Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
EPW POLICY BEAT: BROKEN WINDOWS AND GREEN JOBS
With all of the talk these days about green jobs—or, more precisely, the Democrats’ version of taxpayer subsidized green jobs—EPW Policy Beat wondered whether they will usher in a “clean energy future.” They won’t. We came to this conclusion after reading Henry Hazlitt’s classic book, “Economics in One Lesson.”
In the book, Hazlitt takes up Bastiat’s theory of the broken window. Hazlitt wrote about a “hoodlum” who breaks a baker’s window. A crowd gathers, and, after some “philosophic reflection,” concludes that the baker’s misfortune has a bright side: the broken window creates business for the glazier, who will spend his new-found $250 with “other merchants,” who then will spend it with other merchants, ad infinitum. The smashed window, then, is a job creator, and the hoodlum is “a public benefactor.”
Now it’s true that the broken window created jobs, but, as Hazlitt notes, one cannot ignore that which is unseen: the baker, out $250, cannot buy a suit “or some equivalent need or luxury.” Here’s how Hazlitt explained it: “The glazier’s gain of business, in short, is merely the tailor’s loss of business. No new ‘employment’ has been added. The people in the crowd were thinking only of two parties to the transaction, the baker and the glazier. They had forgotten the potential third party involved, the tailor. They forgot him precisely because he will not now enter the scene. They will see the new window in the next day or two. They will never see the extra suit, precisely because it will never be made. They see only what is immediately visible to the eye.”
Shift from the baker to the American economy. Through cap-and-trade, Democrats break coal and manufacturing, raise the price of fossil fuels, and get wind and solar to fill the gaps. Green jobs arise but millions of other jobs are destroyed. Somehow, Democrats believe, this will revitalize American economy. Yet the broken window theory demonstrates that the economy can’t grow if one industry prospers at the expense of others.
This undeniable fact was addressed in a recent analysis by CRA International of the Waxman-Markey bill, commissioned the National Black Chamber of Commerce. CRA wrote about the net job loss from Waxman-Markey and taxpayer subsidized green jobs: “However, any calculation of jobs created in these activities is incomplete if not supplemented with a calculation of the reduced employment in other industries and the decline in the average salary that would result from the associated higher energy costs and lower overall productivity in the economy. This study finds that even after accounting for green jobs, there is a substantial and long-term net reduction in total labor earnings and employment. This is the unintended but predictable consequence of investing to create a “green energy future.”
A green energy future indeed. We recommend Al Gore read Bastiat, who summed up the fallacy of Democrats’ green jobs thus: “But if, by way of deduction, you conclude, as happens only too often, that it is good to break windows, that it helps to circulate money, that it results in encouraging industry in general, I am obliged to cry out: That will never do! Your theory stops at what is seen. It does not take account of what is not seen.”
###