Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov

Today, the National Journal Experts Blog on Energy and Environment asks the question:

Is legislation needed to protect wetlands and solidify the government’s authority under the Clean Water Act? The White House and Democratic leaders are proposing legislation that would replace the term "navigable waters" with "waters of the United States," a move that they say is needed to restore the law’s original intent of protecting wetlands, streams and other waterways. Proponents argue that a 2006 Supreme Court decision too narrowly interpreted the government’s authority, confusing regulators and endangering the nation’s ecologically important wetlands. But Republicans and business groups charge that the Clean Water Act legislation is a power grab that would expand federal control of private property, burden farmers and businesses, and override state authorities. Who’s right?

As a contributor to the blog, Senator Inhofe responded:

Partisan Water Bill Would Harm Rural America

If you live in rural America, look out: Democrats in Congress are targeting you. Rural communities are under siege from a barrage of proposed mandates that threaten the viability of family farms and the rights of property owners. Just consider S. 787, the Clean Water Restoration Act, which has an appealing but misleading title -everyone supports clean water, but not everyone supports perhaps the biggest bureaucratic power grab in a generation, directed right at America’s heartland. The little-talked about bill with huge implications has already passed the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee on a party line-vote. (Also See Inhofe YouTube Video on S. 787.)

Let me convey what this legislation is not about: it is not about clean water and it is not about restoring what was lost. For the last 37 years, the federal government and the states have successfully partnered to improve the quality of our nation’s lakes, streams, and rivers. This bill eliminates that partnership by transferring a state’s authority to protect its waters to the federal government in Washington. Moreover, instead of improving water quality, a goal we all share, the bill would create federal obstacles to local storm water management and would delay development of local water infrastructure.

In effect, the bill would require a federal permit=2 0for just about any activity that could affect virtually any body of water. It would extend the scope and reach of federal water jurisdiction beyond anything that ever existed under the Clean Water Act. The bill would put under federal jurisdiction virtually anywhere water collects, including "mudflats, sandflats, wetlands, sloughs, prairie potholes, wet meadows, playa lakes, (and) natural ponds…" It covers "all impoundments" of water, which would include ditches and private ponds. And it calls for the federal reach t o go out "to the fullest extent that these waters, or activities affecting these waters," can be controlled.

Congress passed the Clean Water Act in 1972, and I support its overarching goal to ensure that navigable waters, and the rivers and lakes feeding into them, are kept clean. But over the years, government regulators stretched the definition of "navigable" beyond all reason. In 2001 and 2006, the Supreme Court stepped in to spell out the statutory and constitutional boundaries of federal jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act. The Court held that Congress meant what it said and upheld limits on federal power under the Act. S. 787 is an attempt to overturn the Supreme Court and radically change the original meaning of the Clean Water Act.

Of course, advocates say the bill is to make sure our waters are protected. They say they just want to clarify things. Make no mistake about it, though. If this bill becomes law, it would allow government regulators to have a say over the use of virtually every body of water, every piece of property having any kind of water on it, and every activity that could affect water. It would take away jurisdiction from state and local authorities who know local needs and conditions better than anybody from Washington. It would affect the property rights of citizens who want to use their land. And, instead of advancing progress made in cleaning our nation’s waterways, it would add more bureaucracy, cost and delay to citizens’ lives.

Consider that just last week, the House Committee on Small Business held a hearing on "Meeting the Needs of Small Busines s and Family Farmers in Regulating the Nations Waters." All five of the witnesses said they were opposed to S. 787. The business and farming communities understand that the Clean Water Restoration Act would create bigger government, more permitting requirements, higher compliance costs and increases in litigation with little or no impact on the nations waters. The witnesses left the Small Business Committee members with a clear message: leave the Clean Water Act the way it is.

In conclusion, I will certainly do everything possible to protect America’s waters from pollution. But I will also do everything in my power to protect our freedoms from those who seek to use environmental law to transfer more and more power from the states back here to Washington.

###