Posted by David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

In the News…

EPA Haze Plan Costly for Oklahoma

Oklahoman: EPA Plan to Clean Air Could Cost Oklahoma Residents  – The result could be a hefty increase in electric rates if utilities are forced to install expensive scrubbers to their oldest power plants. An industrial consumers group in November estimated Oklahoma Gas and Electric Co. customers could see their rates rise more than 15 percent. The EPA on Monday proposed its own plan to reduce emissions of sulfur dioxide by about 95 percent over the next three years at three coal-fired power plants in Oklahoma. The plants have helped power the state since the late 1970s. …OG&E has estimated installing scrubbers at its coal plants in Red Rock and Muskogee could cost as much as $1.5 billion, plus another $150 million a year for operations and maintenance. PSO officials estimated it would cost about $800 million for scrubbers at its plant northeast of Tulsa. Bud Ground, the company’s manager of governmental and environmental affairs, said the EPA’s timetable for cutting emissions is "unreasonable." Ground said further study of the EPA’s 122-page proposal will help state officials decide how to proceed.  "We think they’re wrong, but we don’t know just yet what their assumptions were to get to that point," he said.  Attorney General Scott Pruitt said he is willing to litigate the issue, if necessary.  "Let the EPA be put on notice, as attorney general, I plan to do all that I can to protect and preserve the state’s authority and responsibility under the Clean Air Act to craft and implement solutions for our state," Pruitt said.  Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Tulsa, condemned the EPA plan on Monday, as well.  "State officials in Oklahoma did the right thing: They worked with state utilities to devise a plan that will continue progress in cleaning the air while ensuring affordable, reliable electricity for consumers," Inhofe said. "But that was too much for the Obama EPA, which rejected the Oklahoma-led plan in favor of their preferred scheme to put Washington bureaucrats in charge and, ultimately, to make fossil-fuel-based electricity more expensive for consumers."

Tulsa World: Oklahoma Panel Says EPA "Haze" Plan too Costly   – The cost burden could raise utility customers’ bills by 10 percent to 12 percent, according to some estimates.  "Oklahoma had a plan in place that would have met the federal mandates without sudden price shock," Commission Vice Chairman Jeff Cloud said in a statement. "As an entity charged with ensuring affordable and reliable utility service to Oklahoma, the commission will work with all the stakeholders and others in government against such misguided federal requirements."  … The proposal, which was crafted by the state Department of Environmental Quality with the input of AEP-PSO and Oklahoma Gas & Electric, would reach the same reductions in emissions but over a longer time frame, state officials say.  "I am very disappointed the EPA failed to work with Oklahoma and disregarded the devastating impact the EPA’s plan would have on Oklahoma electricity customers," Commission Chairman Dana Murphy said. "Now that EPA has released its proposed mandate, we need to move quickly to protect Oklahomans’ pocketbooks."  U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Okla., has criticized the EPA mandate, describing it as a "regulatory power grab."  The EPA’s plan calls for pollution reductions at AEP-PSO’s coal-fired units in Oologah and OG&E coal-fired plants in Muskogee and Noble County.  "These three power plants emit greater than one-third of all the (sulfur dioxide) from the hundreds of industrial and utility sources in Oklahoma,” the EPA stated.  Scrubbers cost $350 million each, while nitrogen oxide controls would add at least $100 million more at the Oologah facility, AEP-PSO officials said.

Journal Record: Lawmaker, Utilities Decry EPA Plan  – OKLAHOMA CITY The Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality submitted an air quality plan to the EPA last year that would have asked utility companies to reduce emissions more gradually over a longer period of time, but the federal agency rejected most of that plan. "We believed that the State Implementation Plan provided the best opportunity to meet the long-term goal of the regional haze provisions of the Clean Air Act while mitigating its impacts on economic growth," said Steve Thompson, executive director of the Department of Environmental Quality. "We are disappointed that it has been rejected." U.S. Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla., ranking member of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, issued a statement on Monday vowing to fight the new EPA plan. "State officials in Oklahoma did the right thing: They worked with state utilities to devise a plan that will continue progress in cleaning the air while ensuring affordable, reliable electricity for consumers," Inhofe said. "But that was too much for the Obama EPA, which rejected the Oklahoma-led plan in favor of their preferred scheme to put Washington bureaucrats in charge and, ultimately, to make fossil-fuel-based electricity more expensive for consumers." The EPA will hold a public hearing on the plan from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. and 7 p.m. to 9 p.m. April 13 in meeting rooms H and I at the Metro Technology Centers, Springlake Campus business conference center, 1900 Springlake Dr.

###