Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov
"Democrats Deeply Split" – Boxer Pushes Ahead with "Toxic" Maneuver – "Major Climate Bill will be Pushed Into 2010"
Inhofe EPW News Roudup
WashPost: Climate bill faces hurdles in Senate – DEMOCRATS DEEPLY SPLIT (November 2, 2009) – The climate-change bill that has been moving slowly through the Senate will face a stark political reality when it emerges for committee debate on Tuesday: With Democrats deeply divided on the issue, unless some Republican lawmakers risk the backlash for signing on to the legislation, there is almost no hope for passage. Like the measure adopted by the House, the legislation favors a cap-and-trade system that would issue permits for greenhouse gas emissions, gradually lower the amount of emissions allowed, and let companies buy and sell permits to meet their needs — all without adding to the federal deficit, according to projections. But key Republicans are making their opposition clear, even as Sen. John F. Kerry (D-Mass.) has enlisted Sen. Lindsey O. Graham (S.C.) as his most visible GOP ally in gathering support for the bill. Sen. George V. Voinovich (Ohio), a member of the Environment and Public Works Committee who was initially seen as one of the few Republicans who might consider backing the majority, is helping lead the opposition. "Why are we trying to jam down this legislation now?" he asked during a hearing last week. "Wouldn’t it be smarter to take our time and do it right?" He wrote Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa P. Jackson twice this summer to ask for a more detailed economic analysis of the House-passed climate legislation, and he has joined the other six Republicans on the committee in boycotting the climate bill’s markup, scheduled for Tuesday. The measure has deeply divided Democrats. With states in the Midwest, South and Rocky Mountain West dependent on fossil fuels for energy, many senators are worried about the legislation’s impact on industry and consumers. "I think at the end of the day, the people who turn the switch on at home will be disadvantaged," Sen. Ben Nelson (D-Neb.) told CNBC on Friday, explaining why he did not think the bill Kerry had sponsored along with Environment and Public Works Chairman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) could pass.
E&E News Boxer pushes ahead with "Toxic" Maneuver (11/02/2009) – Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) plans to proceed under a rarely used interpretation of the committee’s rules that allows her to start and finish the markup so long as a majority of the panel’s members are present, rather than longstanding precedent requiring two minority members to be in attendance, according to sources on and off Capitol Hill. Boxer’s justification for the move is that Republicans are trying to stall on a climate bill that they have no intention of voting for anyway. And with a 12-7 majority favoring Democrats, she does not need their support to report the bill favorably. "We believe that there’s no reason for them to stay away," Boxer told reporters last week. "It’d be remarkably bad faith if they did."…Andrew Wheeler, a former EPW Committee Republican staff director, agreed that Boxer has the power to proceed with the markup absent Republicans’ participation, though he warned against the precedent she could create. "The loophole is she’s the one who decides the rules are being followed," he said. "There’s no appeal to any higher authority. There’s no Senate Parliamentarian. … There’s no police."…But some question whether Boxer’s efforts now could foretell trouble as Kerry tries to work with moderate Democrats and Republicans. A former Senate Democratic staffer warned that an end-run around the committee’s process may not be the best strategy when appealing to swing-vote senators. "That product is totally toxic," the former staffer said. "It’s basically worthless." Wheeler, the former EPW Republican staff director, said that Boxer’s move to bypass longstanding rules could hurt the Democrats’ chances on the floor for winning the votes of committee members like Voinovich and Alexander, as well as GOP moderates off the committee like Sens. Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe of Maine, and Judd Gregg of New Hampshire. "They all believe in the process and minority rights," Wheeler said. "The fastest way to ensure that no Republican ever supports this is to do something like that."
Politico: Efforts Lead by "two most moderate Republicans, Sens. George Voinovich of Ohio and Lamar Alexander of Tennessee" – The boycott, led by the committee’s two most moderate Republicans, Sens. George Voinovich of Ohio and Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, illustrates the difficulty for Democrats in getting significant bipartisan backing for their climate bill – even among GOP lawmakers who support taking action to combat climate change."I’m willing to work with the people on the other side of the aisle. But if you jam this thing through here, it’s not going to be good," Voinovich said on Thursday. The Obama administration has so far been unable to attract significant Republican backing for major initiatives like health care and the economic stimulus package. On climate, the two parties are battling over a handful of Republicans who might support a bill, including Sens. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, Judd Gregg of New Hampshire, Dick Lugar of Indiana and Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe of Maine. Republican leaders see cap and trade as an issue that could severely hurt Democratic chances in the midterm elections, and they’re pressuring their members to vote against the bill to keep their caucus as united as possible. Democrats may need Republican votes to pass a bill to offset possible losses within their own party. Prominent moderate Democrats such as Sens. Max Baucus of Montana, Blanche Lincoln of Arkansas and Byron Dorgan of North Dakota have raised a long list of concerns about the bill. And at least some Democratic supporters expect to lose the votes of Sens. Ben Nelson of Nebraska and Mary Landrieu of Louisiana. Nelson said on Friday that a cap-and-trade bill could not pass the Senate this Congress.
WSJ: Republicans Plan To Block US Climate Vote This Week (11/01/09) – WASHINGTON (Dow Jones)–Republicans plan to block a vote this week on climate legislation, saying they need a complete economic analysis of a measure that would reshape the U.S. economy. Senate Environment and Public Works Committee Chairman Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., has scheduled a Tuesday meeting to consider the measure, which would impose mandatory reductions in greenhouse-gas emissions. Republicans say that they won’t show up, denying Democrats the quorum they need to proceed."We are not opposed to a markup, only on holding one before we have a full economic analysis," said Matt Dempsey, a spokesman for the Republicans on the panel, in an email late Saturday…Last week, EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson testified that the costs of the legislation would be modest compared with the benefits. But she also said that the EPA hadn’t completed a full economic analysis, a process that she said would take several more weeks.
Reuters: Republicans move to delay climate bill progress (11/01/09) – Republicans on the environment committee say the climate-change bill would cause significant job losses by encouraging manufacturers to relocate more of their plants in countries that do not have as strict carbon controls.They also say it would significantly boost consumer prices as companies are forced to use more expensive alternative fuels — a claim that has not been backed up by some independent analysis or by a preliminary EPA analysis. "Republicans are insisting on a full EPA analysis before a mark up. We are not opposed to a mark up, only on holding one this rushed," said a statement by committee Republicans. Full details of the Democratic bill were unveiled only a week ago.
The Hill: Ben Nelson: Cap-and-trade Will Not Pass This Congress – A cap-and-trade bill to address climate change cannot pass the Congress this session, Sen. Ben Nelson (D-Neb.) claimed Friday. Nelson, a centrist Democrat whose vote is key to leaders wielding its 60-vote majority in the Senate, said he and his constituents had not been sold on the cap-and-trade system proposed in House and Senate bills to address global warming. "No," Nelson simply responded when asked if those cap-and-trade bills can pass through this Congress during an interview on CNBC. "I haven’t been able to sell that argument to my farmers, and I don’t think they’re going to buy it from anybody else," Nelson said. "I think at the end of the day, the people who turn the switch on at home will be disadvantaged."
E&ENEWS: "Major climate bill will be pushed into 2010" – Senate Commerce Chairman Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.) may not mark up his panel’s portions of the Senate climate bill this year, he said yesterday. Although he confirmed plans to hold a markup eventually, Rockefeller’s comments are another sign that with dwindling days left this year and health care legislation not yet on the floor, a major climate bill will be pushed into 2010. "I am a conferee on health. If you can tell me how long we will be negotiating with the House, then I can give you a better answer to your question," he said when asked whether a Commerce Committee markup would occur this year. "I think it is going to be a long time."