Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
Inhofe EPW News Roundup
"The science linking warming and malaria risk was always iffy, a reality reflected in the relevant sections of the 2007 reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change"
NYT: Cooling Fear of a Malaria Surge from Warming (05/20/10) – As various arguments for action on global warming have failed to blunt growth in emissions in recent years, environmental groups and international agencies have sometimes tried to turn the focus to diseases that could pose a growing threat in a warming world – with malaria being a frequent talking point. It shouldn’t be. The science linking warming and malaria risk was always iffy, a reality reflected in the relevant sections of the 2007 reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Modeling studies cited there had variegated results, and many focused only on the potential expansion of the geographical range or mosquito-friendly seasons, while not considering how shifting patterns of health care and human behavior might render such changes moot.
Roger Pielke Jr.: Last Word on Malaria? (05/20/10) – The Nature News article ends on a predictable note, quoting a researcher who says: "This does not diminish the importance of climate change at all."I agree with this statement of course, because I never thought addressing malaria was a key justification for dealing with climate change in the first place. However the systematic overselling of malaria and climate change in the past requires some attention, and it is not the only context in which these dynamics have occurred — disasters and climate change provides another obvious example. Readers from last summer may remember that I took issue with the Global Humanitarian Forum’s absurd estimate of more than 300,000 deaths per year due to human-caused climate change, mainly due to diseases and including malaria. The new study underscores my critique.
BBC News: Climate change is ‘distraction’ on malaria spread (05/20/10) – Research leader Peter Gething from Oxford University described the climate link as an "unwelcome distraction" from the main issues of tackling malaria. The paper, by scientists in the UK, US and Kenya, is published in Nature. "We were looking to quantify something that perhaps we already knew with regard to the interaction of climate and malaria," Dr Gething told BBC News. "A lot of the studies proposing there would be a dramatic increase in a warmer world have been met with guarded criticism, and often what’s been said about them surpasses what the actual science indicates. "So this redresses the balance a bit."
The Economist : Don’t sweat it (05/19/10) – ONE of the obvious problems with predicting the future effects of climate change is that they haven’t happened. This makes climate studies highly dependent on models, which invariably and unavoidably make simplifying assumptions. This means that using their results to say anything of practical import needs care and caveats, both of which can often be in short supply, or stripped out to make a point. However, it is now ever more possible for studies of climate change to look at the past, not the future. The 20th century saw a fair amount of warming, and it is sometimes possible to compare what this warming did and didn’t do with what future warming might or might not do. This is what a paper published in Nature this week does in an attempt to re-examine, and perhaps close down, long-running debates about malaria and climate change.
Nature: Malaria may not rise as world warms (05/19/10) – Yet when epidemiologists Peter Gething and Simon Hay of the Malaria Atlas Project at the University of Oxford, UK, and their colleagues compiled data on the incidence of malaria in 1900 and 2007 (see page 342), they found the opposite: despite rising temperatures during the twentieth century, malaria has lost ground. According to the models the researchers used to tease out the factors affecting the incidence of malaria, the impact of public-health measures such as improved medications, widespread insecticide use and bed nets have overwhelmed the influence of climate change. "Malaria is still a huge problem," says Gething. "But climate change per se is not something that should be central to the discussion. The risks have been overstated."
Science Magazine : Malaria Probably Won’t Get Worse With Warming Temperatures (05/20/10) – A prominent group of malaria researchers has questioned that link. Several years ago, they formed a collaboration called the Malaria Atlas Project (MAP). Their first effort was to create a current-day world map of malaria endemicity-that is, a map of the degree and extent of risk for the disease. In a more recent project, MAP acquired similar data for malaria transmission during about 1900, compiled in a Russian study published in the 1960s. Then, they compared the centurywide spread for changes (see illustration). The result, they report in today’s issue of Nature, is that malaria’s reach has actually contracted dramatically, despite the fact that temperatures rose on average about 0.6?C during the 20th century. The most likely factors in that contraction are vector-control measures such as insecticide spraying and bed nets, as well as effective antimalarial drugs.
Times India: Control, not climate change, key to malaria (05/20/10) – A study published today casts doubt on the widely held notion that warming global temperatures will lead to a future intensification of malaria and an expansion of its global range. The research, conducted by the Malaria Atlas Project (MAP), a multinational team including Oxford University researchers, suggests that current interventions could have a far more dramatic – and positive – effect on reducing the spread of malaria than any negative effects caused by climate change. he study has been published in the journal Nature , an Oxford University release said.
Register UK: Climate change ‘no excuse’ for failure to beat malaria (05/20/10) – However a team of disease specialists based at Oxford University, the University of Florida and in Kenya have analysed the long battle between humanity and malaria – much of which has occurred against a background of increased temperatures in the generally accepted global records. They say there is no cause for concern. "The globe warmed over the past century, but the range of malaria contracted substantially," says Andy Tatem of Florida uni. "Warming isn’t the only factor that affects malaria."
American: Blog: Climate Change Not a Significant Cause of Malaria (05/20/10) – The highly prestigious journal Nature has just published a major report showing that climate change is not a significant cause of malaria-in apparent opposition to numerous alarmists who have been claiming that malaria growth has been caused by climate change. The Economist has picked up on it as well.Paul Reiter, who is quoted in the Nature article, and I testified on the topic and wrote an article for the Wall Street Journal in April 2008, which make some of the same points. What is most interesting is the process by which this study came about-or at least why some of the authors probably wanted to write it. It is a classic case of the emperor being stark naked.
New Scientist: Malaria in retreat despite warmer climate (05/19/10) – transmission has also fallen almost everywhere. This indicates that the incidence of malaria may not rise as a result of climate change. "The things acting to reduce malaria spread, like improved healthcare and disease control, are much more powerful than the weak effect of warming," Gething says. That doesn’t mean health authorities can rest on their laurels. Kevin Lafferty, an ecologist at the US Geological Survey, says the positive global picture hides shifting regional ones. Malaria is expected to move to different areas, even as its overall range decreases, he says.
###