted by David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

Pachauri Is Damaging The World – Why It’s Time For Change At The IPCC – Climate Panel Needs Credibility

Inhofe EPW News Roundup

FT Editorial: Time For A Change in Climate Research   – Now it is time to implement fundamental reforms that would reduce the risk of bias and errors appearing in future IPCC assessments, increase transparency and open up the whole field of climate research to the widest possible range of scientific views. … A rejuvenated IPCC leadership could tackle the deficiencies in its review process. This should become more inclusive, welcoming alternative views where these are scientifically valid, and at the same time more exclusive, rejecting unsubstantiated claims of dramatic change. The many uncertainties need recognition, with IPCC assessments talking more about risks and probabilities than they have in the past. Then the debate can get back to the real issues posed by climate change.

Telegraph UK: IPCC’s Rajendra Pachauri Is Damaging The World  – Dr Shapiro said he was not criticising Dr Pachauri personally, but there is no doubt he should go. As the IPCC’s leader, Dr Pachauri is ultimately responsible for the defects identified by the inquiry. Worse, he has done much to aggravate them. He has been in the vanguard of the panel’s detour into policy pronouncements – for example, by calling a decision by President Obama not to try for a full climate treaty in Copenhagen "an abandonment of moral responsibility".  And his bombastic rejection last winter of any criticism deepened the crisis.

WSJ Editorial: Climate of Uncertainty  – On Monday an independent review found that the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has downplayed uncertainties surrounding climate science. The review also found that the IPCC needs more robust safeguards against conflicts of interest, that it had committed "unnecessary errors" by failing to meet its own standards, that it had inadequately flagged its use of nonscientific sources, that it made claims with "high confidence" based on "weak evidentiary basis," and that it gave short shrift to dissenting scientists.

Orange County Register: Editorial: U.N. agency told to cool climate advocacy  – A consortium of national scientific academies has scolded the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for downplaying uncertainties about global warming, failing to point out when its claims of catastrophe were based on weak evidence and misrepresenting some findings as peer-reviewed by scientists, when they weren’t. The findings of the InterAcademy Council investigation also criticized IPCC management, recommending the organization adopt a conflict-of-interest policy. IPCC Chairman Rajendra Pachauri has advised energy and financial companies potentially affected by policies stemming from IPCC findings. He says proceeds go to an energy think tank he heads, and to charity.

New York Post: Op-Ed: Meltdown of the climate ‘consensus’  – If this keeps up, no one’s going to trust any scientists.  The global-warming establishment took a body blow this week, as the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change received a stunning rebuke from a top-notch independent investigation.  For two decades, the IPCC has spearheaded efforts to convince the world’s governments that man-made carbon emissions pose a threat to the global temperature equilibrium — and to civilization itself. IPCC reports, collated from the work of hundreds of climate scientists and bureaucrats, are widely cited as evidence for the urgent need for drastic action to "save the planet."

The Atlantic: Reforming the IPCC – In most media accounts, attention has focused on what appears to be the implicit recommendation that Rajendra Pachauri, the IPCC’s current head, should step down. The committee says the chief (and other key people) should serve one term, and Pachauri is already into his second. I am no fan of Pachauri, and I think it would be far better if he went, but this is less important than repairing other aspects of the panel’s governance and methods.

New Scientist: Fred Pearce: Why It’s Time For Change At The IPCC   -The IPCC has tried hard to preserve the normal rules of scientific discourse and to explain continuing uncertainty, but it has been pushed towards simple sound-bite conclusions. Some of this pressure has come from the desire of many scientists to underline their concerns about the dangers the world faces. Sometimes, in the process, "could happen" has become "will happen", and analysis has veered close to advocacy. Journalists have been willing colluders.

Telegraph UK: Editorial: Flawed Science  – It should have triggered the resignation of Dr Pachauri but he insists he wants to stay on to implement any necessary changes in procedure. Yet his – and the IPCC’s – credibility have been tarnished by this affair. We have argued that a conservative case for preserving the planet’s scarce resources should support much of the action demanded by concerned scientists, regardless of whether the case for man-made global warming can be proved. But it becomes difficult to keep an open mind on such issues if the findings of a purportedly scientific document cannot be trusted.

AP: Report: Climate Science Panel Needs Change At Top   – The independent review of the U.N. climate panel puts new pressure on chairman Rajendra Pachauri, who has been criticized for possible conflicts of interest, but shows no sign of stepping down."It’s hard to see how the United Nations can both follow the advice of this committee and keep Rajendra Pachauri on board as head," said Roger Pielke Jr., a frequent critic of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. The University of Colorado professor praised the review findings as a way of saving the climate panel with "tough love." 

Reuters: UN Climate Panel Urged To Reform, Stick To Science   -The U.N. climate panel should make predictions only when it has solid evidence and should avoid policy advocacy, scientists said in a report on Monday that called for thorough reform of the body. The U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) was widely criticized after admitting its 2007 global warming report wrongly said Himalayan glaciers would vanish by 2035 and that it overstated how much of the Netherlands is below sea level. Such firm forecasts should be made "only when there is sufficient evidence," said a review group supported by the academies of science from the United States, Netherlands, Britain and around 100 other countries.

WSJ: An Unlikely General In Climate-Change War   –Weeks later, IPCC officials were confronted with a factual error in their 2007 report: a projection that Himalayan glaciers would melt by 2035. Climate scientists say it is essentially impossible to project the demise of a glacier by a particular year. Within days, Mr. Pachauri and his top IPCC lieutenants issued a statement expressing "regret" over the claim. But criticism mounted, and by mid-February the IPCC informed governments it would appoint a committee to investigate itself. A few weeks later, Mr. Pachauri asked an outside agency, the InterAcademy Council, to conduct the probe.

###