Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov
EPW POLICY BEAT: OUT OF
AFRICA
With Old Man
Winter knocking again, EPW Policy Beat is packing up and heading to shelter. But before we leave town, we pause to
wonder: Will global warming slash crop production in North Africa by 50 percent
by 2020? The IPCC once thought so,
but now it’s thinking again. The
question is: Will EPA?
As London’s Sunday Times reported on February 7, Professor Chris Field, "the new lead author of the IPCC’s climate impacts
team," said "he could find nothing in the [IPCC’s Fourth Assessment] report to
support" the North Africa crop claim. "The revelation," the Times noted, "follows the IPCC’s
retraction of a claim that the Himalayan glaciers might all melt by 2035,
dubbed ‘Glaciergate’ by commentators."
As we noted in a recent blogpost, the
Himalayan claim was based not a peer-reviewed study, but on a 1999 magazine
article, which itself was based on a speculative conversation with an Indian
scientist. The more interesting
tidbit from our standpoint was the fact that EPA’s Technical Support Document
(TSD), the scientific basis of EPA’s endangerment finding for greenhouse gases,
uses the Himalayan example as evidence cited by the IPCC of "regional impacts"
caused by global warming. On page 162, EPA states: "Glacier melt in the Himalayas is projected to increase
flooding and rock avalanches from destabilized slopes and to affect water
resources within the next two to three decades. This will be followed by
decreased river flows as the glaciers recede."
As we turned back to the TSD to see
whether EPA mentioned the Africa claim, we found this, also on page 162, in a
box titled "Africa": "The area suitable for agriculture, the length of growing
seasons, and yield potential, particularly along the margins of semi-arid and
arid areas, are expected to decrease. This would further adversely affect food
security and exacerbate malnutrition in the continent. In some countries, yields from rain-fed agriculture could be reduced by
up to 50% by 2020." [Emphasis added]
We trust EPA will initiate the proper
administrative procedures to correct the TSD, and to ensure that other sections
that rely on the IPCC are cross-checked for errors and other questionable
references using non peer-reviewed research.
###