The environmental left continue to argue through their websites, blogs and sympathetic press that the Clear Skies bill must be opposed because it does not place a mandatory cap on carbon dioxide emissions from coal-fired power plants. They claim that any new law reducing air pollution that does not contain carbon caps is inadequate. Their false charge: carbon emissions are contributing to global warming and pose a significant public health threat. FACT: There is significant disagreement and uncertainty within the scientific community over whether anthropogenic greenhouse gases are contributing to global warming. According to a 2001 report by the National Academy of Sciences, “Because of the large and still uncertain level of natural variability inherent in the climate record and the uncertainties in the time histories of the various forcing agents (and particularly aerosols), a causal linkage between the buildup of greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere and the observed climate changes during the 20th century cannot be unequivocally established. [emphasis added]” The NAS further observed: “The fact that the magnitude of the observed warming is large in comparison to natural variability as simulated in climate models is suggestive of such a linkage, but it does not constitute proof of one because the model simulations could be deficient in natural variability on the decadal to century time scale. [emphasis added]” (NAS, “Climate Change Science: An Analysis of Some Key Questions,” 2001) It is also important to note that carbon dioxide is not a pollutant. It is not harmful to human health—humans exhale it with every breath, and it’s necessary for life on earth. For these reasons, CO2 was not included as a criteria pollutant under the Clean Air Act, and therefore the question of regulating CO2 has no place in the context of the debate over multi-pollutant legislation.