Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
In Case You Missed It…
Wall Street Journal
Republicans: EPA Holding Up More Coal Permits Than Disclosed
By Mark Peters and Siobhan Hughes
NEW YORK (Dow Jones)–Republican lawmakers allege that federal regulators have put on hold at least twice as many Appalachian coal-mining permits as publicly disclosed, shutting off an estimated two billion tons of coal production planned for the region.
A report by Republican members of the U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, also finds actions by the Environmental Protection Agency under the Obama administration are disproportionately affecting small companies in the eastern U.S.
With 190 permits put under scrutiny as of March, more than the 79 publicly identified by the EPA, about 41% of the Appalachian region’s annual coal production is on hold, the report found.
EPA representatives did not return phone calls or emails seeking comment.
The report is an attempt to quantify the effects of tighter water-quality standards on Appalachia. Under the Obama administration, the EPA has taken steps to protect water from the effects of coal mining. The agency has cast its actions largely as an effort to limit so-called mountaintop-removal mining. The process, primarily used in Kentucky and West Virginia, involves blasting the tops off mountains to access the coal beneath.
But according to the report, only 19 of the 190 permits that are currently held up involve mountaintop-removal coal mining. The remaining 171 permits are being sought for traditional surface mines, underground mines and coal processing facilities. The report concluded the Obama administration’s effort to cast its initiative as an effort to regulate mountaintop-removal mining is "highly misleading."
According to the report, the EPA as of early March hadn’t decided on 190 applications for water-quality permits that mining companies need to dump leftover rock and dirt into nearby valleys. The materials can bury streams and increase the mineral and metal levels, damaging fish and plant life. Since May 2009, shortly after the EPA began scrutinizing mountaintop-removal mining permits, the EPA issued 45 permits. The report didn’t account for permits companies withdrew, and some of the 190 permits cited may have been withdrawn.
Permit approval is essential to maintain production levels in Central Appalachia, where surface mines supply coal used by power plants. The committee report estimates the requested permits–which Republican staffers say usually cover four to five years of production–represent about two billion tons of total, planned production. Total production for the Appalachian region was 340 million tons last year.
Curbing coal production also translates into a loss of coal-mining jobs, the report found.
"If the EPA continues to block the permits noted above, roughly one out of every four coal-mining jobs in the Appalachian region could be lost," the report said. It estimates that the 190 coal-mining operations placed on hold by the EPA would support 14,814 jobs.
Democratic members of the Senate committee did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The committee found that a majority of the permit applications awaiting approval were filed by small mining companies. Of the 190 pending permit applications, 154 were filed by companies with 500 or fewer employees. Permit challenges and increased volatility of coal prices among other factors are prompting smaller operators to exit the business, driving increased industry consolidation.
The EPA last month announced it would tightened water-quality standards, setting limits on the electrical conductivity, or salinity, of streams, which can be impacted by mining. The agency said last year it was conducting an enhanced review of 79 permit application. About 35% of those applications have been withdrawn, while the EPA has approved four.
###