Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It… 

The Oklahoman

Editorial: ‘New’ climate bill still bad idea for economy

Published May 18, 2010

Link to Editorial

Sens. John Kerry and Joseph Lieberman unveiled a modified version of a bill first introduced last year that quickly stalled as critics rightly depicted it as a tax on virtually the entire economy.

Now it’s back, its authors hoping time, new terminology and ginned-up urgency will resuscitate an economy-stifling, tax-increasing, job-killing piece of legislation. "It’s the same old cap-and-trade scheme that the Senate has defeated three times since 2003," said Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Tulsa. "It has a strong resemblance to the disastrous (House) bill. Only now, along with paying skyrocketing electricity prices, consumers will pay a gas tax." More on that presently.

Kerry and Lieberman now refer to "pollution reduction and investment" legislation instead of "cap and trade." The latter was too easily morphed into "cap and tax" by opponents. By whatever name, it’s a stew of subsidies, incentives and rebates to lure support from various quarters while promising not to hit regular Americans’ wallets.

The campaign to pass Kerry-Lieberman is straight from the Obamacare playbook.

Recall that Obamacare began as "health care reform" before becoming "health insurance reform" after the White House discovered that demonizing insurance companies generated political traction.

Recall, too, that Obamacare stayed alive with a buffet of subsidies, payoffs and barely veiled bribes to special interests, even as President Obama promised most Americans wouldn’t bear the costs.

This 987-page bill seeks carbon reductions from separate sectors of the economy instead of imposing the nationwide limit under the House version. Nonetheless, the bill still guns for the same goal: reducing carbon dioxide emissions by 17 percent from 2005 levels by 2020 and by 83 percent by 2050.

"This is going to change the face of American energy," Kerry, D-Mass., said last week, flanked by CEOs of companies that make thermostats and energy-saving products. (They should check with Big Pharma to see how signing on to Obamacare has worked out for them.)

As for the bill’s gasoline tax, Kerry bristled when asked about it. By now Americans should know the stronger the denial, the tighter they should grip their pocketbooks.

Producers and importers of gasoline and jet fuel would be segregated from the bill’s other carbon-permit auctions, but it’s just flim-flammery to distract from the immutable economic fact that increased costs will be borne by consumers.

Months ago, cap and trade was dead on arrival in the Senate. They’ve tightened some of the bolts and rearranged the furniture, but it’s still the same bad bill it was – one that should die a second, permanent, death.

###