Fact of the Day: Tuesday, February 21, 2006 Keystone: ESA Can Be Improved Monday’s New York Times editorial, “Soaring Eagles,” argued for “clarification and measured reform” of the current Endangered Species Act (ESA), citing the likely delisting of the Bald Eagle, despite the fact that it would be just the eleventh species to be removed from the list over the past three decades, as proof that the current framework of the law is yielding results – “great news for the 1973 Endangered Species Act.” A group of 23 experts with a combined wealth of experience and distinctly different perspectives brought together as part of the Keystone Center’s ESA Working Group on Habitat, however, believes we can do much better. In May 2005, a bipartisan group of six United States Senators, including Environment and Public Works Committee chairman James Inhofe (R-Okla.), ranking member James Jeffords (I-Vt.), Lincoln Chafee (R-R.I.), Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.), Mike Crapo (R-Idaho) and Blanche Lincoln (D-Ark.), asked the Center to review the current ESA and provide recommendations to improve species protection. Fact: After 30 years of implementation, members of Congress in both chambers and on both sides of the aisle have reached the consensus that the current framework of the ESA is in need of improvement and modernization. To help achieve that end, the Keystone working group recently provided the following recommendations in its cover letter and executive summary responding to the bipartisan request: “The Keystone ESA Working Group on Habitat agrees that the present regulatory approach to habitat protection could be improved to better address the biological needs of species, increase transactional efficiency, and reduce the concerns of regulated parties. Although the group is not able to offer a single, comprehensive consensus based approach or construct, significant headway was made in clarifying some of the central issues and considerations regarding the habitat listed species need to recover. Further, the group concurs on a number of ways to strengthen recovery planning and on programs and procedures that can provide additional landowner incentives that, if instituted, promise to redound to the benefit of listed species.” “In essence, the group believes that it should be possible for you and your Congressional colleagues to take steps that would improve the law’s effectiveness for the species at risk, make government activities more efficient, and reduce the concerns of regulated parties. It is the opinion of the group that addressing all three of these issues—the biological needs of the species, the efficiency of government, and the concerns of those most directly affected by the Act’s provisions—is the only practical way to move forward if the goal is to do so in a more consensus-based manner.” “If an objective is to list fewer and delist more species, then it will be important to look beyond the ESA in isolation toward additional conservation measures by state and local governments, private sector efforts, and other regulatory and non-regulatory programs. The ESA in its current form cannot shoulder this burden alone.” “The group emerged from its first meeting in Keystone with the view that, if it were possible, the benefits of ‘building a better mousetrap’ might yield substantially bolder and more important benefits than ‘tweaks’ to the existing ESA regime.” The Keystone recommendations clearly show the need for ESA modernization. Many on both sides of the aisle in the Senate are serious about improving ESA to allow for better protection and improved recovery. We can certainly do better than a ratio of 10 – or 11 – species recovered for every 1,300 listed.