Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In the News… 

E&E News  

Chesapeake Bay: N.Y. lawmakers lash out at ‘drastic,’ ‘unfair’ EPA cleanup plan

(10/15/2010)

Paul Quinlan, E&E reporter

Link to Article

New York’s congressional delegates say U.S. EPA’s sweeping Chesapeake Bay cleanup plan is inherently unfair to their state and should make greater demands of their downstream neighbors.

Most of the pollution in the sprawling watershed, which includes parts of six states and the District of Columbia, is generated closer to the bay, the lawmakers say in a letter sent Wednesday to EPA.

Democratic Sens. Charles Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand and seven House lawmakers signed the letter, which said EPA’s ambitious bay plan, which is set to take effect at the end of the year, contains "drastic" and "unattainable" pollution-reduction requirements that will "jeopardize the economic well-being of communities within New York’s Bay Watershed and the agricultural industry on which the entire state relies."

"This is simply unfair and needs to change," Gillibrand said in a statement. She said the proposed rules "punish New York State."

EPA’s proposed state-by-state "pollution diets" set strict limits on nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment flowing into the bay. The phased plan requires states to have 60 percent of the controls in place needed to meet pollution reduction goals by 2017 and to have 100 percent in place by 2025.

Along with New York and the District of Columbia, the bay states are Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Delaware and West Virginia.

The bay cleanup has struggled in part because of interstate disputes over responsibility for pollution and habitat damage and how to divide the costs of cleaning up stormwater, sewage, and farm and development wastes.

"The New York delegation came out first," said Doug Siglin, lobbyist for the nonprofit Chesapeake Bay Foundation. "We expect Maryland elected officials, Virginia elected officials, Pennsylvania elected officials to weigh in. The timing of this thing during election season just sort of has a certain inevitability."

New York has about 10 percent of the bay watershed and includes the headwaters of the Susquehanna and Chemung river systems. The New York delegation argues that the EPA plan requires steeper pollution reductions in the state, despite "significant improvements in water quality since the 1980s."

The delegation calls for EPA to resurrect a principle within the plan that it said was struck from earlier documents: "States that benefit the most from the Chesapeake Bay recovery must do more."

"Under the draft EPA proposal, New York State is bearing the brunt of the regulation and none of the benefits of a clean Chesapeake Bay," Gillibrand wrote.

The delegates complain that meeting those goals will cost state and local taxpayers "several billion dollars."

"In tough economic times like these, we need to do everything we can to create jobs, not drive them away," Schumer said.

EPA spokesman David Sternberg said the agency "greatly appreciates" the comments and concerns of the New York delegation. He added that EPA would continue to work closely with colleagues to produce a "cost effective strategy to reduce water pollution for the benefit of all communities."

"Our hope is that by working together, New York will submit a revised strategy to EPA at the end of November that achieves these goals," Sternberg said.

###